Capital investment decisions — buying a new machine, opening a branch, launching a product — commit large sums for several years, so businesses appraise them before deciding. The syllabus requires four techniques: payback, accounting rate of return (ARR), net present value (NPV) and internal rate of return (IRR), plus their strengths and weaknesses and the non-financial factors. Questions will not involve discounted payback or a residual (scrap) value at the end of the project.
Cash flows, not profits
Payback, NPV and IRR use net cash flows: the extra cash coming in (revenue) less the extra cash going out (running costs) each year because of the project. Only relevant cash flows count:
- Include: the initial cost (year 0), extra revenue, extra running costs, extra working capital, costs saved, and opportunity costs (income given up).
- Exclude: depreciation (not a cash flow — the cash went out when the asset was bought), sunk costs already spent (such as a feasibility study last year), and fixed overheads that will be paid anyway.
ARR is the exception: it uses accounting profit, which is cash flow less depreciation.
Time value of money: $1 today is worth more than $1 in the future, because it could be invested to earn interest (and because of inflation and risk). Discounting converts future cash flows to their present value so they can be compared fairly with the cost today.
The worked example: data
Delta Ltd can buy one of two machines, each costing $120,000 and lasting four years with no residual value. Net cash inflows are expected to be:
| Net cash inflows | Machine A $ | Machine B $ |
|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | 40 000 | 70 000 |
| Year 2 | 45 000 | 50 000 |
| Year 3 | 50 000 | 20 000 |
| Year 4 | 35 000 | 10 000 |
| Total | 170 000 | 150 000 |
The company depreciates machinery by the straight-line method and uses a cost of capital of 10%. Discount factors: 10% — 0.909, 0.826, 0.751, 0.683; 18% — 0.847, 0.718, 0.609, 0.516.
Payback
Payback period: the time it takes for the net cash inflows to repay the initial investment.
- List the cumulative net cash flow year by year, starting with the cost as a negative in year 0.
- Find the year in which the cumulative figure turns positive.
- Payback = years before that + (amount still to recover at the start of that year ÷ that year’s cash inflow), assuming cash flows arise evenly through the year. Convert the fraction to months if asked (× 12).
| Machine A | Cash flow $ | Cumulative $ |
|---|---|---|
| Year 0 | (120 000) | (120 000) |
| Year 1 | 40 000 | (80 000) |
| Year 2 | 45 000 | (35 000) |
| Year 3 | 50 000 | 15 000 |
| Year 4 | 35 000 | 50 000 |
After 2 years, $85,000 has been recovered; $35,000 more is needed out of year 3’s $50,000. Payback = 2 + 35,000 ÷ 50,000 = 2.7 years (2 years and 0.7 × 12 = 8.4, about 9 months). Machine B: 70,000 + 50,000 = 120,000 exactly after 2 years.
Accounting rate of return (ARR)
ARR = (average profit ÷ average investment) × 100
Average investment = (initial cost + residual value) ÷ 2 = initial cost ÷ 2 (no residual value)
- Profit each year = net cash inflow − depreciation (here 120,000 ÷ 4 = $30,000 a year). Or: total profit = total cash inflows − cost.
- Average profit = total profit ÷ number of years.
- Average investment = cost ÷ 2.
- ARR = average profit ÷ average investment × 100. Compare it with the company’s target return.
Machine A: total profit = 170,000 − 120,000 = $50,000; average profit = 50,000 ÷ 4 = $12,500; average investment = 120,000 ÷ 2 = $60,000; ARR = 12,500 ÷ 60,000 × 100 = 20.83%. Machine B: total profit = 150,000 − 120,000 = $30,000; average $7,500; ARR = 7,500 ÷ 60,000 × 100 = 12.50%.
Use the syllabus formula: average profit over average investment. Dividing by the initial cost instead halves the answer and loses the marks.
Net present value (NPV)
Net present value: the total present value of the future net cash inflows minus the initial investment, discounted at the business’s cost of capital. A positive NPV means the project earns more than the cost of capital and adds value: accept it. Between projects, choose the higher NPV.
- Multiply each year’s net cash flow by the discount factor for that year (year 0 is not discounted).
- Add the present values.
- Deduct the initial cost.
| Machine A at 10% | Cash flow $ | Factor | Present value $ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | 40 000 | 0.909 | 36 360 |
| Year 2 | 45 000 | 0.826 | 37 170 |
| Year 3 | 50 000 | 0.751 | 37 550 |
| Year 4 | 35 000 | 0.683 | 23 905 |
| Total present value | 134 985 | ||
| Less initial cost | (120 000) | ||
| Net present value | 14 985 |
| Machine B at 10% | Cash flow $ | Factor | Present value $ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | 70 000 | 0.909 | 63 630 |
| Year 2 | 50 000 | 0.826 | 41 300 |
| Year 3 | 20 000 | 0.751 | 15 020 |
| Year 4 | 10 000 | 0.683 | 6 830 |
| Total present value | 126 780 | ||
| Less initial cost | (120 000) | ||
| Net present value | 6 780 |
Both NPVs are positive, so both machines are worth buying, but A adds more value: $14,985 against $6,780.
Internal rate of return (IRR)
Internal rate of return: the discount rate at which the project’s NPV is exactly zero — the project’s own rate of return. Accept if the IRR is higher than the cost of capital.
