← Topical Vault

Methods and effects of government intervention in markets Revision notes

Unit 3: Government microeconomic intervention · Chapter 13 · about 15 minutes · written for the 9708 syllabus · last checked 2026-11-17

This is the biggest AS microeconomics topic and the single most examined chapter in Paper 2. It covers six ways a government can change what a market produces or charges, and for each you need the diagram, its effects on consumers, producers and the government, and its weaknesses. Most essays ask you to compare two methods, so the judgement about which works better is where the top marks are.

Specific indirect taxes

Indirect tax: a tax on spending on goods and services, collected from producers.

Specific tax: a fixed amount of tax per unit sold, such as $2 per packet of cigarettes. (An ad valorem tax is a percentage of the price, such as VAT or GST.)

Incidence of a tax: how the burden of the tax is shared between consumers and producers.

A specific tax raises the cost of supplying each unit, so the supply curve shifts up (to the left) by the amount of the tax, in parallel.

A specific tax shifts supply up by the tax per unit. Output falls from Q1 to Q2; consumers now pay Pc and producers keep only Pp. The tax revenue is the whole rectangle between Pc and Pp: the top part is paid by consumers and the bottom part by producers Price Quantity 0 D S S + tax Q1 P1 Q2 Pc Pp consumers producers
The tax per unit is the vertical gap between S and S + tax. Consumers pay Pc, up from P1; producers keep Pp, down from P1. Tax revenue is (Pc − Pp) × Q2.
  • Impact: price rises, quantity falls from Q1 to Q2, the government gains revenue.
  • Incidence: consumers pay the part of the tax shown by the rise in price (Pc − P1) on each unit; producers pay the rest (P1 − Pp).

consumers’ share per unit = new price paid − original price

producers’ share per unit = tax per unit − consumers’ share

Example: a $3 tax per unit raises the market price from $10 to $12 and sales fall to 4,000 units. Consumers pay $2 of each $3 (total $8,000); producers pay $1 (total $4,000); tax revenue is $3 × 4,000 = $12,000.

Elasticity decides who pays

The same tax per unit in two markets. With inelastic demand (a) price rises a lot, so consumers pay most of the tax (top rectangle). With elastic demand (b) price hardly rises, so producers pay most of it (bottom rectangle) Price Quantity 0 (a) Inelastic demand S S + tax D Price Quantity 0 (b) Elastic demand S S + tax D
The more inelastic demand is (compared with supply), the greater the share of the tax paid by consumers.

With inelastic demand (cigarettes, petrol), producers can pass most of the tax on, because buyers keep buying. That raises a lot of revenue but cuts consumption only a little. With elastic demand, producers must absorb most of the tax to avoid losing sales, and consumption falls a lot. So taxes on demerit goods with inelastic demand are good at raising revenue but weak at changing behaviour.

Advantages of taxing a demerit goodDisadvantages
Raises price and reduces consumption, using the market rather than banning the goodLittle effect on consumption if demand is inelastic (addictive goods)
Raises revenue that can fund healthcare or information campaignsRegressive: takes a bigger share of income from poorer households
Makes consumers face more of the true cost of their choicesHard to know the right size of tax; may encourage smuggling and illegal markets

Subsidies

Subsidy: a payment by the government to producers to lower their costs and encourage them to produce more, usually a fixed amount per unit.

A subsidy per unit shifts supply down by the amount of the subsidy. Output rises from Q1 to Q2, consumers pay a lower price Pc, producers receive Pp, and the government pays the shaded rectangle (subsidy per unit times Q2) Price Quantity 0 D S S − subsidy Q1 P1 Q2 Pc Pp
A subsidy shifts supply down by the subsidy per unit. Consumers pay Pc, below P1; producers receive Pp including the subsidy; output rises to Q2. The shaded rectangle is the cost to the government.

A subsidy is the mirror image of a tax. Its incidence is shared too: consumers gain from the lower price (P1 − Pc) and producers from the higher price they receive (Pp − P1). With inelastic demand, consumers get most of the benefit as a lower price, but consumption rises only a little.

Advantages of subsidising a merit goodDisadvantages
Lowers price and raises consumption of goods such as public transport or vaccinationsOpportunity cost: the money could be spent elsewhere, or requires higher taxes
Helps low-income households afford essentialsLittle extra consumption if demand is inelastic, or if people still underestimate the benefits
Can keep firms in business and protect jobsFirms may become inefficient and dependent; hard to remove once given

Direct provision

The government supplies the good itself, often free or at a low price, paid for from taxation: state schools, public hospitals, roads, street lighting and defence. It is the main way of providing public goods, and is used for merit goods so that everyone can consume them regardless of income.

The drawbacks: high cost to taxpayers (with an opportunity cost), a lack of competition and profit motive that can make state providers inefficient, waiting lists when a free service faces excess demand, and less choice for consumers.

Maximum and minimum prices

Maximum price (price ceiling): a legal limit above which a price can’t rise. To have any effect, it must be set below the equilibrium price.

Minimum price (price floor): a legal limit below which a price can’t fall. To have any effect, it must be set above the equilibrium price.

A maximum price set below equilibrium (a) means quantity demanded Qd is greater than quantity supplied Qs: a shortage. A minimum price set above equilibrium (b) means quantity supplied is greater than quantity demanded: a surplus Price Quantity 0 (a) Maximum price D S Pmax Qd Qs shortage P* Price Quantity 0 (b) Minimum price D S Pmin Qd Qs surplus P*
(a) A maximum price below equilibrium creates a shortage (Qd greater than Qs). (b) A minimum price above equilibrium creates a surplus (Qs greater than Qd).

