The macroeconomic objectives don’t move independently. Changing one usually changes the others, sometimes for better and sometimes for worse. This topic explains the main links, especially the famous trade-off between inflation and unemployment shown by the Phillips curve. It is the heart of many Paper 4 essays: “can a government achieve all its aims at once?”
The internal and external value of money
Internal value of money: how much a unit of the currency buys at home. It falls when there is inflation.
External value of money: how much the currency is worth in other currencies: the exchange rate.
The two are usually linked in both directions.
Higher inflation can lower the exchange rate. If a country’s inflation is higher than its trading partners’, its exports become less competitive and imports more attractive. Foreigners demand less of its currency (to buy its exports), and its residents supply more of it (to buy imports), so the currency depreciates.
A lower exchange rate can raise inflation. Imports become more expensive in the home currency. If one unit of the home currency falls from $0.50 to $0.40, an imported product priced at $20 rises from 40 to 50 units of home currency. Imported raw materials also cost more, raising firms’ costs (cost-push inflation), and domestic firms face less pressure from cheap imports to keep prices down.
The link isn’t automatic. A country with a fixed exchange rate can have inflation without its external value changing, and a country whose inflation is lower than its rivals’ may see its currency rise even though prices at home are rising.
The balance of payments and inflation
- Inflation → current account. Inflation above that of competitors makes exports less price-competitive and imports more attractive, so export revenue falls, import spending rises and the current account worsens.
- Current account surplus → inflation. A growing surplus means net exports are adding more to aggregate demand, and more money is flowing into the country, which can cause demand-pull inflation. But the effect may not last: a growing surplus tends to push the exchange rate up, which makes imports cheaper and puts pressure on domestic firms to keep prices low.
- Financial inflows from multinational companies can reduce inflation if they bring new technology and more competition.
Growth and inflation
- Actual growth driven by demand can cause inflation: more output means more competition for workers and materials (cost-push) and more income and spending (demand-pull). The closer the economy gets to full capacity, the stronger this effect.
- Potential growth can reduce inflation: if productive capacity grows, demand can rise without pushing up prices, and new technology lowers costs.
- High inflation reduces growth: it makes exports less competitive, creates uncertainty that discourages investment, and may force the central bank to raise interest rates.
Growth and the balance of payments
- Growth often worsens the current account, at least in the short run. Higher incomes mean more spending on imports, and firms import more raw materials and machinery to produce more.
- Export-led growth improves both. If growth comes from rising exports (as in Singapore, South Korea and China), higher net exports raise national income through the multiplier and improve the current account at the same time.
- Potential growth can improve competitiveness, in price and quality, and so improve the current account in the long run.
- A current account surplus adds to aggregate demand and so can cause actual growth.
Inflation and unemployment: the Phillips curve
The traditional Phillips curve
In 1958, the economist Bill Phillips studied nearly 100 years of UK data and found an inverse relationship between unemployment and the rate of change of money wages. Since wage growth drives inflation, this became a relationship between unemployment and inflation.
Phillips curve: a curve showing the relationship between the unemployment rate and the inflation rate: lower unemployment is associated with higher inflation.
This suggested that governments could choose a combination: for example, accept a little more inflation to get unemployment down, using expansionary fiscal or monetary policy. The curve can shift: outwards if workers start expecting higher inflation or a supply shock raises costs; inwards if supply-side improvements make the labour market work better.
Stagflation: when the trade-off broke down
In the 1970s, many countries had high inflation and high unemployment at the same time, which the traditional curve said shouldn’t happen.
Stagflation: high inflation combined with stagnant or falling output and rising unemployment.
Stagflation is hard to fix: expansionary policy to cut unemployment would push inflation even higher, while contractionary policy to cut inflation would raise unemployment further. Many economies faced a milder version in 2022, when energy and food prices jumped after the pandemic and the war in Ukraine.
The expectations-augmented Phillips curve
Milton Friedman explained the breakdown using expectations. Workers care about real wages, so their wage demands depend on the inflation they expect.
- A to B: higher demand pushes up prices and money wages. Workers think their real wages have risen, so more people take jobs; firms see higher prices and expand output. Unemployment falls below the natural rate.
- B to C: workers realise prices have risen as much as wages, so their real wages haven’t improved, and firms see their costs have risen too. Workers build 5% inflation into their wage demands, firms cut back, and unemployment returns to the natural rate. The economy is now on a higher short-run curve.
Long-run Phillips curve (LRPC): vertical at the natural rate of unemployment. In the long run there is no trade-off: boosting demand can’t keep unemployment below the natural rate; it only raises inflation.