- Calculate the NPV at two rates: one giving a positive NPV and one giving a negative NPV (the question usually supplies the factors).
- Interpolate: IRR = lower rate + (difference between the rates × positive NPV ÷ (positive NPV − negative NPV)). Note that subtracting the negative NPV means adding its size.
| Machine A at 18% | Cash flow $ | Factor | Present value $ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | 40 000 | 0.847 | 33 880 |
| Year 2 | 45 000 | 0.718 | 32 310 |
| Year 3 | 50 000 | 0.609 | 30 450 |
| Year 4 | 35 000 | 0.516 | 18 060 |
| Total present value | 114 700 | ||
| Less initial cost | (120 000) | ||
| Net present value | (5 300) |
IRR = 10% + 8% × 14,985 ÷ (14,985 + 5,300) = 10% + 8% × 0.739 = 15.91%. Worked the same way, Machine B has an NPV of −$7,470 at 18%, giving an IRR of 13.81%. Both exceed the 10% cost of capital; A’s return is higher.
Interpolation assumes the NPV falls in a straight line between the two rates, so the answer is an approximation; the closer the two rates, the more accurate it is.
Comparing the results
| Summary | Machine A | Machine B |
|---|---|---|
| Payback | 2.7 years | 2.0 years |
| ARR | 20.83% | 12.50% |
| NPV at 10% | $14,985 | $6,780 |
| IRR | 15.91% | 13.81% |
The methods disagree. Machine B pays back faster because most of its cash comes early, so it is less risky and better for liquidity. But Machine A earns more in total, and every method that looks at the whole life of the project (ARR, NPV, IRR) prefers it. Since NPV measures the value each project adds after allowing for the cost of capital, Delta should choose Machine A — unless it is short of cash or B’s later cash flows are much more certain than A’s.
Advantages and disadvantages of each method
| Method | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|
| Payback | Simple to calculate and understand; favours quick returns, reducing risk; useful when cash is short | Ignores cash flows after payback; ignores the time value of money (in its simple form); doesn’t measure profitability |
| ARR | Gives a percentage that can be compared with a target return or ROCE; considers the whole life; uses familiar profit figures | Uses profit, not cash; ignores the timing of returns and the time value of money; depends on depreciation policy |
| NPV | Allows for the time value of money; uses cash flows over the whole life; shows the money value added; clear decision rule | Harder to calculate and explain; needs an accurate cost of capital; depends on forecasts of distant cash flows |
| IRR | Allows for the time value of money; gives a percentage easy to compare with the cost of capital | Interpolation is approximate; can mislead when comparing projects of different sizes; more complex |
Ways the future cash flows may have been estimated: market research, past results of similar projects, suppliers’ quotations, and economic forecasts — all uncertain, which is why later years carry more risk.
Non-financial factors
- Reliability of the forecasts and the risk of the project; how quickly technology may make the machine obsolete.
- Effect on employees: redundancies, training, morale; and on the community and the environment (pollution, noise, sustainability).
- Quality of output, reliability and after-sales service of the supplier.
- Fit with the business’s strategy and image; reactions of customers and competitors.
- How the investment will be financed, and the effect on liquidity and gearing.
Answering the Paper 4 questions
Typical questions: “Calculate for the new machine the accounting rate of return, the net present value and the internal rate of return”; “Calculate the payback period, in years”; “Explain what is meant by the term ‘net cash inflow’”; “State three advantages of using the NPV method”; or “Advise the directors which, if either, of the options they should choose. Justify your answer.”
Paper 4 has two structured questions of 25 marks each: you calculate costs, budgets or variances, then explain, discuss or advise. The written parts are marked on knowledge, analysis and evaluation. Plan every “discuss”, “advise” or “evaluate” answer in the same five steps, in this order:
- Knowledge: state what each technique measures and its decision rule (positive NPV; IRR above the cost of capital; payback within the target; ARR above the target).
- Application: quote your results for each option and compare them with the targets and the cost of capital.
- Analysis: explain why the methods agree or disagree: for example, Machine B pays back sooner because its cash is front-loaded, but Machine A’s larger later inflows give it a higher NPV.
- Evaluation: weigh the reliability of the forecasts, risk, liquidity, the limitations of each method, and the non-financial factors.
- Conclusion: give a justified decision, for example: the directors should buy Machine A, because it has the higher NPV and IRR, provided the later cash flows are reliable.
Check yourself
An investment of $50,000 returns $15,000, $20,000, $25,000 and $10,000. What is the payback period?
After 2 years $35,000; $15,000 more from year 3’s $25,000 = 0.6 years. Payback = 2.6 years.
The same investment has no residual value and lasts 4 years. Calculate the ARR.
Total profit = 70,000 − 50,000 = 20,000; average = 5,000; average investment = 25,000; ARR = 20.00%.
Why is depreciation excluded from NPV calculations?
It isn’t a cash flow; the cash outflow is the initial cost in year 0, so including depreciation would count it twice.
NPV is $12,000 at 10% and −$6,000 at 16%. Estimate the IRR.
10% + 6% × 12,000 ÷ 18,000 = 14%.
A project has a positive NPV but a payback longer than the company’s target. What should it consider?
NPV shows it adds value, but a long payback means more risk and slower recovery of cash; consider the reliability of later cash flows, liquidity and how the project would be financed.
Now practise it
Try the 9 past paper questions on Investment appraisal, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.