This topic explains what money is, how banks create most of it, and how interest rates are set. It is the theory behind monetary policy, so it links directly to the policy chapters in Unit 10. Paper 4 essays on it are common and fairly predictable: the quantity theory of money, quantitative easing, the transmission mechanism and the Keynesian theory of interest rates come up again and again.
What money is
Money: anything that is generally acceptable as a means of payment.
The four functions of money
- Medium of exchange: people sell goods for money and use the money to buy other goods, which avoids the need for a double coincidence of wants (in barter, each side must want exactly what the other has).
- Store of value: money can be saved and spent later.
- Unit of account: prices are expressed in money, so the value of different items can be compared.
- Standard of deferred payment: money allows borrowing and lending, and agreements to pay in the future.
The characteristics of good money
To do these jobs, money must be: generally acceptable (the most important), recognisable, portable, divisible into small units, homogeneous (every unit identical), durable, limited in supply, and hard to counterfeit.
When inflation is very high, money stops working as a store of value and a unit of account, and people switch to a foreign currency, as happened in Zimbabwe in 2008–09. Cryptocurrencies such as bitcoin can be used for some payments, but most shops don’t accept them and their value swings wildly, so they don’t yet fully work as money.
The money supply
Money supply: the total amount of money in the economy: currency plus bank deposits.
Narrow money: money that can be spent directly: notes and coins in circulation, cash held by banks, and banks’ balances at the central bank (the monetary base).
Broad money: narrow money plus money held mainly for saving, such as savings accounts.
Most money is not cash but bank deposits, moved by cards, transfers and phone apps.
The quantity theory of money
MV = PT (often written MV = PY)
- M: the money supply.
- V: the velocity of circulation: how many times, on average, each unit of money is spent in a year.
- P: the average price level.
- T (or Y): the number of transactions, or real output.
As an equation, MV = PT is always true: both sides measure total spending. It becomes a theory when monetarists assume that V and T are constant (V depends on payment habits, which change slowly; T is fixed at full-employment output in the long run). Then any increase in M must cause the same percentage increase in P.
Worked example
M = $50bn and V = 6, so total spending MV = $300bn. Real output T = 150bn units, so P = 300 ÷ 150 = 2.
The money supply rises by 20% to $60bn. If V and T don’t change, MV = $360bn, so P = 360 ÷ 150 = 2.4: a 20% rise in the price level, the same as the rise in M.
You can also rearrange it: V = PT ÷ M. If nominal national income is $60bn and the money supply is $12bn, V = 60 ÷ 12 = 5.
Monetarists vs Keynesians
- Monetarists (such as Milton Friedman): “inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon.” Inflation is caused by the money supply growing faster than output, so the government’s main job is to control the growth of the money supply.
- Keynesians argue that V and T are not constant:
- V changes: people hold more money when confidence is low or interest rates are low, and spend it faster when they expect inflation; new payment technology also changes V.
- T changes: if there is spare capacity, more money can raise output rather than prices.
- Causation may run the other way: rising prices (from cost-push pressures) can lead banks to lend more, increasing M.
The evidence is mixed. Countries with very fast money growth, such as those with hyperinflation, always have high inflation. But after 2008 many central banks expanded the money supply hugely through quantitative easing and inflation stayed low for years, because V fell and there was a lot of spare capacity.
Commercial banks
Commercial (retail or high street) banks:
- provide deposit accounts: demand deposit (current) accounts for making and receiving payments, and savings deposit accounts that pay interest;
- lend: overdrafts (permission to spend more than is in your account, for short-term needs) and loans (a set amount for a set time and purpose);
- hold a range of assets: cash, balances at the central bank, government securities (bills and bonds), loans to customers, and equities (shares).
Objectives: liquidity, security and profitability
Liquidity: how quickly and easily an asset can be turned into cash without loss.
Banks make most of their profit from lending, especially longer-term and riskier loans. But they must also keep enough liquid assets to pay customers who want their money, and stay secure (avoid losses that could make them fail). These aims conflict: cash is perfectly liquid and safe but earns nothing; long-term loans are profitable but illiquid and risky. Banks have to balance them.
Reserve ratio: the proportion of a bank’s deposits that it keeps as liquid assets.
Capital ratio: a bank’s own financial capital (shareholders’ funds and retained profits) as a percentage of its risky assets. A higher capital ratio means the bank can absorb bigger losses without failing.
How banks create money
When a bank makes a loan, it credits the borrower’s account: new money is created. Because people mostly pay by card or transfer, the money stays in the banking system as someone else’s deposit, which can then be lent again. So banks can create deposits many times bigger than their liquid assets.
