← Topical Vault

Investment appraisal Revision notes

Unit 5: Finance and accounting · Chapter 35 · about 13 minutes · written for the 9609 syllabus · last checked 2026-11-17

Should a business buy a new machine, open a new branch or launch a new product? Investment appraisal uses forecast cash flows to judge whether a project is worth its cost and which of several options is best. Paper 3 sets a payback, ARR or NPV calculation in most sessions, followed by a 12-mark “Evaluate whether the business should invest” question.

Why investment appraisal is needed

Investment appraisal: evaluating the profitability or desirability of an investment project, using quantitative methods based on forecast cash flows together with qualitative factors.

Investment decisions involve large sums, are hard to reverse and affect the business for years. Appraisal helps managers compare options objectively, check that a project earns more than the cost of the finance, and justify the decision to owners and lenders.

The worked example

A business is considering a machine costing $100,000, expected to last 4 years and then be sold for $20,000 (residual value). Forecast net cash flows (cash in minus cash out, with the residual value included in year 4):

YearNet cash flow ($)Cumulative cash flow ($)
0(100 000)(100 000)
130 000(70 000)
240 000(30 000)
340 00010 000
450 00060 000

Payback

Payback period: the length of time it takes for a project’s net cash inflows to repay the initial investment.

months into the payback year = amount still to be recovered ÷ net cash flow in that year × 12

Example: after 2 years, $30,000 is still to be recovered; year 3 brings $40,000. 30,000 ÷ 40,000 × 12 = 9 months, so payback = 2 years 9 months.

Strengths: simple and quick; focuses on how soon the money comes back, which matters for businesses short of cash or facing uncertainty (later forecasts are less reliable). Weaknesses: ignores cash flows after payback, so it ignores overall profitability; ignores the timing of cash within the payback period; and doesn’t consider the time value of money.

Accounting rate of return (ARR)

ARR (%) = average annual profit ÷ average investment × 100

average annual profit = (total net cash flows − initial cost) ÷ number of years

average investment = (initial cost + residual value) ÷ 2

Example: total net cash flows = 30 + 40 + 40 + 50 = $160,000; total profit = 160,000 − 100,000 = $60,000; average annual profit = 60,000 ÷ 4 = $15,000. Average investment = (100,000 + 20,000) ÷ 2 = $60,000. ARR = 15,000 ÷ 60,000 × 100 = 25%.

The ARR is compared with the business’s target rate of return, the interest rate on borrowing, or other projects. Strengths: uses all the cash flows over the project’s life; gives a percentage that is easy to compare. Weaknesses: ignores the timing of cash flows (a project paying most of its return early is treated the same as one paying late), and ignores the time value of money.

Use the syllabus formula: divide by the average investment, (cost + residual value) ÷ 2, not the initial cost. And remember to subtract the initial cost before averaging profit.

Net present value (NPV)

Money received in the future is worth less than the same amount today, because money today could be invested to earn interest, and because of inflation and risk. This is the time value of money. Discounted cash flow methods convert future cash flows into their present value using discount factors based on an interest (discount) rate.

Net present value (NPV): the total of the present values of a project’s future net cash flows, minus the initial investment. A positive NPV means the project earns more than the discount rate.

present value = net cash flow × discount factor

NPV = total present values − initial investment

YearNet cash flow ($)Discount factor at 10%Present value ($)
130 0000.90927 270
240 0000.82633 040
340 0000.75130 040
450 0000.68334 150
Total present value124 500

NPV = 124,500 − 100,000 = +$24,500, so on these forecasts the machine is worth buying at a 10% discount rate.

The discount factors are given in the exam. Strengths: takes account of the time value of money and all cash flows; gives a clear decision rule (accept if positive; choose the highest NPV). Weaknesses: more complex to calculate and explain; the choice of discount rate is a judgement and changes the answer; still depends on uncertain forecasts.

Making the investment decision

Quantitative results

Managers compare results against targets (a maximum payback period, a minimum ARR, a positive NPV) and between projects. Different methods can rank projects differently: a project with the fastest payback may have a lower NPV. Using all three gives a fuller picture.

Qualitative factors

  • Fit with the business’s objectives and strategy, such as growth, quality or sustainability.
  • Effects on employees: job losses from automation, retraining needs, morale.
  • Environmental and ethical impact, and the reaction of customers, the community and pressure groups.
  • Risk and reliability of the forecasts; the state of the economy; competitors’ likely reactions.
  • How the investment will be financed, and its effect on gearing and liquidity.
  • Reputation and brand image.

Limitations of investment appraisal

All the methods depend on forecasts of costs and revenues, which may be wrong, especially for new products or long projects; unexpected changes (new competitors, recession, technology, exchange rates) can turn a good project bad. The figures also leave out qualitative factors, which is why the final decision needs judgement as well as numbers.

Answering the Paper 3 and 4 questions

Typical questions: “Calculate the NPV of the IT proposal. Evaluate whether RR should invest in it”; “Calculate the ARR for kiln option A. Evaluate which kiln PP should buy”; “Calculate the payback period for PPP’s proposed new machine”; or “Calculate the payback of the country C location. Evaluate which location KTJ should choose.”

Papers 3 and 4 mark long answers on knowledge, application, analysis and evaluation, and “Analyse” questions stop before evaluation. Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order:

  1. Knowledge: define the method(s) and the time value of money; give the formula.
  2. Application: calculate accurately with the case data, showing working, and compare the results between options and with targets or the cost of borrowing.
  3. Analysis: explain what the results mean: for example, option A pays back sooner, which reduces risk and helps a business short of cash, but option B has the higher NPV, so it adds more value over its life.
  4. Evaluation: question the reliability of the forecasts and discount rate, and weigh qualitative factors (objectives, staff, environment, finance, risk). Consider which method matters most for this business.
  5. Conclusion: give a justified recommendation, for example: the business should buy the machine because the NPV is strongly positive and payback is within its three-year target, provided the sales forecast is realistic.

Check yourself

A project costs $50,000 and returns $20,000 in year 1 and $40,000 in year 2. What is its payback period?

After year 1, $30,000 remains; 30,000 ÷ 40,000 × 12 = 9 months, so 1 year 9 months.

A project costs $80,000, has a residual value of $0 and total net cash flows of $120,000 over 5 years. Calculate its ARR.

Average profit = (120,000 − 80,000) ÷ 5 = $8,000; average investment = (80,000 + 0) ÷ 2 = $40,000; ARR = 20%.

What does a negative NPV mean?

The project’s discounted future cash flows are less than its cost, so it earns less than the discount rate and should not go ahead on financial grounds.

Give one weakness of payback and one of ARR.

Payback ignores cash flows after the payback point (and profitability); ARR ignores the timing of cash flows and the time value of money.

Give three qualitative factors in an investment decision.

Any three of: fit with objectives; effect on employees; environmental and ethical impact; risk and reliability of forecasts; financing and gearing; reputation; competitor reactions.

Now practise it

Try the 21 past paper questions on Investment appraisal, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.

Practise Investment appraisal questions →