The price mechanism usually allocates resources well, but not always. When it produces too much of some things, too little of others, or none at all, economists call it market failure. This topic gives you the vocabulary to explain why — and the reasons governments intervene in the mixed economic system. (Demand and supply diagrams of market failure are not required at IGCSE: explain it in words.)
Market failure: a situation in which the market forces of demand and supply lead to a misallocation of resources: too much or too little of a product is produced and consumed, or it is not produced at all.
Costs and benefits: private, external and social
Private costs: costs paid by the consumers or producers who take a decision (the price of a car, its fuel and insurance).
External costs: costs imposed on third parties — people not involved in the decision — which they are not paid for (pollution from the car harming people’s health, congestion).
Social costs = private costs + external costs: the full cost to society.
Private benefits: benefits received by the people who consume or produce a product. External benefits: benefits to third parties. Social benefits = private benefits + external benefits.
Example. A factory’s wages, materials and energy cost $8 million a year (private costs). Its smoke damages local crops and people’s health, costing others $3 million a year (external costs). The social cost is 8 + 3 = $11 million. Because the factory pays only $8 million, it produces more than is best for society, and its products are underpriced.
A person who is vaccinated gains protection (private benefit), and others are less likely to catch the disease (external benefit). Because people consider only their own benefit, too few are vaccinated if it is left to the market.
The market fails when external costs or benefits exist, because people take decisions on private costs and benefits only. Goods with external costs are over-produced and over-consumed; goods with external benefits are under-produced and under-consumed.
Merit goods and demerit goods
Merit good: a product that is more beneficial to consumers than they realise, and that usually has external benefits — for example education, healthcare, vaccinations. It is under-consumed if left to the market.
Demerit good: a product that is more harmful to consumers than they realise, and that usually has external costs — for example cigarettes, alcohol, sugary drinks, gambling. It is over-consumed if left to the market.
Why do people get these choices wrong? They may lack information (not knowing the long-term harm of smoking), think only of the short term (education pays off years later), or be unable to afford the product (healthcare for low-income families).
Public goods
Public good: a product that is non-excludable (people who don’t pay cannot be stopped from benefiting) and non-rival (one person’s use does not reduce the amount available to others). Examples: street lighting, national defence, flood defences, lighthouses.
A private good is the opposite: excludable and rival (a sandwich — if you eat it, no one else can, and you can be made to pay). Because people can benefit from a public good without paying, they have no reason to pay: this is the free rider problem. Firms cannot make a profit, so a market would not provide public goods at all.
Monopoly
Monopoly: a market with a single seller (or one firm with a very large share of the market) and high barriers stopping new firms entering.
Without competition, a monopoly can restrict supply to push the price up and earn high profits. Consumers pay more, buy less and have less choice; the firm may have little reason to keep costs down or improve quality. Resources are misallocated because less is produced than consumers would buy at a price that just covers costs.
Causes and consequences: a summary
| Cause | Consequence (misallocation of resources) |
|---|---|
| Demerit goods; goods with external costs | Over-consumption: too many resources go into them (more smoking-related illness, more pollution) |
| Merit goods; goods with external benefits | Under-consumption: too few resources (too little education and healthcare; a less productive workforce) |
| Public goods | Non-provision: they are not produced at all by the market |
| Abuse of monopoly power | Restricted supply and higher prices; less choice; possibly lower quality |
Environmental damage is a major example: when firms and consumers don’t pay for the pollution they cause or the non-renewable resources they use up, the market over-produces polluting goods and the environment suffers for future generations.
Common mistakes: saying merit goods are goods the government provides (they can be sold by private firms too — the point is under-consumption); defining a public good as “a good provided by the government”; and forgetting to identify the third party when explaining an external cost or benefit.
Answering the Paper 1 and 2 questions
Typical questions: “Define market failure”; “Identify two characteristics of a public good”; “Explain why a merit good is under-consumed”; “Analyse why the production of electricity from coal may lead to market failure”; “Discuss whether a monopoly always acts against the interests of consumers.”
Paper 1 has 40 multiple-choice questions in an hour: work out the answer before you look at the options, because the wrong options are the answers you get from the common mistakes. Paper 2 (2 hours) has a compulsory data question in Section A and three structured questions, from a choice of four, in Section B. Short parts ask you to define, identify, calculate or explain; longer parts ask you to analyse or discuss, and a “discuss” answer is marked on analysis and on evaluation — both sides, then a judgement. Plan every “analyse” or “discuss” answer in the same five steps, in this order:
- Knowledge: define the type of market failure precisely (public good, merit or demerit good, external cost or benefit, monopoly).
- Application: apply it to the product in the question and name the third parties affected.
- Analysis: explain why the market gets the quantity wrong: for example, the power station pays only its private costs, so electricity from coal is underpriced and over-produced, and the external cost of pollution falls on local people.
- Evaluation: consider the other side: how large the external effect is, whether people really lack information, and (for monopoly) possible benefits such as lower costs from large-scale production or money for research.
- Conclusion: reach a judgement, for example: a monopoly is likely to harm consumers unless it is regulated or faces some competition.
Check yourself
Define an external cost.
A cost imposed on third parties, not involved in the decision, which they are not paid for.
Private benefits are $5 million and external benefits $2 million. What are the social benefits?
$7 million.
Why is street lighting a public good?
It is non-excludable (non-payers can’t be stopped from benefiting) and non-rival (one person’s use doesn’t reduce it for others).
What is the free rider problem?
People can benefit from a public good without paying, so no one has an incentive to pay and firms cannot provide it profitably.
Give one consequence of a monopoly abusing its power.
It restricts supply and charges higher prices (also: less choice, possibly lower quality).
Now practise it
Try the 97 past paper questions on Market failure, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.