Bank credit multiplier = 1 ÷ reserve ratio
Worked example
Banks keep a reserve ratio of 10%, so the credit multiplier is 1 ÷ 0.1 = 10. A customer deposits $1,000 of new cash.
| Round | New deposit ($) | Kept as reserves (10%) | Lent out (90%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1,000 | 100 | 900 |
| 2 | 900 | 90 | 810 |
| 3 | 810 | 81 | 729 |
| … and so on | |||
| Total | 10,000 | 1,000 | 9,000 |
Total deposits can rise to $1,000 × 10 = $10,000, of which $9,000 is new lending (total deposits minus the original deposit).
In practice banks create less than this, because:
- there may not be enough creditworthy households and firms who want to borrow (especially in a recession);
- people keep some money as cash, which leaks out of the banking system;
- banks may choose to hold more reserves than required when they are worried about risk;
- regulators set minimum reserve and capital ratios.
The multiplier works in reverse too. If banks lose confidence or customers rush to withdraw money (a “run on the bank”, as in 2008), lending and the money supply can shrink sharply. Banking depends on confidence.
What changes the money supply
In an open economy, the money supply increases when:
- Commercial banks lend more (through the credit multiplier).
- The government runs a budget deficit financed by borrowing from banks or the central bank. If the government sells securities to the central bank or commercial banks, the money it spends adds to bank deposits and liquid assets. (If it borrows from the non-bank public instead, people use existing deposits to buy the securities, so the money supply doesn’t rise.)
- The central bank carries out quantitative easing (below).
- More money flows into the country than out through the balance of payments (the total currency flow): for example, export revenue or foreign investment deposited in domestic banks.
The central bank
A country’s central bank:
- issues bank notes;
- is the bank of the commercial banks: they hold accounts there to settle payments with each other;
- acts as lender of last resort to banks in difficulty, to stop a collapse spreading;
- is the government’s bank and manages its borrowing;
- carries out monetary policy: setting the main interest rate and influencing the money supply;
- regulates banks, and may manage the exchange rate and foreign currency reserves.
Quantitative easing
Quantitative easing (QE): the central bank creates new money to buy government bonds and other securities from banks and other financial institutions, to increase the money supply and push down long-term interest rates.
It is used when the central bank’s interest rate is already close to zero and can’t usefully be cut further (Japan from the 2000s, the USA and UK after 2008, many countries in 2020). Banks receive new reserves and should lend more; bond prices rise so long-term interest rates fall; asset prices rise, making people feel wealthier. All of this is meant to raise spending and aggregate demand.
Evaluation: it helped prevent deeper recessions, but banks may simply hold the extra reserves if they don’t want to lend; it pushed up share and house prices, benefiting the wealthy most and increasing inequality; and if it continues for too long, it risks higher inflation later.
How monetary policy works: the transmission mechanism
Monetary transmission mechanism: the chain of effects by which a change in interest rates or the money supply affects aggregate demand, and then output, employment and the price level.
Why it might not work as expected: each link can break. If confidence is very low, people and firms won’t borrow however cheap credit is; banks may not pass on lower rates; the effects take a long time (often 18 months to two years) to reach inflation; and in a liquidity trap, interest rates can’t be cut any further.
Policies to reduce inflation, and how well they work
- Contractionary monetary policy: higher interest rates or slower money growth reduce borrowing and spending (demand-pull inflation).
- Contractionary fiscal policy: higher taxes or lower government spending reduce aggregate demand.
- Supply-side policy: training, investment incentives and competition raise productivity and reduce costs (cost-push inflation) in the long run.
Their effectiveness depends on:
- Identifying the cause correctly. Cutting demand when inflation is cost-push (for example, from higher oil prices) mainly raises unemployment, without much effect on prices. In practice, inflation is often a mix of both.
- Time lags and forecasts. By the time policy works, inflation may already have fallen, so the policy deepens a downturn.
- How people react. Optimistic households may keep spending despite higher interest rates; credible central banks can lower inflation expectations, which makes the job easier.
- Constraints. Members of a monetary union (like the eurozone) can’t set their own interest rate; high taxes may drive skilled workers and firms abroad; controlling the money supply is hard because banks find ways round limits.
- Side effects: higher unemployment, slower growth, a stronger exchange rate that hurts exporters, and a heavier burden on borrowers.
The demand for money: liquidity preference
Liquidity preference: Keynes’s theory of why people choose to hold their wealth as money (which earns little or no interest) rather than in interest-earning assets such as bonds.
There are three motives:
- Transactions motive: money to pay for everyday purchases. It rises with income.
- Precautionary motive: money held for unexpected expenses or opportunities. It also rises with income.
- Speculative motive: money held instead of bonds, when people expect bond prices to fall. It depends on the interest rate.
Transactions and precautionary balances (called active balances) depend mainly on income, so they are interest inelastic. Speculative balances (idle balances) are interest elastic.
