This chapter brings finance into strategy: how managers, investors and other stakeholders use accounting data to make big decisions, and how those decisions in turn change the accounts. It is a regular Paper 4 topic, where you might be asked to evaluate a business’s finance strategy over ten years, or advise which accounting data a manager should use to plan a new strategy.
Using accounting data to make strategic decisions
Financial statements in developing strategy
The statement of profit or loss shows which products, divisions or markets are profitable and where costs are rising; the statement of financial position shows the resources available, how the business is financed and how much more it could borrow. Together they help managers judge whether a strategy is affordable (can it be financed?), whether it is working (are margins and returns improving?), and which parts of the business to grow or close.
The annual report
Public companies publish an annual report, which typically contains: the chair’s statement and directors’ report (review of the year and future plans); the strategic report (objectives, strategy, risks); the financial statements with notes; the auditor’s report (an independent check that the accounts are fair); and often a sustainability or corporate social responsibility report.
| Stakeholder | What they look for |
|---|---|
| Shareholders and potential investors | Profitability, dividends, investment ratios, growth prospects |
| Lenders (banks) | Liquidity and gearing: can the business repay loans and interest? |
| Suppliers | Liquidity: will they be paid on time? |
| Employees and unions | Profit and job security; ability to pay wage rises |
| Government and tax authorities | Profit for tax; compliance with laws |
| Competitors | Performance to benchmark against |
| Community and pressure groups | Social and environmental performance |
The annual report is useful because it is audited and regularly published, but it is historical, written partly as public relations (the narrative sections present the business favourably), and gives only limited detail about individual products or markets.
Ratio analysis in strategic decisions
Assessing performance over time and against competitors
A single ratio says little. Strategy is judged by trends (is ROCE rising or falling over five years?) and by comparison with competitors and the industry average (is our gross margin above or below rivals’?). For example, a falling profit margin while revenue grows may show the business is buying growth with price cuts; liquidity that falls every year may warn of a cash crisis ahead.
How accounting data shapes strategy
Weak liquidity may push a business to cut inventory, chase receivables or postpone expansion. Low ROCE may lead it to sell underperforming assets or divisions. High gearing may rule out further borrowing, making share issues or retained profit the main sources of finance for growth. Strong profitability and low gearing give the confidence to invest or acquire.
How strategic decisions affect ratio results
Debt or equity finance
Example: a company with non-current liabilities of $2m and equity of $8m (gearing = 2 ÷ 10 × 100 = 20%) needs $3m for expansion.
- Borrow $3m: non-current liabilities become $5m; gearing = 5 ÷ 13 × 100 = 38.5%. Interest costs rise, reducing profit for the year and EPS if the expansion doesn’t earn enough; but shareholders keep full control and, if the project earns more than the interest rate, earnings per share rise.
- Issue $3m of shares: equity becomes $11m; gearing = 2 ÷ 13 × 100 = 15.4%. No extra interest, so lower risk; but ownership is diluted, so EPS and control per existing share fall unless profits rise enough.
Either way capital employed rises to $13m, so ROCE falls unless operating profit grows by at least as much.
Dividend strategy
Paying higher dividends raises the dividend yield and pleases shareholders who want income, but lowers dividend cover and retained earnings, leaving less to finance growth (which may then require borrowing, raising gearing). Cutting dividends to retain profit strengthens reserves and finances growth without debt, but can disappoint investors and lower the share price.
Business growth
Growth, especially through takeovers, changes many ratios: revenue and profit rise, but capital employed rises too (so ROCE depends on how profitable the new assets are); borrowing to fund it raises gearing; and rapid growth can strain liquidity as cash is tied up in inventory and receivables (overtrading). In the long run, economies of scale may improve margins.
Other strategies
- Sale and leaseback of property raises cash (better liquidity) and reduces capital employed (higher ROCE), but adds rental costs.
- Cost-cutting raises profit margins and ROCE, but may affect quality and morale.
- JIT and tighter credit control improve inventory turnover, receivables days and liquidity.
- Price cuts may raise revenue but lower gross margin.
Limitations of published accounts and ratio analysis
- Accounts are historical and may not reflect current conditions or future prospects.
- They can be presented favourably (window dressing), for example by delaying payments to suppliers or collecting receivables just before the year end to boost liquidity.
- Accounting choices (depreciation, inventory valuation) affect profit and asset values, so comparisons between businesses are imperfect.
- They don’t value intangible strengths such as staff skills, brand loyalty or innovation pipelines, and give little detail for individual products or markets.
- Inflation and one-off events distort comparisons over time.
- Ratios show what has happened, not why; managers still need to investigate the causes.
Answering the Paper 4 essay
Typical questions: “Evaluate EH’s finance and accounting strategy between 2015 and 2025”; “Advise Idir on what accounting data he should use to help him develop a new business strategy for PI to sell pet insurance”; “Evaluate LC’s business performance between 2014 and 2023”; or “Evaluate the usefulness of accounting data to FSA in the decision to purchase shares in RR” (Paper 3).
Paper 4 essays are worth 20 marks, and Paper 3 questions are marked the same way: on knowledge, application, analysis and evaluation. Plan every answer in the same five steps, in this order:
- Knowledge: define the relevant accounting data and ratios: financial statements, annual report, liquidity, profitability, efficiency, gearing and investment ratios.
- Application: use the case data: calculate and compare ratios over the years and against competitors; identify the key finance decisions (borrowing, share issues, dividends, takeovers) and when they happened.
- Analysis: link decisions to results: for example, financing the 2018 takeover with loans raised gearing to 60%, so when sales fell in 2020, interest payments squeezed profit and the business had to cut dividends.
- Evaluation: judge effectiveness against the business’s objectives; weigh risks taken against returns achieved; recognise the limitations of the data and other factors (the economy, competitors, management) that explain performance.
- Conclusion: give a clear, justified judgement or recommendation, for example: the finance strategy was effective until 2018, but the decision to fund rapid growth mainly by borrowing left the business too exposed when demand fell.
Check yourself
Why would a bank look at a business’s gearing and liquidity before lending?
To judge whether the business can afford to repay the loan and the interest, and how much debt it already has.
A business with non-current liabilities of $4m and equity of $6m borrows another $2m. What happens to gearing?
It rises from 4 ÷ 10 = 40% to 6 ÷ 12 = 50%.
How does paying higher dividends affect dividend cover and retained earnings?
Both fall: profit covers the dividend fewer times and less profit is kept to reinvest.
What is window dressing?
Presenting the accounts in a more favourable light, for example by timing payments and receipts around the year end, to make ratios look better.
Give two items in an annual report and why they are useful.
Any two, for example: financial statements (performance and position); chair’s or strategic report (objectives, plans and risks); auditor’s report (independent check of the accounts); sustainability report (social and environmental performance).
Now practise it
Try the 15 past paper questions on Finance and accounting strategy, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.