A standard cost is a carefully estimated cost of making one unit, under expected conditions. Comparing actual results with these standards, and splitting the differences into variances, tells managers exactly where performance differed from plan and who is responsible. Paper 4 questions ask you to calculate variances (2 marks each), reconcile budgeted and actual profit or cost, then explain causes and advise.
Standard costing
Standard costing: a system in which standard costs and revenues per unit are set in advance for materials, labour, overheads and selling price, and actual results are compared with them to find variances.
Variance: the difference between a standard (or budgeted) figure and the actual figure. Favourable (F) if it increases profit; adverse (A) if it reduces profit.
Standards are set from past records, engineering studies (time-and-motion), suppliers’ price lists and expected wage rates. An ideal standard assumes perfect conditions (no waste or idle time) — it is rarely met and can demotivate; an attainable standard allows for normal waste and breakdowns, and is the usual choice because it is challenging but achievable.
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| A basis for budgeting and for pricing | Time-consuming and costly to set up and keep up to date |
| Management by exception: managers investigate only significant variances | Standards soon go out of date (inflation, new methods), making variances meaningless |
| Shows where and why costs differ from plan, and who is responsible | Unrealistic standards demotivate; staff may cut quality to avoid adverse variances |
| Motivates staff to meet targets; helps control costs | Less suitable for one-off jobs or rapidly changing products |
| Simplifies inventory valuation (at standard cost) | Variances show what happened, not why — investigation is still needed |
The worked example: data
Lumen Ltd makes one product, a lamp. Its standard cost card:
| Standard cost card (per lamp) | $ |
|---|---|
| Direct materials: 4 kg at $5 per kg | 20 |
| Direct labour: 2 hours at $12 per hour | 24 |
| Fixed overhead: 2 hours at $8 per hour | 16 |
| Standard cost | 60 |
| Standard selling price | 80 |
| Standard profit | 20 |
The budget for March was to make and sell 5,000 lamps. Budgeted fixed overhead was $80,000, so the fixed overhead absorption rate is 80,000 ÷ 10,000 budgeted hours = $8 per labour hour ($16 per lamp). Budgeted profit = 5,000 × $20 = $100,000.
Actual results for March: 4,800 lamps made and sold at $82 each; 19,800 kg of materials bought and used, costing $95,040; 9,900 labour hours worked, costing $123,750; fixed overhead $84,000.
Actual profit = 4,800 × 82 − 95,040 − 123,750 − 84,000 = 393,600 − 302,790 = $90,810.
Before you start, work out the actual prices and the standard quantities for the actual output (always flex to actual output):
- Actual price per kg = 95,040 ÷ 19,800 = $4.80. Actual rate per hour = 123,750 ÷ 9,900 = $12.50.
- Standard quantity for actual output = 4,800 × 4 kg = 19,200 kg. Standard hours for actual output = 4,800 × 2 = 9,600 hours.
Calculating each variance
| Variance | Formula | Lumen Ltd |
|---|---|---|
| Material price | (standard price − actual price) × actual quantity purchased | (5.00 − 4.80) × 19,800 = 3 960 F |
| Material usage | (standard quantity for actual output − actual quantity used) × standard price | (19,200 − 19,800) × 5 = 3 000 A |
| Labour rate | (standard rate − actual rate) × actual hours paid | (12.00 − 12.50) × 9,900 = 4 950 A |
| Labour efficiency | (standard hours for actual output − actual hours worked) × standard rate | (9,600 − 9,900) × 12 = 3 600 A |
| Fixed overhead expenditure | budgeted fixed overhead − actual fixed overhead | 80,000 − 84,000 = 4 000 A |
| Fixed overhead volume | (actual output − budgeted output) × standard fixed overhead per unit (= fixed overhead absorbed − budgeted fixed overhead) | (4,800 − 5,000) × 16 = 3 200 A (76,800 − 80,000) |
| — capacity sub-variance | (actual hours worked − budgeted hours) × absorption rate per hour | (9,900 − 10,000) × 8 = 800 A |
| — efficiency sub-variance | (standard hours for actual output − actual hours worked) × absorption rate per hour | (9,600 − 9,900) × 8 = 2 400 A |
| Sales price | (actual price − standard price) × actual units sold | (82 − 80) × 4,800 = 9 600 F |
| Sales volume (profit) | (actual units sold − budgeted units) × standard profit per unit | (4,800 − 5,000) × 20 = 4 000 A |
The capacity and efficiency sub-variances add up to the volume variance: 800 A + 2,400 A = 3,200 A. Capacity shows that fewer hours were worked than budgeted (so less overhead was absorbed); efficiency shows that the hours worked produced fewer lamps than they should have.
Decide F or A by common sense, not by the sign: paying less than standard, using less than standard, or selling for more is favourable. Always label every variance F or A — an unlabelled variance usually loses the mark.
Reconciliation statements
- Start with the budgeted profit (or the standard cost of actual production).
- Adjust for the sales volume variance first (this gives the standard profit on actual sales), then the sales price variance.
- Add favourable and deduct adverse cost variances, grouped by materials, labour and overheads.