Policy implications: repeated attempts to hold unemployment below the natural rate lead to accelerating inflation. The only way to lower unemployment permanently is to reduce the natural rate with supply-side policies, which shift the LRPC to the left. Keeping inflation expectations low, for example through a credible central bank with an inflation target, keeps the short-run curve low.
| Keynesian view | Monetarist / new classical view | |
|---|---|---|
| Is there a trade-off? | Yes, a usable one, especially when unemployment is high | Only in the short run; none in the long run |
| How to cut unemployment | Raise aggregate demand | Supply-side policies to lower the natural rate |
| Cost of extra demand | Some inflation, small when there is spare capacity | Only higher inflation in the long run |
In recent decades the Phillips curve has looked flatter in many countries: unemployment changed a lot with little effect on inflation, probably because central banks convinced people that inflation would stay near 2%. The sudden inflation of 2021–23, driven largely by supply shocks, showed that the relationship can change quickly.
Conflicts between objectives
| Policy | Helps | May harm |
|---|---|---|
| Expansionary fiscal or monetary policy | Growth, employment | Inflation, current account (more imports), government borrowing |
| Higher interest rates | Inflation | Growth, employment; a stronger currency hurts exporters |
| Contractionary fiscal policy (budget surplus) | Inflation, current account deficit | Growth, employment |
| Fixed or high exchange rate | Inflation (cheaper imports) | Exports, jobs, current account |
| Devaluation or depreciation | Exports, current account, jobs | Inflation (dearer imports) |
| Progressive taxes and benefits | Redistribution | Possibly incentives to work and invest |
Can all the objectives be achieved at once? In the short run, demand-side policies usually involve trade-offs. But supply-side improvements can help several goals together: higher productivity raises growth, lowers costs and inflation, improves competitiveness and the current account, and can reduce the natural rate of unemployment. A rise in productivity that is faster than the rise in wages can lead to falling unemployment, falling inflation and a growing current account surplus at the same time.
Answering the Paper 4 essay
Typical questions: “A country is experiencing stagflation. With the help of a diagram, evaluate the effectiveness of using fiscal policy to solve this problem”; “Discuss whether a government can achieve all its key macroeconomic aims simultaneously”; or “In periods of rising and persistent inflation, consumers and workers change their expectations of the future rate of inflation. Evaluate, with a diagram, the consequences of these changes.”
Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:
- Knowledge: define the objectives involved, the Phillips curve (short-run and long-run), the natural rate of unemployment, stagflation, and the internal and external value of money.
- Application: use real episodes: the stagflation of the 1970s and of 2022 after energy prices rose; export-led growth in East Asia; countries whose currencies fell and whose inflation then rose, such as Argentina or Turkey.
- Analysis: draw the relevant diagram and explain the chain. For stagflation, show SRAS shifting left, then show that raising AD increases output but pushes prices higher still, while cutting AD lowers prices but deepens the fall in output. For expectations, take the economy from A to B to C on the expectations-augmented Phillips curve.
- Evaluation: consider the cause of the problem (demand or supply), the time period (short-run trade-offs versus long-run neutrality), how expectations are formed and how credible the central bank is, spare capacity, the size of the import leakage, and whether supply-side policies could ease several problems at once, though slowly.
- Conclusion: make a judgement: for example, fiscal policy alone can’t cure stagflation without worsening either inflation or unemployment; a combination of policies, including supply-side measures, is needed, and all the aims are achievable together only in the long run.
Check yourself
Why might a rise in a country’s inflation rate cause its exchange rate to fall?
Its exports become less competitive, so demand for its currency falls, and imports become more attractive, so supply of its currency rises. Lower demand and higher supply reduce the exchange rate.
When might a government not welcome a rise in its trade surplus?
When the country already has high demand-pull inflation: higher net exports add further to aggregate demand.
What does the long-run Phillips curve show, and where is it?
It is vertical at the natural rate of unemployment: in the long run there is no trade-off between inflation and unemployment, so raising demand only raises inflation.
Unemployment falls, the current account surplus grows and inflation falls, all at once. What could explain this?
Productivity rising faster than wages: unit costs fall, so prices fall relative to competitors, exports rise, output and jobs grow, and inflation falls.
Why is stagflation hard for a government to deal with using demand-side policy?
Raising aggregate demand to reduce unemployment pushes inflation even higher, while cutting aggregate demand to reduce inflation raises unemployment further. The cause is on the supply side.
Now practise it
Try the 73 past paper questions on Links between macroeconomic problems and their interrelatedness, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.
Practise Links between macroeconomic problems and their interrelatedness questions →