← Topical Vault

The nature of the economic problem Revision notes

Chapter 1 · about 10 minutes · written for the 0455 syllabus · last checked 2026-11-19

Economics starts from one simple fact: people want more than can ever be produced. Everything else in the course — markets, prices, government policy, trade — is about how societies decide what to do with resources that are not enough to go round. Questions on this topic are short (definitions and examples), but the ideas come back in every other topic.

Finite resources and infinite wants

The basic economic problem: resources are finite (limited) but wants are infinite (unlimited), so not every want can be satisfied and choices have to be made.

Scarcity: the situation in which there are not enough resources to produce everything that people want.

Wants are things people would like to have; needs are things required to survive (food, water, shelter, clothing). Wants are unlimited because as soon as one is satisfied another appears: a family that buys a car soon wants a bigger one, a holiday, a new phone. Resources — land, workers, machines, entrepreneurs (the factors of production, see factors of production) — are limited at any one time.

Scarcity is relative, not absolute: even the richest countries face it, because their people also want more than they can produce. Scarcity forces choice, and every choice has an opportunity cost (see opportunity cost).

The basic economic problem for each decision-maker

WhoLimited resourceExample of the choice they face
ConsumersIncome and timeA student with $40 must choose between new trainers and a concert ticket.
WorkersTime, skills and energyWorking extra hours for more pay or keeping the time for family and leisure; taking a job now or training for a better-paid one.
Producers (firms)Money for investment, land, workers, machinesA farmer with 50 hectares must decide how much to plant with rice and how much with vegetables.
GovernmentsTax revenue and borrowingSpending on a new hospital or a new road; cutting taxes or improving schools.

Three questions every economy must answer

Because resources are scarce, every economy has to decide how to allocate them. This comes down to three questions:

  1. What to produce? Which goods and services, and how much of each: more electric cars or more buses; more food or more weapons.
  2. How to produce? Which combination of resources to use: many workers and few machines (labour-intensive) or few workers and many machines (capital-intensive); methods that cause pollution or cleaner ones.
  3. For whom to produce? Who gets the goods and services: those who can pay most, those who need them most, or everyone equally.

Different economic systems answer these questions in different ways: in a market system mainly through prices (see the role of markets), in a mixed system through prices and government decisions.

Example. A small island has fertile land, a fishing fleet and 20,000 workers. What: it could grow coffee for export or food for its own people. How: it could farm with many workers by hand, or buy tractors and use fewer workers. For whom: the fish caught could be exported to tourists’ hotels that pay high prices, or sold cheaply to local families. Each answer uses resources that can’t then be used for something else.

Economic goods and free goods

Economic good: a good that is scarce, so it takes resources to produce and has an opportunity cost. Most goods and services are economic goods: food, phones, haircuts, education.

Free good: a good that is not scarce: there is enough of it to satisfy everyone’s wants without using any resources, so it has no opportunity cost. Examples: air in the open, sea water, sunlight.

“Free” in economics does not mean “given away at no charge”. A school meal that pupils don’t pay for is an economic good: food, cooks and kitchens were used to produce it, and the government or school paid for them. A good is free only if no resources are used to provide it.

Free goods can become economic goods. Clean air in a polluted city is scarce: resources must be spent on filters or cleaner transport to provide it. Fresh water in a desert region has to be pumped, treated or piped. Using the environment carelessly turns free goods into scarce ones — one reason why sustainability matters in economics.

Common mistakes: saying scarcity means a good is “rare” (scarcity applies to all resources compared with wants); giving a product sold at a zero price, such as free public healthcare, as an example of a free good; and confusing wants with needs.

Answering the Paper 1 and 2 questions

Typical questions: “Define the basic economic problem”; “Identify two examples of a free good”; “Explain the difference between an economic good and a free good”; “Explain why scarcity means a government has to make choices”.

Paper 1 has 40 multiple-choice questions in an hour: work out the answer before you look at the options, because the wrong options are the answers you get from the common mistakes. Paper 2 (2 hours) has a compulsory data question in Section A and three structured questions, from a choice of four, in Section B. Short parts ask you to define, identify, calculate or explain; longer parts ask you to analyse or discuss, and a “discuss” answer is marked on analysis and on evaluation — both sides, then a judgement. Plan every “analyse” or “discuss” answer in the same five steps, in this order:

  1. Knowledge: define scarcity and the basic economic problem precisely: finite resources, infinite wants, so choices must be made.
  2. Application: use the example in the question: the decision-maker (consumer, worker, firm or government) and the resource that is limited.
  3. Analysis: explain the chain: limited resources → not every want can be met → a choice is needed → something is given up (an opportunity cost).
  4. Evaluation: consider whether the good really is scarce here (a free good in one place may be an economic good in another) and who pays for goods supplied at no charge.
  5. Conclusion: state a clear answer, for example: a school meal provided at no charge is an economic good, because resources are used to produce it.

Check yourself

Define scarcity.

The situation in which there are not enough resources to produce everything that people want.

Why are wants described as infinite?

When one want is satisfied people find new ones, so there is no limit to what they would like to have.

Is a free public library service a free good? Explain.

No. Buildings, books and staff are used to provide it, so it has an opportunity cost; it is an economic good provided at no charge to users.

State the three basic economic questions.

What to produce, how to produce, and for whom to produce.

Give one example of the basic economic problem facing a worker.

Choosing between working overtime for more income and having more leisure time, because time is limited.

Now practise it

Try the 39 past paper questions on The nature of the economic problem, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.

Practise The nature of the economic problem questions →