How do we know whether a country is “developed”, or whether people are better off than they were ten years ago? This topic covers the different ways of measuring living standards and development, and the problems with each. It is one of the most examined parts of Unit 11: Paper 4 essays regularly ask whether GDP or GNI is a good enough measure, and how it compares with the HDI, MEW or MPI.
Growth and development
Economic growth is an increase in real output. Economic development is much broader: an improvement in people’s quality of life, including higher incomes but also better health, education and nutrition, less poverty, a cleaner environment, more equality of opportunity and greater freedom. Growth usually helps development, but a country can grow without developing much, for example if the gains go to a small elite or come with heavy pollution.
Classifying economies
- Developed and developing. Developed economies usually have high incomes per head, strong institutions, advanced infrastructure, high productivity and a large tertiary sector. Developing economies have lower incomes, depend on fewer products, have a larger primary sector and lower productivity. Some organisations now avoid these labels, since every country is still developing in some way.
- By income. The World Bank divides countries into low-income, lower middle-income, upper middle-income and high-income using GNI per head. Roughly, low-income means below about $1,100 a year and high-income above about $14,000; the thresholds are updated every July for inflation, and countries move between groups.
- By human development. The UN groups countries by their HDI score: very high, high, medium and low human development.
Income classification is simple and helps target aid, but it hides a lot: countries in the same group can be very different (Saudi Arabia relies heavily on oil, yet has a high income per head), and it says nothing about health, education or inequality.
Poverty cycles
Poverty cycle: a set of links that keeps a country poor. Low incomes mean low saving, so low investment, so low productivity and low growth, so incomes stay low.
A second cycle runs through people: low incomes mean poor education and healthcare, so low human capital and productivity, so low incomes. These cycles create development traps. They can be broken by aid, foreign investment, remittances, or government spending on education and health.
Monetary indicators
The usual starting point is real national income per head:
- GDP: the value of output produced within the country;
- GNI = GDP + net income from abroad (profits, interest and dividends earned abroad minus those paid abroad);
- NNI = GNI − depreciation (the capital used up in production).
It must be real (adjusted for inflation) and per head (divided by the population), otherwise a country could look richer just because prices or its population rose.
Purchasing power parity
Purchasing power parity (PPP): converting incomes into a common currency using an exchange rate that reflects how much each currency actually buys, rather than the market exchange rate.
Example: people in country X earn 120,000 pesos a year on average. At the market rate of 40 pesos = $1, that is $3,000. But a basket of goods costing $100 in the USA costs only 2,000 pesos in X, so the PPP rate is 20 pesos = $1. At PPP, income per head is 120,000 ÷ 20 = $6,000. Prices are lower in X, so people there can buy twice as much as the market exchange rate suggests.
Market exchange rates usually understate living standards in low-income countries, where many goods and services are cheap, and they swing with speculation. That is why international comparisons use PPP. A simple version is the Big Mac index, which compares the price of the same burger in different countries.
Problems with GDP per head as a measure of living standards
- Distribution: an average hides inequality; GDP per head can rise while many people become worse off.
- The shadow (informal) economy: undeclared work, to avoid tax or because it is illegal, isn’t counted, and its size differs between countries and over time.
- Non-marketed output: housework, caring, subsistence farming and voluntary work aren’t counted, and are especially large in low-income countries.
- Data quality: where literacy is low and many work informally, figures are partly estimates.
- Quality and composition: GDP measures quantity, not quality; and spending on weapons, police or cleaning up pollution raises GDP without making people better off.
- Leisure and working conditions: people may produce more by working longer hours in worse conditions.
- The environment: pollution and the using-up of natural resources aren’t subtracted.
- Happiness: beyond a certain point, extra income may add little to well-being, as wants rise with incomes.
Non-monetary and composite indicators
Non-monetary indicators measure aspects of development directly: life expectancy, infant mortality, literacy rates, years of schooling, doctors per 1,000 people, access to clean water and sanitation, internet access.
The Human Development Index (HDI)
Human Development Index: a UN composite measure combining three dimensions: income (GNI per head at PPP), education (expected years and mean years of schooling) and health (life expectancy at birth). It runs from 0 to 1.
- Strengths: broader than income alone; easy to compare; shows countries that turn income into well-being well or badly. Cuba ranks much higher on HDI than on GNI per head, thanks to strong health and education; some oil-rich Gulf states rank lower on HDI than on income.
- Weaknesses: only three dimensions (it leaves out inequality, the environment, freedom and working conditions); the equal weighting is a value judgement; years of schooling say nothing about the quality of education; life expectancy says nothing about quality of life; data can be unreliable.