- The result must equal the actual profit (or actual cost) — if it doesn’t, recheck each variance.
| Statement reconciling budgeted profit with actual profit for March | $ | $ |
|---|---|---|
| Budgeted profit (5,000 × $20) | 100 000 | |
| Sales volume variance | (4 000) | |
| Standard profit on actual sales (4,800 × $20) | 96 000 | |
| Sales price variance | 9 600 | |
| Cost variances | ||
| Material price (F) | 3 960 | |
| Material usage (A) | (3 000) | |
| Labour rate (A) | (4 950) | |
| Labour efficiency (A) | (3 600) | |
| Fixed overhead expenditure (A) | (4 000) | |
| Fixed overhead volume (A) | (3 200) | |
| Net cost variances | (14 790) | |
| Actual profit | 90 810 |
The capacity and efficiency sub-variances could replace the single volume line (800 A and 2,400 A). If a question asks you to reconcile cost instead:
| Statement reconciling standard cost of actual production with actual cost | $ | $ |
|---|---|---|
| Standard cost of actual production (4,800 × $60) | 288 000 | |
| Material price (F) | (3 960) | |
| Material usage (A) | 3 000 | |
| Labour rate (A) | 4 950 | |
| Labour efficiency (A) | 3 600 | |
| Fixed overhead expenditure (A) | 4 000 | |
| Fixed overhead volume (A) | 3 200 | |
| Net variances | 14 790 | |
| Actual cost of production | 302 790 |
In a cost reconciliation the signs are reversed: adverse variances are added (cost was higher) and favourable ones deducted.
Causes and interrelationships
| Variance | Possible causes |
|---|---|
| Material price | F: cheaper supplier, bulk discounts, lower-quality material. A: price rises, urgent small orders, better-quality material, loss of discounts |
| Material usage | F: better-quality material, skilled staff, new machinery. A: poor-quality material (more waste), inexperienced staff, faulty machines, theft |
| Labour rate | F: less-skilled (cheaper) staff. A: pay rise, overtime, more-skilled staff |
| Labour efficiency | F: skilled, motivated staff, better materials or machines. A: inexperienced or demotivated staff, poor materials, machine breakdowns |
| Fixed overhead expenditure | Changes in rent, insurance, energy prices, salaries |
| Fixed overhead volume / capacity / efficiency | Output below budget: falling demand, strikes, breakdowns, material shortages (capacity); slow working (efficiency) |
| Sales price | F: price rise, strong demand. A: discounts to win sales, competition |
| Sales volume | F: higher demand, lower price, marketing. A: price rise, competitors, recession, poor quality |
Variances are often linked — look for one cause behind several:
- Lumen bought cheaper material (price 3,960 F), but more of it was wasted (usage 3,000 A), and poor material slowed the workers down (labour efficiency 3,600 A, fixed overhead efficiency 2,400 A). The “saving” on price cost more than it saved.
- A higher selling price (sales price 9,600 F) may have reduced demand (sales volume 4,000 A).
- Paying more for skilled staff (rate A) often brings efficiency F; cheaper staff do the reverse.
Using variances to improve performance: investigate significant variances, hold the right manager responsible (the buyer for price, the production manager for usage and efficiency), update unrealistic standards, and feed the findings into the next budget.
Non-financial factors: product quality and customer complaints, staff morale and turnover, supplier reliability, delivery times, machine reliability, and the effect of targets on behaviour — variances don’t measure these but they often explain them.
Answering the Paper 4 questions
Typical questions: “Calculate the total standard cost of production”; “Prepare a statement reconciling the total standard cost of production with the actual cost”; “Calculate the sales price, sales volume, material price and usage, and labour rate and efficiency variances”; or “Discuss the change in each variance between month 1 and month 2, suggesting one reason for each.”
Paper 4 has two structured questions of 25 marks each: you calculate costs, budgets or variances, then explain, discuss or advise. The written parts are marked on knowledge, analysis and evaluation. Plan every “discuss”, “advise” or “evaluate” answer in the same five steps, in this order:
- Knowledge: state what each variance measures and whether it is favourable or adverse.
- Application: use the figures: the size of each variance and its share of the total difference between budgeted and actual profit.
- Analysis: explain likely causes and links: for example, the favourable material price variance of $3,960 probably reflects cheaper, lower-quality material, which explains the adverse usage and labour efficiency variances.
- Evaluation: judge the overall effect (the cheaper material cost more than it saved), whether the standards are still realistic, who is responsible, and the non-financial effects (quality, morale, customers).
- Conclusion: give a justified recommendation, for example: Lumen should return to its original supplier, because the net effect of the cheaper material was an adverse $5,040 across materials, labour and overhead.
Check yourself
Standard: 3 kg at $6. Actual: 5,000 units made using 15,400 kg costing $89,320. Calculate the material price and usage variances.
Actual price = $5.80. Price = (6.00 − 5.80) × 15,400 = $3,080 F. Usage = (15,000 − 15,400) × 6 = $2,400 A.
Standard: 0.5 hours at $14. Actual: 2,000 units in 1,050 hours costing $14,280. Calculate the labour rate and efficiency variances.
Actual rate = $13.60. Rate = (14.00 − 13.60) × 1,050 = $420 F. Efficiency = (1,000 − 1,050) × 14 = $700 A.
Budgeted fixed overhead $60,000 for 6,000 units (2 hours each); actual output 6,300 units; actual fixed overhead $58,500. Calculate the expenditure and volume variances.
Rate = $10 per unit. Expenditure = 60,000 − 58,500 = $1,500 F. Volume = (6,300 − 6,000) × 10 = $3,000 F.
Standard profit is $15 per unit; budget 2,000 units; actual sales 2,200 units. Calculate the sales volume variance.
(2,200 − 2,000) × 15 = $3,000 F.
Why might a favourable material price variance be bad news?
It may come from lower-quality material, causing adverse usage, labour efficiency and sales variances (more waste, slower work, unhappy customers).
Now practise it
Try the 9 past paper questions on Standard costing and variances, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.