The final topic of the course ties together trade, multinational companies, exchange rates and development. It asks how the world economy has become so closely connected, who gains and who loses, and what happens when countries form trading blocs. Paper 4 essays usually ask whether globalisation benefits high-income countries at the expense of low-income ones, or whether joining a free trade area is always beneficial.
What globalisation is
Globalisation: the growing integration of the world’s economies through trade in goods and services, flows of capital and investment, movement of people, and the spread of technology and ideas.
Signs of it include the rapid growth of world trade, global supply chains (a smartphone may contain parts from a dozen countries), the expansion of multinational companies, huge cross-border flows of money, and more international migration.
Causes
- Lower transport costs, especially container shipping and cheaper air freight.
- Information and communication technology: the internet makes it cheap to coordinate production worldwide and to trade services.
- Trade liberalisation: tariffs have fallen through the WTO and many trade agreements.
- Freer movement of capital: most countries have removed controls on investment flows.
- Growth of multinational companies and their global supply chains.
- The opening up of large economies, especially China from the late 1970s, India from the 1990s and the former communist countries of Eastern Europe.
Consequences
Benefits
- Countries can specialise according to comparative advantage, raising world output.
- Economies of scale from serving bigger markets, so lower prices and more choice for consumers.
- More competition, pushing firms to be efficient and innovative.
- Faster spread of technology and ideas.
- Investment flows to where it is most productive, including FDI into developing countries.
- Faster growth: hundreds of millions of people, especially in East and South Asia, have escaped extreme poverty as their countries joined the world economy.
Costs
- Structural unemployment where industries can’t compete: many manufacturing jobs in high-income countries moved to lower-cost countries.
- Rising inequality within countries: skilled workers and owners of capital have gained most, while some less-skilled workers have lost out.
- Exploitation: poor working conditions and low pay in some supply chains.
- Environmental damage: more transport and production, and some polluting industries moving to countries with weaker rules.
- Vulnerability to global shocks: financial crises, pandemics and supply chain disruptions spread quickly (the 2008 financial crisis, and shortages in 2020–22).
- Tax competition: countries cut taxes to attract MNCs, and MNCs shift profits to low-tax countries.
- Loss of national control over policy, and concerns about cultural identity.
High-income vs low-income countries
| High-income countries | Low-income countries | |
|---|---|---|
| Gains | Cheaper imports, bigger export markets for high-value goods and services, profits from MNCs, access to skilled migrants | FDI, jobs, technology, access to large markets, export-led growth |
| Losses | Lost manufacturing jobs, wider inequality, pressure on wages for less-skilled workers | Dependence on volatile commodities, exploitation, environmental damage, profit outflows, “brain drain” of skilled workers, competition crushing local firms |
The gains have been very uneven: East Asian economies that combined openness with investment in education and infrastructure gained hugely, while many commodity-dependent countries gained much less.
Trading blocs and economic integration
Many countries join with neighbours to reduce trade barriers. The levels of integration, from least to most:
| Type | Features | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Free trade area | No tariffs or quotas on trade between members; each member keeps its own barriers against non-members (so “rules of origin” are needed to stop goods entering through the member with the lowest tariff) | USMCA (USA, Mexico, Canada); ASEAN Free Trade Area |
| Customs union | Free trade between members plus a common external tariff on imports from outside | Mercosur (partly); the EU’s customs union |
| Common (single) market | A customs union plus free movement of labour and capital, and common rules on products | The EU single market |
| Monetary union | Members share a single currency and a single central bank that sets one interest rate | The eurozone (the EU countries that use the euro) |
| Full economic union | Monetary union plus harmonised fiscal and economic policies, close to becoming one economy | No complete example; the EU has elements |
Monetary union: benefits and costs
Benefits: no exchange rate uncertainty or currency exchange costs between members, so more trade and investment; prices are easier to compare, increasing competition. Costs: members lose their own interest rate and exchange rate as policy tools, so a country in recession can’t cut rates or devalue on its own (a problem for Greece and Spain after 2008); a single interest rate may suit some members and not others; and strict limits on budget deficits restrict fiscal policy.
