← Topical Vault

Analysis and communication Revision notes

Syllabus section 3.5 · about 28 minutes · written for the 9706 syllabus · last checked 2026-11-18

At AS Level you calculated profitability, liquidity and efficiency ratios. At A Level you add solvency and investment ratios for limited companies, and — more importantly — you must use all the ratios together to explain performance, link one ratio to another, and give justified advice to a stakeholder (a shareholder, a lender, the directors). Paper 3 questions typically ask for 4–14 marks of calculations, then an 8–10 mark discussion.

You must use the formulas in the syllabus appendix — a different version of a formula gets no credit (though your answer is then carried forward). Use year-end figures unless the question says to use averages, and give answers to the number of decimal places asked for.

The A Level ratios

RatioFormula (syllabus)What it shows
Working capital cycle (days)Trade receivables turnover (days) + inventory turnover (days) − trade payables turnover (days)How long cash is tied up between paying suppliers and collecting from customers. Shorter is better.
Net working assets to revenue (%)Net working assets ÷ revenue × 100, where net working assets = inventories + trade receivables − trade payablesHow much working capital is needed for each $1 of sales. Lower means more efficient use of working capital.
Interest cover (times)Profit from operations ÷ interest payableHow many times profit covers the interest; the safety margin for lenders.
Gearing (%)Non-current liabilities ÷ (issued ordinary share capital + all reserves + non-current liabilities) × 100The proportion of long-term finance from borrowing. Over about 50% is usually seen as highly geared (risky).
Earnings per shareProfit for the year ÷ number of issued ordinary sharesProfit earned for each share.
Price/earnings (P/E)Market price per share ÷ earnings per shareHow many years of current earnings investors will pay for a share — market confidence in future growth.
Dividend per shareAnnual ordinary dividend ÷ number of issued ordinary shares, where annual dividend = interim dividend paid + final dividend proposedCash return per share.
Dividend yield (%)Dividend per share ÷ market price per share (× 100)The cash return on the share’s current price — compare with interest rates.
Dividend cover (times)Profit for the year available to pay ordinary dividend ÷ annual ordinary dividendHow safe the dividend is, and how much profit is retained.

The components of the working capital cycle are the AS efficiency ratios: inventory turnover = average inventory ÷ cost of sales × 365; trade receivables turnover = trade receivables ÷ credit sales × 365; trade payables turnover = trade payables ÷ credit purchases × 365. Return on capital employed (profit from operations ÷ capital employed × 100, where capital employed = issued shares + reserves + non-current liabilities) is also often needed.

The number of shares is share capital ÷ nominal value: $300,000 of $0.50 shares is 600,000 shares. Dividend per share uses the interim paid plus the final proposed for that year — not the dividends paid during the year shown in the SOCE.

Fully worked example

Willow plc expanded in 2025, financed by issuing $150,000 of debentures. All sales and purchases are on credit. Ordinary share capital is $300,000 in $0.50 shares in both years.

Willow plc2024 $2025 $
Revenue800 000960 000
Cost of sales520 000648 000
Purchases530 000660 000
Profit from operations120 000132 000
Interest payable8 00020 000
Tax22 00022 400
Profit for the year90 00089 600
Inventory at start of year60 00070 000
Inventory at end of year70 000110 000
Trade receivables88 000128 000
Trade payables58 00061 000
Ordinary share capital300 000300 000
Reserves260 000301 600
Non-current liabilities (debentures)100 000250 000
Interim dividend paid18 00018 000
Final dividend proposed30 00024 000
Market price per share at year end$1.80$1.40

Workings for 2025 (2024 is done the same way):

