← Topical Vault

Scarcity, choice and opportunity cost Revision notes

Unit 1: Basic economic ideas and resource allocation · Chapter 1 · about 8 minutes · written for the 9708 syllabus · last checked 2026-11-17

Every other topic in economics grows out of one idea: we can’t have everything we want, so we have to choose. This chapter sets out that idea and the words economists use for it. It is examined mostly in multiple choice, but scarcity, choice and opportunity cost also turn up in Paper 2 essays, usually alongside a production possibility curve.

The basic economic problem

Scarcity: the situation in which there are not enough resources to satisfy all of people’s wants. Wants are unlimited, but the resources needed to meet them are limited.

The basic (fundamental) economic problem: how to allocate scarce resources between unlimited, competing wants.

Wants are unlimited because once one want is met, people find new ones: a better phone, a bigger home, more travel, better healthcare. Resources are limited because there is only so much land, labour, machinery and know-how at any one time. Economists group these resources into four factors of production: land, labour, capital and enterprise.

Scarcity is not the same as poverty. A rich country faces scarcity too: its government still can’t build every hospital, school and road that people would like, because the resources used for one can’t also be used for another.

Don’t say a good is “scarce” just because it is in short supply this week. In economics almost everything is scarce, because more of it could be wanted than is available at a zero price. The only exceptions are free goods such as air or seawater, which you’ll meet in classification of goods and services.

Choice at every level

Because resources are scarce, every economic agent has to choose:

  • Individuals and households choose how to spend a limited income and limited time: buying a laptop or going on holiday, working an extra shift or studying.
  • Firms choose what to produce, which methods to use and how to spend their budget: a new machine or more workers, a new product or a cheaper version of an old one.
  • Governments choose how to spend tax revenue: more on health means less on education, defence or roads, unless taxes rise or the government borrows, which has costs of its own.

Opportunity cost

Opportunity cost: the benefit of the next best alternative given up when a choice is made.

Notice the two key words. It is the next best alternative, not every alternative, and it is measured by what is given up, not by the money spent. A student who spends Saturday working in a café for $60, when the next best use of the day was revising for an exam, has an opportunity cost of the revision (and possibly a better grade), not the $60.

A government that spends $500 million on a new airport might otherwise have built ten hospitals. The opportunity cost of the airport is the ten hospitals, and the healthcare they would have provided.

Opportunity cost exists even when something is “free” to the user. Free state schooling still uses teachers, buildings and books that could have been used elsewhere, so it has an opportunity cost to society. A good exam answer points this out.

Showing scarcity, choice and opportunity cost on a diagram

A production possibility curve (PPC) shows the most an economy can produce of two goods with all its resources, used efficiently, and its current technology. It shows all three ideas at once:

A production possibility curve for food and clothing. Moving from A to B gains C1 to C2 of clothing at an opportunity cost of F1 to F2 of food; point X lies outside the curve and cannot be reached Food Clothing 0 PPC C1 F1 C2 F2 A B X: not reachable
Scarcity: points beyond the curve, such as X, can’t be reached. Choice: the economy must pick one point on the curve, such as A or B. Opportunity cost: moving from A to B gains C1 to C2 of clothing but gives up F1 to F2 of food.

Because the curve bows outwards, each extra unit of clothing costs more food than the one before: resources good at farming are moved into clothing production, where they are less productive. So not every choice has the same opportunity cost. This is explained fully in the PPC notes.

The three basic questions

Every economy, whatever its system, has to answer three questions about how to use its scarce resources:

QuestionWhat it meansExample
What to produce?Which goods and services, and how much of eachMore electric cars or more buses; more houses or more offices
How to produce?Which combination of resources and methods to useA labour-intensive method (many workers) or a capital-intensive one (machines and robots)
For whom to produce?Who receives the output: how it is shared between peopleAccording to income, need, or a government decision

Different economic systems answer these questions in different ways. In a market economy prices and profits decide; in a planned economy the state decides; in a mixed economy both play a part.

Answering the Paper 2 essay

Typical questions: “With the help of a production possibility curve diagram, explain the terms scarcity and choice and consider the extent to which every choice has an equal opportunity cost”; or “Explain why scarcity makes choice inevitable for firms and how each choice has an opportunity cost.” These ideas also open many longer answers on economic systems.

Section B questions come in two parts: part (a), worth 8 marks, asks you to explain and then briefly consider; part (b), worth 12 marks, asks you to assess. Plan both in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:

  1. Knowledge: define scarcity, the basic economic problem, choice and opportunity cost precisely, stressing “next best alternative forgone”.
  2. Application: give real choices: a student choosing between work and study, a firm choosing between a new machine and more staff, a government choosing between hospitals and roads.
  3. Analysis: draw a PPC with labelled axes, two points on the curve and one outside it. Explain the chain: limited resources mean points outside the curve can’t be reached (scarcity), so a point on the curve must be chosen (choice), and moving along the curve means giving up some of one good (opportunity cost).
  4. Evaluation: consider whether every choice has an equal opportunity cost: it does only if resources are equally good at producing both goods (a straight-line PPC). Usually resources are specialised, so the curve bows outwards and opportunity cost rises. Also note that opportunity cost can be hard to measure when the alternative is not priced, such as leisure or the environment.
  5. Conclusion: answer the question directly, for example: scarcity always forces choice and every choice has an opportunity cost, but the size of that cost is rarely constant; it depends on how suitable resources are for each use.

Check yourself

Why does a rich country still face the basic economic problem?

Because wants are unlimited and resources are still limited. A rich country can produce more, but people’s wants grow too, and resources used for one purpose can’t be used for another.

Define opportunity cost.

The benefit of the next best alternative given up when a choice is made.

A worker gives up a $200 weekend job to attend a free training course. What is the opportunity cost of the course?

The next best alternative given up: the weekend job and the $200 it would have paid (plus any other benefit of that use of time). The course being free to attend doesn’t make its opportunity cost zero.

State the three basic questions every economy must answer.

What to produce, how to produce it, and for whom to produce it.

How does a PPC show scarcity?

Points outside the curve can’t be produced with the economy’s current resources and technology, so not every combination of goods that people want is attainable.

Now practise it

Try the 42 past paper questions on Scarcity, choice and opportunity cost, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.

Practise Scarcity, choice and opportunity cost questions →