Maximum prices

Used to make essentials such as rented housing, bread or fuel affordable. Those who can buy at the lower price gain, but quantity supplied falls and a shortage appears. The limited supply must then be rationed some other way: queues, waiting lists, “first come, first served”, or favouritism. Black markets often develop, where the good is resold illegally above the maximum price. With rent controls, landlords may let property fall into disrepair or withdraw it from the market.

Minimum prices

Used to raise producers’ incomes (guaranteed prices for farmers) or to discourage consumption of demerit goods (minimum prices per unit of alcohol). Producers who sell gain, but quantity demanded falls and a surplus appears. If the government promises to buy the surplus, it must pay for and store it (or destroy it), which is costly. Consumers pay more. A minimum wage is a minimum price in the labour market (see income inequality).

A maximum price set above equilibrium, or a minimum price set below it, has no effect at all: the market simply settles at its equilibrium. Always place the maximum price line below the intersection and the minimum price line above it.

Buffer stock schemes

Buffer stock scheme: a scheme in which an agency buys a product when its price is low and sells it from its stock when its price is high, to keep the price within a set range.

A buffer stock scheme keeps price between a floor and a ceiling. After a good harvest the price would fall below the floor, so the agency buys the surplus and stores it; after a bad harvest the price would rise above the ceiling, so it sells from its stock Price Quantity 0 D Sbad Snormal Sgood ceiling price floor price buys sells
Supply of a crop depends on the harvest. A good harvest would push price below the floor, so the agency buys the surplus; a bad harvest would push price above the ceiling, so the agency sells from its stocks.

Buffer stocks suit agricultural products and commodities, whose prices swing because supply depends on the weather and is price inelastic. They stabilise farmers’ incomes and food prices, and help farmers plan and invest.

But they often fail in practice. The product must be storable (not fresh fruit); storage costs money; the agency needs large funds to buy in good years; and if the floor is set too high, the agency keeps buying, stocks pile up and the money runs out. Good and bad harvests must roughly balance over time for the scheme to survive.

Provision of information

If merit and demerit goods are consumed in the wrong quantities because people lack information, the direct cure is to give them the information: health warnings on cigarette packets, sugar labelling on food, advertising campaigns on the benefits of vaccination or exercise, or careers guidance on the value of education.

This tackles the cause of the problem, costs relatively little and respects consumer choice. But it can be slow to work, people may ignore it (especially if a good is addictive), and its effect is hard to measure. It is often used alongside taxes or subsidies rather than instead of them. Governments can also use regulation, such as banning smoking in public places or setting a minimum age for buying alcohol.

Answering the Paper 2 essay

Typical questions: “Assess whether an increase in the tax on a demerit good is always the best way to reduce its consumption”; “Assess whether the over-consumption of a demerit good should be reduced through a tax or through a public information campaign”; “Assess the extent to which a subsidy is likely to be the best method to increase the consumption of a merit good”; or “With the help of a diagram, explain how the introduction of an effective maximum price affects the market.”

Section B questions come in two parts: part (a), worth 8 marks, asks you to explain and then briefly consider; part (b), worth 12 marks, asks you to assess. Plan both in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:

  1. Knowledge: define each method in the question (specific tax, incidence, subsidy, maximum or minimum price, buffer stock, provision of information) and the type of good it targets.
  2. Application: use real examples: taxes on cigarettes and sugary drinks; subsidies for public transport or electric cars; rent controls; minimum alcohol prices; health warnings and vaccination campaigns.
  3. Analysis: draw the diagram for each method and explain its effect on price, quantity, consumers, producers and the government (revenue or cost). Explain why elasticity determines who bears a tax and how far consumption changes.
  4. Evaluation: compare methods: a tax raises revenue but works poorly if demand is inelastic and hits the poor hardest; information tackles the cause but is slow and may be ignored; subsidies cost money and may not change behaviour; price controls cause shortages or surpluses. Effectiveness depends on elasticity, the time period, how well the government judges the right level, and whether methods are combined.
  5. Conclusion: make a judgement for the case in the question, for example: a tax is not always the best way to cut consumption of a demerit good; where demand is very inelastic, a tax combined with information and regulation is likely to be more effective than a tax alone.

Check yourself

A $4 specific tax raises the market price of a good from $20 to $23. How is the tax shared?

Consumers pay $3 per unit (the price rise) and producers pay $1 per unit.

Why do consumers bear most of a tax when demand is price inelastic?

Buyers keep buying even when price rises, so producers can pass most of the tax on as a higher price without losing many sales.

Why does an effective maximum price cause a shortage?

It is set below equilibrium, so quantity demanded rises and quantity supplied falls, leaving demand greater than supply.

Give two problems with buffer stock schemes.

Any two of: storage costs; the product must be storable; large funds are needed; if the floor price is too high the agency keeps buying and runs out of money; it needs good and bad harvests to balance out.

Why might providing information be better than taxing a demerit good?

It tackles the cause of over-consumption (imperfect information), costs less, isn’t regressive and respects consumer choice. But it may be slow and ignored.

Now practise it

Try the 236 past paper questions on Methods and effects of government intervention in markets, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.

Practise Methods and effects of government intervention in markets questions →