  • Inventory turnover = (70,000 + 110,000) ÷ 2 ÷ 648,000 × 365 = 50.69 → 51 days. Receivables = 128,000 ÷ 960,000 × 365 = 48.67 → 49 days. Payables = 61,000 ÷ 660,000 × 365 = 33.73 → 34 days. Working capital cycle = 51 + 49 − 34 = 66 days.
  • Net working assets = 110,000 + 128,000 − 61,000 = 177,000; ÷ 960,000 × 100 = 18.44%.
  • Interest cover = 132,000 ÷ 20,000 = 6.60 times.
  • Gearing = 250,000 ÷ (300,000 + 301,600 + 250,000) × 100 = 29.36%.
  • Shares = 300,000 ÷ $0.50 = 600,000. EPS = 89,600 ÷ 600,000 = $0.1493 (14.93 cents). P/E = 1.40 ÷ 0.1493 = 9.38.
  • Annual dividend = 18,000 + 24,000 = 42,000. DPS = 42,000 ÷ 600,000 = $0.07. Dividend yield = 0.07 ÷ 1.40 × 100 = 5.00%. Dividend cover = 89,600 ÷ 42,000 = 2.13 times.

Reserves 2025 = 260,000 + profit 89,600 − dividends paid in 2025 (2024 final 30,000 + 2025 interim 18,000) = $301,600.

Willow plc: ratios20242025
Inventory turnover (days)4651
Trade receivables turnover (days)4049
Trade payables turnover (days)4034
Working capital cycle (days)4666
Net working assets to revenue12.50%18.44%
Interest cover (times)15.006.60
Gearing15.15%29.36%
Return on capital employed18.18%15.50%
Earnings per share (cents)15.0014.93
Price/earnings12.009.38
Dividend per share ($)0.080.07
Dividend yield4.44%5.00%
Dividend cover (times)1.882.13

Interpreting the results — and how they link

  • Growth, but at a cost. Revenue rose 20% and profit from operations 10%, but the new debentures raised interest from $8,000 to $20,000, so profit for the year fell slightly and EPS fell from 15.00 to 14.93 cents. ROCE fell from 18.18% to 15.50%: the extra capital has not yet earned as much as the old.
  • Higher financial risk. Gearing nearly doubled (15.15% → 29.36%) and interest cover fell from 15.00 to 6.60 times. These two always move together: more borrowing means more interest. Both are still safe levels, but lenders would watch the trend.
  • Working capital management worsened. The cycle lengthened from 46 to 66 days: customers are taking 9 days longer to pay (perhaps longer credit was offered to win the extra sales), more inventory is held, and suppliers are being paid 6 days faster. Net working assets to revenue rose from 12.50% to 18.44% — more cash is tied up for every $1 of sales, which puts pressure on liquidity.
  • The market’s view. The share price fell from $1.80 to $1.40, so the P/E fell from 12.00 to 9.38 — investors are less confident about future growth, perhaps because of the higher risk and flat EPS.
  • Dividends. The dividend was cut from $0.08 to $0.07, so dividend cover rose to 2.13 times (more profit retained, perhaps to support the expansion). Dividend yield rose to 5.00% only because the share price fell further than the dividend — not a sign of good performance.

Recommendations

  • To improve the working capital cycle: tighten credit control (credit checks, chasing overdue accounts, cash discounts for early payment), reduce inventory (better forecasting, just-in-time ordering), and negotiate longer credit from suppliers without losing discounts or goodwill.
  • To an investor seeking income: the 5.00% yield is attractive, but the dividend has just been cut and EPS is flat — a cautious “hold”. To an investor seeking growth: the expansion has raised revenue, and the low P/E may mean the shares are cheap if profits from the new investment come through. To a lender: interest is still covered 6.6 times and gearing is below 30%, so a further loan is possible, but the lengthening cycle needs watching.

Financing decisions: loan or shares?

Questions often ask you to compare raising money by borrowing or by issuing shares, using EPS, gearing and interest cover. Work out each ratio under each option, then weigh them.

Willow plc plans to raise $200,000 to invest in new non-current assets, which should increase profit from operations by 15% (to $151,800). Option 1: a 10% long-term loan. Option 2: issue 160,000 ordinary shares at $1.25. Tax is 20% of profit before tax. Use 2025 capital as the starting point.

