At AS Level you learned the types of unemployment and their costs. At A Level the question becomes: which kind of unemployment is it, and so which policy will actually work? This topic gives you the tools to answer that, using the aggregate labour market diagram, the idea of a natural rate of unemployment, and labour mobility. Paper 4 essays usually ask you to evaluate policies to reduce unemployment.
Full employment
Full employment: the level of employment where everyone who wants to work at the current wage has a job, apart from people briefly between jobs (frictional unemployment).
Full employment doesn’t mean 0% unemployment. At any moment, some people are changing jobs or have just started looking. Many governments treat an unemployment rate of around 3–5% as close to full employment, though the figure differs between countries.
A quick reminder of the types
| Type | Cause | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Frictional | Time spent moving between jobs and searching for work | A graduate searching for their first job |
| Structural | Long-term changes in the economy: some industries decline and workers lack the skills or location for new jobs | Coal miners after mines close; workers replaced by automation |
| Cyclical (demand-deficient) | Too little aggregate demand in a downturn | Construction workers laid off in a recession |
| Seasonal | Demand varies with the seasons | Holiday resort staff out of season |
| Real wage (classical) | Wages held above the market-clearing level | Unions or a minimum wage set above equilibrium |
Equilibrium and disequilibrium unemployment
The aggregate labour market uses three curves:
- ADL: the aggregate demand for labour (all firms), which slopes down: at a lower real wage, firms want more workers.
- ASL: the workers who are willing and able to accept a job at each real wage.
- ALF: the whole aggregate labour force, including people who are looking for a better job, are between jobs, or lack the skills or location for the jobs on offer.
Equilibrium unemployment: unemployment that exists even when the labour market is in equilibrium (ADL = ASL). It consists of frictional, structural and other voluntary unemployment, and is a supply-side problem.
Disequilibrium unemployment: unemployment caused by the supply of labour being greater than the demand for labour at the current real wage. It is mainly cyclical unemployment.
Notice that the ALF curve gets closer to ASL as the real wage rises: a higher wage persuades more of the labour force to accept the jobs on offer.
Why doesn’t the wage just fall to clear the market? Workers resist pay cuts, contracts fix wages for a time, and minimum wages set a floor. Keynesian economists add that even if wages did fall, workers would have less to spend, so aggregate demand (and demand for labour) could fall further: a downward spiral. So disequilibrium unemployment can last a long time.
An economy can have both kinds at once: some disequilibrium unemployment from a recession on top of its equilibrium unemployment.
Voluntary and involuntary unemployment
Voluntary unemployment: people who could get a job at the current wage but choose not to take it, for example because they are searching for a better-paid job, or benefits are close to the wage on offer.
Involuntary unemployment: people who are willing to work at the current wage but can’t find a job.
Cyclical unemployment and most structural unemployment are involuntary. Some frictional (search) unemployment is voluntary. In practice it is hard to tell them apart: is a laid-off scientist who turns down a job as a cleaner voluntarily unemployed?
Hysteresis
Hysteresis: when unemployment itself causes more unemployment in the future, because people who are out of work for a long time lose skills, confidence and the habit of work, and employers become unwilling to hire them.
Hysteresis means a temporary rise in cyclical unemployment can turn into lasting structural unemployment, so the natural rate rises after a long recession. It is a strong argument for acting quickly in a downturn and for retraining the long-term unemployed (those out of work for a year or more).
The natural rate of unemployment
Natural rate of unemployment: the rate of unemployment when the labour market is in equilibrium (ADL = ASL) and inflation is stable. It is the equilibrium unemployment the economy tends to return to in the long run.
What determines it
The natural rate depends on supply-side factors: anything that affects people’s willingness or ability to take the jobs on offer.
- How generous unemployment benefits are compared with low pay.
- Minimum wage levels and trade union power.
- The quality of education and training, and how well workers’ skills match the jobs available.
- How good the information is about vacancies and workers.
- Geographical and occupational mobility of labour.
- How flexible workers and firms are (hours, contracts, where work is done).
- Hysteresis from past recessions.
Policy implications
New classical (free market) economists argue that raising aggregate demand can’t keep unemployment below the natural rate for long. Extra demand pushes up wages and prices; once workers realise prices have risen too, real wages fall back, and unemployment returns to the natural rate, but with higher inflation. So the way to cut unemployment permanently is to lower the natural rate with supply-side policies:
- widen the gap between benefits and pay (lower benefits or lower income tax on low earners);
- improve education, training and retraining (especially for the long-term unemployed);
- improve information about jobs (job centres, online matching);
- increase labour mobility (housing, transport, recognition of qualifications);
- increase labour market flexibility: some favour reducing union power and minimum wage rules, though this is controversial because it can reduce workers’ pay and security.
Keynesian economists accept that supply-side policies matter, but argue that much unemployment, especially in recessions, is demand-deficient and needs demand-side policy.
Labour mobility
Occupational mobility: the ability of workers to change from one type of job to another.
Geographical mobility: the ability of workers to move to a job in a different place.