Trade creation and trade diversion
Trade creation: when joining a trading bloc replaces higher-cost domestic production with lower-cost imports from a partner, and lets consumers buy more at lower prices. It increases efficiency.
Trade diversion: when joining a trading bloc switches imports from a low-cost supplier outside the bloc to a higher-cost supplier inside it, because the outsider still faces the tariff. It reduces efficiency.
Whether joining a bloc is good overall depends on whether the gains from trade creation outweigh the losses from trade diversion. Trade creation is likely to dominate when:
- the partner’s costs are close to the lowest world costs (small diversion);
- the country’s tariffs before joining were high (big creation);
- the members’ economies are competitive rather than all producing similar goods at very different costs;
- the common external tariff is low.
Blocs, especially monetary unions, tend to work best when members are geographically close, at similar levels of development, and have similar inflation rates, budget positions and current account balances, so one set of rules or one interest rate suits them all. Membership and rules change over time, so check recent examples.
Other effects of blocs: bigger markets give economies of scale; more competition; more inward FDI (firms locate inside the bloc to avoid the external tariff); and stronger bargaining power in world trade talks. But non-members lose exports, members give up some control over trade policy, and the bloc may be less efficient than global free trade.
Answering the Paper 4 essay
Typical questions: “To what extent do you agree that globalisation benefits high-income countries at the expense of low-income countries?”; “Evaluate the likely impact of globalisation on a low-income country’s standard of living”; or “Evaluate, with the help of a diagram, whether membership of a free trade area is always beneficial to a country.”
Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:
- Knowledge: define globalisation and its causes, standard of living, comparative advantage, and (for trading blocs) free trade area, customs union, monetary union, trade creation and trade diversion.
- Application: use real examples: poverty reduction in China, Vietnam and Bangladesh through export-led growth; lost manufacturing jobs in parts of the USA and UK; commodity-dependent countries in Africa; the EU, USMCA, ASEAN and the eurozone’s problems after 2008.
- Analysis: explain the chains: openness lets a low-income country specialise in labour-intensive exports, attracting FDI and jobs, raising incomes and tax revenue, and so living standards. For a trading bloc, draw the trade creation and diversion diagram and explain both effects.
- Evaluation: the gains depend on the country’s policies (education, infrastructure, governance), what it exports (manufactures vs volatile commodities), how the gains are distributed within the country, environmental costs, and the time period. For blocs, compare the size of trade creation and diversion, and consider dynamic effects (economies of scale, FDI, competition).
- Conclusion: make a judgement, for example: globalisation has benefited both groups overall, but unevenly; low-income countries gain most when they combine openness with investment in people and infrastructure, while the main losers are particular groups of workers in both rich and poor countries.
Check yourself
What is the difference between a free trade area and a customs union?
Both remove barriers on trade between members. A customs union also has a common external tariff on imports from non-members; in a free trade area, each member sets its own.
Define trade diversion and explain why it reduces efficiency.
Imports switch from a lower-cost producer outside the bloc to a higher-cost producer inside it, because only the outsider still pays the tariff. Resources are used less efficiently, since the goods are now made by a less efficient producer.
Give two disadvantages of joining a monetary union.
Any two of: the country loses control of its own interest rate; it can’t devalue its currency to restore competitiveness; one interest rate may not suit all members; rules may limit its budget deficit.
Give three causes of globalisation.
Any three of: lower transport costs; ICT and the internet; trade liberalisation through the WTO and trade agreements; freer capital flows; the growth of MNCs; the opening of large economies such as China and India.
Why might globalisation increase inequality within a high-income country?
Less-skilled jobs in manufacturing move to lower-cost countries, so those workers face unemployment or lower wages, while skilled workers and owners of capital gain from bigger markets and cheaper inputs.
Now practise it
Try the 32 past paper questions on Globalisation, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.