← Topical Vault

Equity and redistribution of income and wealth Revision notes

Unit 8: Government microeconomic intervention · Chapter 39 · about 11 minutes · written for the 9708 syllabus · last checked 2026-11-15

Efficiency is about making the most of scarce resources; this topic is about who gets them. It explains the difference between fairness and equality, how inequality and poverty are measured, and the policies governments use to redistribute income. On Paper 4 it appears mostly in data response questions (define equity, read a Gini coefficient, assess a policy), and sometimes as part of an essay on fiscal policy or efficiency.

Equity, equality and efficiency

Equality: everyone is treated in the same way or has the same amount, for example everyone receiving the same income or the same benefit.

Equity: a fair distribution of income, wealth and opportunities. Fair is not necessarily equal.

A doctor who trained for ten years earning more than a school leaver is unequal, but most people think it is fair. Giving a disabled person more support than others is unequal, but equitable. Equity has two parts:

  • Horizontal equity: people in the same circumstances are treated the same, for example two people with the same income pay the same tax.
  • Vertical equity: people in different circumstances are treated differently in a fair way, for example richer people pay a larger share of their income in tax.

Equity is about what is fair, which is a value judgement; equality is about what is the same, which can be measured. A policy can increase equality without increasing equity, and the other way round.

Equity and efficiency

Efficiency (productive, allocative and Pareto) says nothing about fairness. A Pareto optimal economy could still be extremely unequal. Policies to make the distribution fairer can sometimes reduce efficiency:

  • High income tax rates may reduce the incentive to work, invest or set up businesses.
  • Generous benefits may reduce the incentive to find a job.
  • Some efficiency measures hurt equity: a congestion charge or fuel tax costs a low-paid worker the same as a rich executive.

But equity and efficiency don’t always conflict. Free education and healthcare for poorer families make them more productive, which raises output as well as fairness.

Poverty

Absolute poverty: income too low to afford the basic necessities of life: enough food, clean water, shelter, basic healthcare and education.

Relative poverty: income well below the average in that country, usually defined as below 50% (sometimes 60%) of median or average income, so people can’t afford the normal standard of living there.

The World Bank measures extreme poverty with an international poverty line, currently about $3 a day per person. The number of people below it has fallen sharply since 1990, mainly because of fast growth in China, India and other parts of Asia; extreme poverty is now concentrated in Sub-Saharan Africa.

The two measures behave very differently. Economic growth almost always reduces absolute poverty. But relative poverty only falls if the incomes of the poorest grow faster than the average, so a rich country can still have many people in relative poverty.

Measuring inequality: the Lorenz curve and Gini coefficient

A Lorenz curve: the further it sags below the line of equality, the more unequal incomes are; the Gini coefficient is area A divided by areas A plus B Cumulative % of income 0 Cumulative % of population 50 50 100 100 line of equality Lorenz curve A B poorest 50% get 19%
The line of equality shows a perfectly equal society (the poorest 50% get 50% of income). The Lorenz curve shows the actual distribution: here the poorest 50% get only 19%. The further the curve sags, the more unequal the society.

Gini coefficient = area A ÷ (area A + area B)

  • 0 means perfect equality (the Lorenz curve is the line of equality).
  • 1 means perfect inequality (one person has all the income). It is sometimes written from 0 to 100 instead.
  • Most countries lie between about 0.25 (Nordic countries, very equal) and over 0.6 (South Africa, very unequal).

A rise in the Gini coefficient means the distribution has become more unequal. The Gini coefficient is a single number, so two very different distributions can have the same value, and it says nothing about how rich the country is overall.

The poverty trap

Poverty trap: a situation where a low-income person gains little or nothing from earning more, because as their income rises they start paying tax and lose means-tested benefits at the same time.

Worked example

Nadia works part-time and receives a means-tested benefit. She takes on extra hours and earns $100 more a week.

  • She pays 20% income tax on it: −$20.
  • Her benefit is reduced by 60 cents for every extra dollar earned: −$60.
  • She keeps just $20 of the $100. Her effective marginal tax rate is 80%, far higher than a rich person’s.

Once travel and childcare costs are added, working more could leave her no better off at all. The trap is worst when the income tax threshold is low and benefits are withdrawn quickly. Governments reduce it by raising the tax-free allowance, withdrawing benefits more gradually, or paying in-work benefits.

Policies towards equity and equality

Taxes

  • Progressive income taxes take a larger percentage from higher incomes, directly narrowing the gap.
  • Wealth, property and inheritance taxes tackle the even bigger inequality in wealth.
  • Cutting regressive taxes such as sales taxes on basic food helps the poor, who spend a larger share of their income on them. (Raising income tax while cutting sales tax would reduce inequality.)

Means-tested and universal benefits

Means-tested benefits: paid only to people whose income or wealth is below a certain level, for example income support or housing benefit.

Universal benefits: paid to everyone in a group regardless of income, for example a state pension for everyone over a certain age, or child benefit for every child.