The Measure of Economic Welfare (MEW)
Measure of Economic Welfare: GDP adjusted to give a fuller picture of welfare. It adds things that improve living standards but aren’t counted (leisure time, housework, voluntary work) and subtracts things that reduce them (pollution, commuting costs, defence spending).
It is closer to what people actually experience, but valuing leisure, housework or pollution in money is very difficult and subjective, so it is rarely calculated officially.
The Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI)
Multidimensional Poverty Index: measures the share of people who are deprived across three equally weighted dimensions: health (child mortality, nutrition), education (years of schooling, school attendance) and living standards (cooking fuel, sanitation, drinking water, electricity, housing, assets). A household deprived in at least a third of the weighted indicators counts as poor.
It shows who is poor and why, which helps governments target help (for example, Rwanda’s MPI poverty fell sharply as access to clean water and sanitation improved). But the choice and weighting of indicators can be questioned, and it focuses on the poorest rather than on the living standards of the whole population.
The Kuznets curve
Kuznets curve: the idea that as a country develops, income inequality first rises and then falls, giving an inverted U shape.
The evidence is mixed. Many countries have followed this path, but inequality has risen again in some high-income countries, such as the USA, since the 1980s, and some developing countries have grown without big rises in inequality. So it is a possible pattern, not a law.
Comparing living standards
Over time
A rise in real GDP per head usually means people are better off, but check: has inequality changed? Has the informal economy grown or shrunk? Has the quality of products improved? Have working hours and conditions changed? Has the environment got worse? Is the growth sustainable? And remember the trade-off: shifting resources to capital goods lowers consumption now but raises it later.
Between countries
Convert at PPP, not market exchange rates; use real figures per head; and allow for differences in the size of the shadow economy, non-marketed output, data quality, inequality, working hours, climate (heating costs) and what output is used for. Combining GDP per head with non-monetary and composite indicators gives a much more reliable picture.
Answering the Paper 4 essay
Typical questions: “Consider whether the use of gross national income alone is sufficient to measure the standard of living in a high-income country”; “Consider the relative merits of GNI and the Multidimensional Poverty Index as measures of the standard of living”; or “To what extent do you agree that an increase in productivity will lead to a higher standard of living in low-income countries?”
Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:
- Knowledge: define standard of living and economic development, GDP, GNI and NNI per head, real values, PPP, and the composite measures in the question (HDI, MEW, MPI) with their components.
- Application: use real comparisons: Cuba’s HDI rank above its income rank and some Gulf states the other way round; Rwanda’s fall in MPI poverty; rising inequality in the USA despite high income per head; large informal economies in many low-income countries.
- Analysis: explain why GNI per head reflects living standards (more income buys more goods and services, and funds health and education) and then each way it falls short (distribution, informal and non-marketed output, environment, leisure, quality). Explain how the alternative measure tackles some of these.
- Evaluation: every measure has limits: composite indicators leave things out and their weights are value judgements; MEW is hard to calculate; MPI focuses on the poorest. The best measure depends on the purpose (comparing incomes, targeting poverty, judging development) and on the type of country (informal output matters far more in a low-income country).
- Conclusion: make a judgement: for example, GNI per head at PPP is a useful starting point and is closely linked to most other indicators, but it is not sufficient on its own; it should be used alongside indicators such as the HDI or MPI.
Check yourself
What are the three dimensions of the HDI?
Income (GNI per head at PPP), education (expected and mean years of schooling) and health (life expectancy at birth).
Why are incomes in low-income countries usually compared at PPP rather than market exchange rates?
Many goods and services are cheaper in low-income countries, so market exchange rates understate how much people can actually buy. PPP rates reflect real purchasing power, and also avoid distortion from speculation in currency markets.
Give three reasons why a rise in real GDP per head may not mean higher living standards.
Any three of: inequality may have increased; the extra output could be weapons or pollution clean-up; working hours may be longer or conditions worse; environmental damage; quality may have fallen; changes in the informal economy; population counted inaccurately.
What does the Kuznets curve suggest happens to inequality as a country develops?
It first rises (as some workers move into higher-paid industry) and then falls (as education, taxes and benefits spread the gains): an inverted U.
How does the MEW differ from GDP?
It adds the value of things that raise welfare but aren’t counted in GDP (leisure, housework, voluntary work) and subtracts things that reduce welfare (pollution, commuting, defence spending).
Now practise it
Try the 51 past paper questions on Economic development, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.