Why bond prices and interest rates move in opposite directions
A bond pays a fixed amount of interest each year. If a bond pays $5 a year and costs $100, the return is 5%. If its price rises to $125, the same $5 is only a 4% return. So when bond prices are high, interest rates are low.
When interest rates are low (bond prices high), people expect bond prices to fall, and holding bonds risks a capital loss while earning little. So they prefer to hold money: speculative demand is high. When interest rates are high, bonds are cheap and attractive, so people hold less money. This is why the demand for money curve slopes down.
How the interest rate is determined
Keynesian (liquidity preference) theory
The interest rate is set where the demand for money (liquidity preference, L) equals the supply of money, which is set by the central bank, so it is drawn vertical.
Liquidity trap: when interest rates are so low that people expect them to rise (and bond prices to fall), they hold any extra money rather than buying bonds. The demand for money becomes perfectly elastic, so increasing the money supply can’t reduce the interest rate any further, and monetary policy loses its power.
This is why governments in deep recessions with near-zero interest rates (Japan for many years, much of the world after 2008) turned to quantitative easing and fiscal policy.
Loanable funds theory
The interest rate is the price that balances the supply of loanable funds (from saving, which rises with the interest rate) and the demand for loanable funds (mainly for investment, plus household and government borrowing, which falls as the interest rate rises).
Comparing the two
| Loanable funds | Liquidity preference (Keynesian) | |
|---|---|---|
| Interest rate depends on | Real factors: saving and investment | Monetary factors: the demand for and supply of money |
| Role of interest rate | The reward for saving; it brings saving and investment into balance | The reward for giving up liquidity (holding bonds instead of money) |
| Main weakness | Saving depends mainly on income, not interest rates, and is done by different people for different reasons than investment | The demand for money is hard to measure and can be unstable |
Keynes argued that the interest rate does not automatically make saving equal investment: if people save more, incomes fall (the paradox of thrift) rather than the interest rate falling enough to raise investment.
Answering the Paper 4 essay
Typical questions: “Evaluate whether the quantity theory of money is a satisfactory explanation of the cause of inflation”; “Central banks can control the money supply. An increase in the money supply will cause inflation, therefore central banks can control inflation. Evaluate this statement”; or “Explain what is meant by quantitative easing and consider whether it is an effective policy in a recession.”
Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:
- Knowledge: define money supply, MV = PT and each term, the credit multiplier, quantitative easing, or liquidity preference, as the question needs.
- Application: use real cases: hyperinflation in Zimbabwe or Venezuela (fast money growth and fast inflation), QE in the USA, UK and Japan after 2008 and in 2020 (huge money growth, low inflation for years), and central banks raising interest rates to fight inflation in 2022–23.
- Analysis: explain the chain: for the quantity theory, if V and T are constant, a rise in M must raise P by the same percentage; for QE, central bank purchases raise banks’ reserves and bond prices, lower long-term interest rates and raise asset prices, so spending and AD rise. Use the liquidity preference diagram to show the effect of more money on the interest rate, and the liquidity trap.
- Evaluation: V and T are not constant (V fell sharply after 2008; output can rise when there is spare capacity); causation may run from prices to money; central banks can’t fully control broad money because banks decide how much to lend; inflation can be cost-push; in a liquidity trap more money doesn’t lower interest rates; QE may raise asset prices and inequality more than spending.
- Conclusion: make a judgement: for example, the quantity theory explains long-run and extreme inflation well, but in the short run and with spare capacity it is a poor guide, so it is only a partly satisfactory explanation.
Check yourself
What is the single most important characteristic of money?
It must be generally acceptable as a means of payment. Without that, it can’t do any of its functions.
A country’s money supply is $10bn and its nominal national income is $40bn. What is the velocity of circulation? If the money supply rises to $12bn and national income to $60bn, what happens to V?
V = 40 ÷ 10 = 4. Afterwards V = 60 ÷ 12 = 5, so velocity rises from 4 to 5.
A bank keeps a reserve ratio of 5% and receives a new deposit of $10,000. What is the credit multiplier, and how much can total deposits and new lending rise?
Multiplier = 1 ÷ 0.05 = 20. Total deposits can rise by $10,000 × 20 = $200,000, of which new lending is $200,000 − $10,000 = $190,000.
A central bank buys government securities from commercial banks. What happens to the money supply and the interest rate?
The money supply increases (banks have more reserves to lend), and the interest rate falls (higher bond prices mean lower yields, and more money is available).
When would an increase in the money supply have no effect on the rate of interest?
In a liquidity trap, when the demand for money is perfectly interest elastic at a very low interest rate: people simply hold the extra money instead of buying bonds.
Why are a bank’s objectives of profitability and liquidity in conflict?
The most profitable assets (long-term loans) are the least liquid, while the most liquid assets (cash, central bank balances) earn little or nothing. Holding more of one means less of the other.
Now practise it
Try the 76 past paper questions on Money and banking, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.