This is the topic that pulls the whole of A Level macroeconomics together. Almost every Paper 4 macro essay ends up asking the same thing: how effective is this policy, and at what cost to the other objectives? This note goes through each type of policy in turn, then the conflicts between them and the ways macroeconomic policy can fail.
For any policy, ask the same five questions: Does it fit the cause of the problem? How big is the effect (the multiplier, elasticities, confidence)? How long does it take? What does it do to the other objectives? What could go wrong? These give you your evaluation in every essay.
Fiscal policy
Fiscal policy uses government spending and taxation to influence aggregate demand (and, through some taxes and spending, aggregate supply).
What it can achieve
- Expansionary fiscal policy (more spending, lower taxes) raises AD, which increases actual growth and reduces cyclical unemployment. Because of the multiplier, the government needn’t spend the full size of the output gap.
- Contractionary fiscal policy reduces AD, which lowers demand-pull inflation and improves the current account.
- Fiscal policy is the main tool for redistribution (progressive taxes, benefits) and development (spending on health, education and infrastructure).
How much it works depends on spare capacity
Crowding out and crowding in
Crowding out: higher government spending, financed by borrowing, reduces private sector spending: the government competes for funds, pushing up interest rates, so firms invest less and households borrow less.
Crowding in: higher government spending raises income through the multiplier, which increases saving, consumption and investment, so private spending rises too.
New classical economists stress crowding out, especially near full employment. Keynesians argue that in a recession, with idle resources and low interest rates, crowding in is more likely.
The Laffer curve
Laffer curve: a curve showing that as the tax rate rises, tax revenue first rises and then falls, because very high rates discourage work and enterprise and encourage tax avoidance and evasion.
The Laffer curve is used to support supply-side tax cuts. But nobody knows where t* actually is, the curve’s shape probably differs between countries and over time, and tax cuts in the USA in the 1980s reduced revenue rather than raising it. So most economies are probably to the left of t*, where tax cuts lose revenue.
Limits of fiscal policy
- Time lags: it takes time to recognise a problem, agree a budget and pass the changes, and for people to respond. By then the economy may have recovered, so the policy adds to a boom.
- Unexpected responses: people may save a tax cut if they expect it to be reversed or are worried about the future.
- Government borrowing: deficits add to the national debt (the total owed), and interest payments use up future tax revenue.
- Hard to reverse: a new hospital or benefit becomes a long-term commitment.
- Incentive effects: higher taxes and generous benefits may reduce the incentive to work and invest.
- Leakages: in an open economy, much of the extra spending goes on imports, worsening the current account.
Budget deficit: government spending is greater than tax revenue in a year.
National debt: the total amount the government owes, built up from past deficits.
Part of a deficit is cyclical: in a recession tax revenue falls and benefit spending rises automatically, and this part disappears as the economy recovers. The rest is structural and remains even at full employment. A government with a large negative output gap is usually more willing to run a deficit than one close to capacity.
Monetary policy
Monetary policy uses interest rates, the money supply and quantitative easing, usually run by an independent central bank with an inflation target. How it works is set out in money and banking.
- Expansionary monetary policy (lower interest rates, QE) raises consumption, investment and net exports, so it promotes growth and employment, but may raise inflation and worsen the current account.
- Contractionary monetary policy (higher interest rates) reduces demand-pull inflation, but slows growth, raises unemployment and, by raising the exchange rate, can hurt exporters.
Strengths: it can be changed quickly (decisions are made monthly), it is run by independent experts rather than politicians, and its shorter lags make it the usual first response to inflation.
Limits:
- Time lags of 18 months to two years before the full effect on inflation.
- Confidence: in a boom, higher rates may not stop spending; in a slump, low rates may not encourage borrowing.
- Banks may not pass on rate changes, or may not lend extra reserves from QE.
- The liquidity trap and the zero lower bound: when rates are already near zero, they can’t be cut much further.
- Other countries: with mobile capital, a country can’t keep its interest rate very different from its rivals’ without large flows of “hot money” and big exchange rate movements.
- Cost-push inflation: raising rates doesn’t fix inflation caused by higher import or energy prices; it just adds unemployment.
- Coordination: it can be undermined if the government is running a very expansionary fiscal policy at the same time.
Supply-side policy
Supply-side policies aim to raise productive capacity (shift LRAS right). They come in two kinds.
| Market-based | Interventionist | |
|---|---|---|
| Idea | Make markets work better by increasing incentives and competition | The government takes an active role to raise productivity |
| Examples | Cuts in income and corporate tax, cuts in unemployment benefit, privatisation, deregulation, reducing trade union power | Spending on education, training, infrastructure, research and technology; regional policy |
| Possible gains | Stronger incentives to work, invest and set up businesses; more competition and lower costs | Can improve all the objectives in the long run: growth, inflation, unemployment, the current account and development |
| Possible problems | Can increase inequality; people may take more leisure instead of working more; privatised monopolies may raise prices; weaker regulation can harm safety and the environment | Expensive (needs taxes or borrowing); slow; workers may be trained in the wrong skills; roads and airports can cause pollution |
Interventionist policies raise both AD (through the extra spending) and AS (through higher productivity). A key limitation of all supply-side policy is time: it does little to fix a recession quickly, and cutting benefits in a recession can actually reduce spending and make unemployment worse.