Effect of each optionOption 1: loanOption 2: shares
Profit from operations151 800151 800
Interest (20,000 existing + 20,000 new loan interest for option 1)(40 000)(20 000)
Profit before tax111 800131 800
Tax (20%)(22 360)(26 360)
Profit for the year89 440105 440
Number of shares600 000760 000
Earnings per share (cents)14.9113.87
Gearing (%)42.7923.77
Interest cover (times)3.807.59

Gearing for option 1 = (250,000 + 200,000) ÷ (851,600 + 200,000); for option 2 = 250,000 ÷ (851,600 + 200,000).

Analysis: the loan gives the higher EPS (14.91 against 13.87 cents), because the profit is shared between fewer shares, and existing shareholders keep control. But it raises gearing to 42.79% and cuts interest cover to 3.80 times, and the interest must be paid even if the new assets don’t deliver the extra profit. The share issue keeps risk low (gearing 23.77%, interest cover 7.59 times) but dilutes EPS and control. Conclusion: if the 15% increase in profit is reliable, the loan benefits shareholders more; if it is uncertain, the share issue is safer.

Limitations of ratio analysis

  • Based on historical figures; year-end balances may not be typical (seasonal trade, window dressing).
  • Different accounting policies (depreciation methods, inventory valuation, revaluations) make comparisons between companies unreliable.
  • Inflation distorts comparisons over time.
  • Ratios show symptoms, not causes; they ignore non-financial factors (staff, quality, reputation, the economy).
  • A single year tells little: compare trends, competitors and industry averages.

Answering the Paper 3 questions

Typical questions: “Calculate the working capital cycle (in days)”; “Calculate, to two decimal places, the price/earnings ratio, dividend yield and interest cover”; “Explain why the competitor has performed better in managing its working capital”; “Discuss the performance of the investment in relation to each of the investor’s three objectives”; “Suggest another solvency ratio which might be affected as the gearing ratio changes”; or “Advise the directors which option to choose to raise the funds.”

Paper 3 has three structured questions of 25 marks each: you prepare statements and calculate figures, then explain, discuss or advise. The written parts are marked on knowledge, analysis and evaluation. Plan every “discuss”, “advise” or “evaluate” answer in the same five steps, in this order:

  1. Knowledge: state what each relevant ratio measures and what a “good” direction is.
  2. Application: quote your figures for both years (or both companies, or both options) — never discuss a ratio without its number.
  3. Analysis: explain the cause and the link between ratios: for example, the debenture issue raised gearing from 15.15% to 29.36% and so cut interest cover from 15.00 to 6.60 times, which reduced EPS even though profit from operations rose.
  4. Evaluation: judge the results from the stakeholder’s point of view (their objective: income, growth, security), and note the limitations (one year, policies, industry averages, non-financial factors).
  5. Conclusion: give a clear, justified recommendation, for example: the investor seeking a secure income should not buy more shares now, because the dividend has just been cut and gearing is rising.

Check yourself

Inventory turnover is 40 days, receivables 35 days and payables 50 days. What is the working capital cycle?

40 + 35 − 50 = 25 days.

Profit for the year is $120,000 and share capital is $400,000 in $0.25 shares. Calculate EPS.

Shares = 1,600,000; EPS = 120,000 ÷ 1,600,000 = $0.075 (7.50 cents).

The share price is $3.00 and EPS is $0.25. Calculate the P/E ratio.

3.00 ÷ 0.25 = 12.

An interim dividend of $10,000 was paid and a final of $20,000 proposed on 500,000 shares priced at $1.20. Calculate DPS and dividend yield.

DPS = 30,000 ÷ 500,000 = $0.06; yield = 0.06 ÷ 1.20 × 100 = 5.00%.

Non-current liabilities $300,000; share capital $500,000; reserves $200,000. Calculate gearing.

300,000 ÷ 1,000,000 × 100 = 30.00%.

Why might dividend yield rise even though the company is doing worse?

Yield = DPS ÷ share price; if the share price falls further than the dividend, the yield rises.

Which solvency ratio is directly affected when gearing rises, and why?

Interest cover: more borrowing means more interest payable, so profit from operations covers it fewer times.

Now practise it

Try the 21 past paper questions on Analysis and communication, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.

Practise Analysis and communication questions →