Means-testedUniversal
TargetingMoney goes only to those in need, so it is cheaperMuch goes to people who don’t need it, so it is expensive
Take-upMany eligible people don’t claim, because of complex forms or stigmaAlmost everyone receives it
IncentivesCan create a poverty trap, as benefit is lost when income risesNo poverty trap: you keep it whatever you earn
AdministrationCostly to check everyone’s incomeSimple and cheap to run

Universal basic income (UBI)

Universal basic income: a regular, unconditional cash payment from the government to every adult, whether or not they work and whatever their income.

For: it guarantees everyone a minimum income, removes the poverty trap (you never lose it by working more), is very simple to run, carries no stigma, and gives security to carers, students and people in insecure jobs.

Against: it is extremely expensive, because everyone receives it, so taxes would have to rise a lot; much of it goes to people who don’t need it; a payment big enough to live on might reduce the incentive to work; and a flat payment ignores different needs (a disabled person may need far more). Only limited trials have been run, for example in Finland, Kenya and parts of the USA.

Negative income tax

Negative income tax: a single system where people earning below a threshold receive money from the government, and people earning above it pay tax.

A negative income tax: someone with no earnings receives 2 thousand dollars; people earning below the 5 thousand dollar threshold receive a payment that shrinks as they earn more, and those above it pay tax Income after tax and benefits ($000) Income earned ($000) 0 5 5 2 no taxes or benefits negative income tax earns below 5: receives a payment earns above 5: pays tax
Everyone is guaranteed $2,000. For each extra dollar earned, the payment falls by 40 cents, so people always keep 60 cents of each extra dollar. At $5,000 the payment reaches zero; above that, people pay tax.

For example, someone earning $2,000 receives $2,000 − (40% × $2,000) = $1,200, so ends up with $3,200. Someone earning $5,000 receives nothing and pays nothing.

For: it combines tax and benefits into one simple system, everyone below the threshold gets help automatically, and because people always keep part of each extra dollar earned, there is always an incentive to work, avoiding the poverty trap.

Against: the withdrawal rate still acts like a tax on the poor; setting the guarantee high enough to live on while keeping the withdrawal rate low is very expensive; it needs accurate, up-to-date income information for everyone, which is hard where many people work informally; and no country has fully adopted it.

Other policies

  • State provision of free education, healthcare and housing gives the poor services they couldn’t otherwise afford, and education helps break the cycle of poverty in the long run.
  • Minimum wages raise the pay of the lowest-paid workers, though they may cost some jobs (see labour markets).
  • Supply-side policies such as training and education raise the earning power of low-skilled workers.

Answering the Paper 4 essay

Typical questions: “Discuss whether fiscal policy alone can promote a more equal distribution of income”; “Pareto optimality can only be achieved when an economy is both productively and allocatively efficient. This will create a more equitable society. Discuss”; or data response tasks such as “Use one supply-side policy and one fiscal policy to assess how a government might achieve greater equality in the distribution of income.”

Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:

  1. Knowledge: define equity (horizontal and vertical) and equality, absolute and relative poverty, the Gini coefficient, and the policies you will discuss (progressive taxes, means-tested and universal benefits, UBI, negative income tax).
  2. Application: use the country or data in the question: its Gini coefficient, the share of income going to the poorest, how many people work informally (which affects how well taxes and benefits can reach them), and real examples such as universal pensions or UBI trials.
  3. Analysis: explain the chain for each policy: a progressive tax takes a larger share from high incomes and funds transfers to low incomes, so the Lorenz curve moves towards the line of equality and the Gini coefficient falls. Use the Lorenz curve diagram, and explain the poverty trap with numbers.
  4. Evaluation: consider the trade-off with efficiency (incentives to work and invest), tax avoidance and capital or skilled workers leaving the country, the cost and targeting of benefits, the poverty trap, low take-up, and whether fiscal policy can reach people in the informal economy. Compare with long-run policies such as education, which tackle the causes of inequality rather than the symptoms.
  5. Conclusion: make a judgement: for example, fiscal policy can quickly reduce inequality in disposable income, but on its own it treats the symptoms; a lasting improvement needs it combined with education, training and job creation.

Efficiency and equity are separate goals. Don’t claim that an efficient (even Pareto optimal) economy must be fair: it can be very unequal.

Check yourself

What is the difference between equity and equality?

Equality means everyone is treated the same or has the same amount. Equity means the distribution is fair, which may involve treating people differently according to their circumstances.

Distinguish between absolute and relative poverty.

Absolute poverty: income too low to meet basic needs (food, shelter, water, healthcare). Relative poverty: income well below the average in that country, usually below half the average, so people can’t afford the normal standard of living there.

A country’s Gini coefficient rises from 0.32 to 0.41. What has happened?

Income has become more unequally distributed: the Lorenz curve has moved further away from the line of equality.

Why can means-tested benefits create a poverty trap?

As a low earner’s income rises, they start paying tax and lose some of their benefit at the same time, so they keep very little of each extra dollar. This high effective marginal tax rate reduces the incentive to work more.

Under a negative income tax with a $2,000 guarantee and a 40% withdrawal rate, how much does someone earning $3,000 receive?

$2,000 − (40% × $3,000) = $2,000 − $1,200 = $800, giving a total income of $3,800.

Now practise it

Try the 89 past paper questions on Equity and redistribution of income and wealth, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.

Practise Equity and redistribution of income and wealth questions →