Every business decision affects someone: owners, workers, customers, suppliers, the local community, the government. This chapter covers who these stakeholders are, what they want, and why their aims often clash. Paper 1 and Paper 2 regularly ask which stakeholder is most important, or how a decision such as a merger or a change of ownership will affect them.
Who are the stakeholders?
Stakeholder: an individual or group with an interest in the activities of a business, because they are affected by its decisions or can affect them.
- Internal stakeholders are inside the business: owners (shareholders), managers and employees.
- External stakeholders are outside it: customers, suppliers, lenders (banks), the government, the local community, and pressure groups.
Stakeholders and shareholders are different. Shareholders own part of a company and are one stakeholder group; stakeholders include everyone with an interest in the business.
Roles, rights and responsibilities
| Stakeholder | What they want (aims) | Rights | Responsibilities |
|---|---|---|---|
| Owners / shareholders | Profit, dividends, rising share value, growth | Vote at meetings; a share of profits; information on performance | Provide capital; appoint directors; act within the law |
| Managers | Pay, bonuses, status, job security, success of the business | Authority to make decisions in their role | Run the business efficiently towards its objectives; treat staff fairly |
| Employees | Good pay, job security, safe conditions, training, being valued | Contract, fair treatment, safety, minimum wage, union membership | Work to the standard agreed; follow rules; act honestly |
| Customers | Good quality, value for money, choice, good service | Safe products described honestly; consumer protection | Pay for what they buy; use products properly |
| Suppliers | Regular orders, prompt payment, long-term relationships | Payment as agreed in contracts | Deliver the right goods on time and at the agreed quality |
| Lenders | Interest paid and loans repaid on time | Repayment as agreed; security over assets | Provide finance on the agreed terms |
| Government | Taxes paid, jobs, growth, laws obeyed | To collect taxes and enforce laws | Provide a stable legal and economic framework, infrastructure |
| Local community | Jobs, a clean and safe environment, support for local causes | Protection from pollution and nuisance by law | Accept reasonable business activity in the area |
Stakeholders and business decisions
How decisions affect stakeholders
Take a decision to move production to a new automated factory: shareholders may gain from lower costs and higher profit; some employees lose their jobs while others need retraining; customers may get lower prices; the old town loses jobs and suppliers lose orders, while the new area gains. Each group reacts according to how it is affected: employees may resist or strike, customers may buy more or switch to rivals, the community may protest.
How stakeholders influence decisions
Stakeholders try to shape decisions to meet their own aims: shareholders vote and can sell their shares; employees negotiate through trade unions; customers buy elsewhere or complain publicly; lenders set conditions on loans; the government passes laws and taxes; communities and pressure groups campaign. How much influence a group has depends on its power (can it stop or change the decision?) and its interest (how much it is affected and how much it cares).
Accountability
A business is accountable to its stakeholders: it must explain and justify its decisions to them. Companies report to shareholders through annual reports and meetings, and to the government through tax returns and legal compliance. Many also publish information on their social and environmental impact. Being accountable builds trust, protects reputation and reduces the risk of conflict or legal action.
Stakeholder conflict
Because stakeholders want different things, their aims often clash:
- Shareholders vs employees: higher profit through lower wage costs or job cuts.
- Shareholders vs customers: higher prices raise profit but reduce value for customers.
- Business vs community: expansion brings jobs but also traffic, noise and pollution.
- Managers vs shareholders: managers may pursue growth or their own status rather than the highest profit.
- Short term vs long term: shareholders wanting dividends now versus investment for the future.
Some aims overlap: a successful, growing business can offer secure jobs, good products, regular orders and tax revenue all at once. Managers deal with conflict by consulting stakeholders, compromising, prioritising according to the business’s objectives, and communicating clearly why decisions were made.
Changing objectives and stakeholders
When objectives change, stakeholders are affected differently. A shift from growth to profit maximisation may mean price rises (customers lose) and cost cuts (employees and suppliers lose) but higher dividends (shareholders gain). A new focus on sustainability may raise costs but please customers and the community.
Answering the Paper 1 and 2 questions
Typical questions: “Evaluate whether owners are the most important stakeholders in a private school”; “‘Employees are the most important stakeholder group in a primary sector oil and gas business.’ Evaluate this view”; or “Evaluate the most likely impact of the proposed merger on one stakeholder of YV” (Paper 2).
In Paper 1 Section B you answer one two-part essay: part (a) for 8 marks and part (b) for 12 marks. Each Paper 2 question ends with an 8-mark part and a 12-mark part. The 12-mark parts must include evaluation, and long answers are marked on knowledge, application, analysis and evaluation. Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order:
- Knowledge: define stakeholders, internal and external stakeholders, and stakeholder conflict.
- Application: identify the stakeholders of the business in the question and what each wants: in a private school, owners, teachers, parents, pupils, the government.
- Analysis: explain how the decision affects each group and how each could react or influence the business: for example, if teachers are poorly treated, they leave, teaching quality falls, parents withdraw their children, and revenue falls.
- Evaluation: weigh the importance of different groups for this business: their power and interest, the business’s objectives, the short term and the long term, and how far their aims overlap.
- Conclusion: make a justified judgement, for example: owners are important because they provide the finance and take the risk, but in a school the success of the business depends on teachers and parents, so they may matter more in the long run.
Check yourself
What is the difference between a stakeholder and a shareholder?
A shareholder owns part of a company; a stakeholder is anyone with an interest in the business, including shareholders, employees, customers and the community.
Name three external stakeholders.
Any three of: customers, suppliers, lenders, the government, the local community, pressure groups.
Give an example of conflict between two stakeholder groups.
For example, shareholders want higher profit from cutting wage costs, while employees want higher pay and job security.
What does it mean for a business to be accountable to its stakeholders?
It must explain and justify its decisions and performance to them, for example through annual reports and meetings.
Why might stakeholder aims overlap?
A successful business can provide profit for owners, secure jobs for employees, good products for customers and tax for the government at the same time.
Now practise it
Try the 25 past paper questions on Stakeholders in a business, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.