Low mobility is a major cause of structural unemployment: there can be unemployed workers in one place or occupation and unfilled vacancies in another.
| Occupational mobility depends on | Geographical mobility depends on |
|---|---|
| Education and training: the more general skills workers have, the easier it is to switch | The price and availability of housing in the new area |
| Information about which occupations are growing | Information about jobs elsewhere |
| Barriers to entry: long qualifications, licences, professional bodies | Family and personal ties |
| Time: given time, workers can retrain | Between countries: immigration rules, language, culture, recognition of qualifications, cost of living |
Patterns and trends
Unemployment is not spread evenly. It is usually higher:
- in declining industries and occupations, and in regions with poor transport links or infrastructure;
- among young people (firms prefer experienced workers and must train the young);
- among groups who face discrimination, such as some ethnic minorities, women in some countries, and people with disabilities.
How serious unemployment is depends on its duration as well as its rate: long-term unemployment does the most damage because of hysteresis.
Employment patterns have also changed:
- as countries develop, employment shifts from the primary sector (farming, mining) to the secondary (manufacturing) and then the tertiary (services);
- a rising share of women in the labour force, as pay, qualifications, childcare and job opportunities improve;
- more self-employment and part-time work;
- growth of insecure work in the gig economy, with no guaranteed hours, sick pay or pension;
- a large informal economy in many developing countries, where workers have no legal protection;
- shifts between public and private sector employment, for example after privatisation.
Policies to reduce unemployment
The key to any answer: match the policy to the cause.
| Cause | Policies | Main problems |
|---|---|---|
| Cyclical (lack of AD) | Expansionary fiscal policy (cut taxes, raise spending); expansionary monetary policy (cut interest rates, increase the money supply); a lower exchange rate to boost net exports | Time lags; low confidence may stop people spending; firms may buy machines rather than hire; inflation if AD rises too much; more government borrowing |
| Frictional | Better information about jobs; a wider gap between benefits and pay | Cutting benefits causes hardship and, in a recession, cuts spending |
| Structural | Education, training and retraining; help with moving; regional policy to attract firms to areas of high unemployment | Expensive and slow; workers may be trained in the wrong skills; firms may not move |
| Real wage | Reducing union power; not raising the minimum wage | Lower pay and job security; may increase inequality and poverty |
A supply-side policy won’t fix cyclical unemployment. Training people for jobs that don’t exist in a recession doesn’t create the jobs, and cutting benefits then reduces spending and can make cyclical unemployment worse. Always identify the type of unemployment first.
Answering the Paper 4 essay
Typical questions: “Assess the extent to which monetary policy can be used effectively to solve the problem of unemployment”; “Government policies which rely on increasing budget deficits to solve unemployment will not be successful because they do not affect the natural rate of unemployment. Discuss”; or “Evaluate the policies available to a government to reduce the level of structural unemployment.”
Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:
- Knowledge: define full employment, the type(s) of unemployment involved, equilibrium and disequilibrium unemployment, the natural rate, and the policy in the question (fiscal, monetary or supply-side).
- Application: apply it to a real situation: rising unemployment in a recession, youth unemployment in southern Europe, structural unemployment as coal mines or plantations close, or automation replacing drivers and factory workers.
- Analysis: use the aggregate labour market diagram to show which kind of unemployment you are dealing with, then explain the chain of the policy: for example, lower interest rates make borrowing cheaper, so consumption and investment rise, AD rises, firms need more workers, ADL shifts right and cyclical unemployment falls. Show that the same policy does nothing to the gap between ASL and ALF.
- Evaluation: what kind of unemployment is it? How confident are households and firms (monetary policy has little effect in a deep slump or when interest rates are already near zero)? How long are the time lags? Could the policy cause inflation or a bigger budget deficit? Are supply-side policies affordable, and how long will they take? Could hysteresis mean waiting is costly?
- Conclusion: make a judgement: for example, demand-side policy is effective against cyclical unemployment but can’t lower the natural rate, so a combination is needed, with the balance depending on the main cause in that country.
Check yourself
What is the difference between equilibrium and disequilibrium unemployment?
Equilibrium unemployment exists even when the demand for labour equals the number willing to accept jobs at the going wage (frictional, structural, voluntary). Disequilibrium unemployment occurs when the supply of labour exceeds the demand at the current real wage, for example in a recession with sticky wages.
What is hysteresis, and why does it matter for policy?
When long periods of unemployment cause more unemployment later, because people lose skills, confidence and the work habit, and employers avoid hiring them. It means recessions can permanently raise the natural rate, so acting quickly and retraining the long-term unemployed are important.
Give three factors that determine the natural rate of unemployment.
Any three of: the level of benefits compared with low pay; minimum wages and union power; the quality of education and training; information about vacancies; labour mobility; labour market flexibility; hysteresis.
Why might a cut in unemployment benefit fail to reduce unemployment in a recession?
If the unemployment is cyclical, there aren’t enough jobs, so pushing people to search harder doesn’t create work. And lower benefits reduce the unemployed’s spending, lowering aggregate demand and possibly raising cyclical unemployment.
Give two reasons why an unemployed worker might not move to a region with job vacancies.
Any two of: housing there is too expensive or unavailable; they don’t know about the jobs; family and personal ties; the cost of moving; their skills don’t match the vacancies.
Now practise it
Try the 91 past paper questions on Employment and unemployment, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.