Exchange rate policy
- A lower exchange rate (devaluation, or selling the currency) makes exports cheaper and imports dearer, so net exports rise: this can improve the current account and raise growth and employment. But it raises the price of imported goods and raw materials (cost-push inflation) and reduces the pressure on firms to keep costs down; with little spare capacity, the extra demand is also inflationary.
- A higher exchange rate helps reduce inflation (cheaper imports, more pressure to cut costs), but worsens the current account and can reduce growth and employment.
Limits:
- Price elasticity: a depreciation only improves the current account if demand for exports and imports is elastic enough (the Marshall–Lerner condition), and at first it may make things worse (the J-curve effect), as covered in the balance of payments notes.
- Speculation: in a floating system, market buying or selling can overwhelm the central bank.
- Reserves: to raise its currency the central bank must buy it with foreign currency reserves, which can run out.
- Other countries may object to a deliberate devaluation, or retaliate, and their central banks can act against it.
- Any competitive gain may be eroded by the higher cost of imported inputs.
International trade policy
A government can choose free trade or protection.
- Free trade lets the country specialise where it has a comparative advantage, increases competition and choice, and lowers prices, which helps growth and keeps inflation down.
- Protection (tariffs, quotas, subsidies to domestic firms) may protect jobs, help infant industries grow, prevent dumping and reduce a current account deficit.
Limits of protection: higher prices for consumers and for firms using imported inputs (raising inflation); protected firms may become inefficient and dependent on protection; other countries may retaliate, harming exports and starting a trade war; and members of trade blocs or the WTO face rules on what they can do.
Conflicts between objectives
- Growth and jobs vs inflation: expansionary fiscal and monetary policy raises output and employment but can cause demand-pull inflation; contractionary policy does the reverse.
- Low inflation vs the balance of payments: higher interest rates cut inflation but raise the exchange rate, which can worsen the current account (though they also attract financial inflows).
- Redistribution vs growth: more progressive taxes and higher benefits may reduce incentives to work, invest and attract foreign firms. But a healthier, better-educated workforce can raise productivity, and effort may depend more on wages and profits than on tax rates.
To reduce conflicts, governments use several policies together, broadly one tool for each objective: for example, interest rates for inflation, supply-side policy for growth, and fiscal policy for redistribution. Supply-side improvements are the main way to improve several objectives at once, in the long run. See links between macroeconomic problems.
Government failure in macroeconomic policy
Macroeconomic government failure: when government policy makes the economy’s performance worse rather than better.
- Misjudging the multiplier. Underestimate it and the government stimulates too much, turning a negative output gap into a positive one (and inflation); overestimate it and the stimulus is too small.
- Time lags. A recognition lag (spotting the problem), an implementation lag (deciding and introducing the policy) and a behavioural lag (people reacting). By the time the policy works, it may be the wrong policy, making the cycle bigger.
- Inaccurate information. Economic data are published late and often revised; forecasts can be wrong.
- Unexpected reactions from households, firms and banks.
- Political pressures. Governments may cut taxes or raise spending before elections, or avoid unpopular but necessary measures.
- Unintended consequences. For example, high taxes encouraging avoidance or causing skilled workers to emigrate.
Answering the Paper 4 essay
Typical questions: “With the help of a diagram, assess the effectiveness of using fiscal policy to close a negative output gap”; “Evaluate the effectiveness of using monetary policy to increase the rate of economic growth”; “With a diagram, assess the effectiveness of government policies that might be used to reduce cost-push inflation”; or “Evaluate the effect of a fall in the exchange rate on the achievement of a country’s macroeconomic aims.”
Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:
- Knowledge: define the policy (fiscal, monetary, supply-side, exchange rate or trade) and the problem it is meant to solve (negative output gap, demand-pull or cost-push inflation, current account deficit), with the relevant terms: multiplier, crowding out, transmission mechanism, Laffer curve.
- Application: use real cases: the big fiscal packages of 2020; near-zero interest rates and QE in Japan, the UK and the USA; central banks raising rates sharply in 2022–23; a depreciation in a country such as Egypt raising inflation; tariffs and trade disputes.
- Analysis: use an AD/AS diagram and explain the chain step by step: for example, higher government spending raises AD, the multiplier increases income further, output rises towards full employment and unemployment falls. Show how the size of the effect depends on where the economy is on the AS curve.
- Evaluation: how big is the output gap; the size of the multiplier and the import leakage; crowding out; time lags; confidence; government debt; the effect on the other objectives (inflation, the current account); whether the cause is demand-side or supply-side; and the risk of government failure.
- Conclusion: make a clear judgement: for example, fiscal policy is effective at closing a large negative output gap, especially when interest rates are already low, but it works best combined with monetary policy and with supply-side policies for lasting growth.
Don’t evaluate a policy without saying what it is evaluated against. “Monetary policy has time lags” is a weak point on its own; “monetary policy’s lags are shorter than fiscal policy’s, but in a deep recession with rates near zero it may not work at all, so fiscal policy is more effective here” is a strong one.
Check yourself
What is crowding out, and when is it most likely?
When higher government borrowing pushes up interest rates and reduces the funds available, lowering private consumption and investment. It is most likely close to full employment, when resources and savings are scarce, and less likely in a recession.
According to the Laffer curve, when would a cut in the tax rate increase tax revenue?
When the tax rate is above the revenue-maximising rate t*: lower rates would encourage enough extra work, enterprise and honest reporting to raise total revenue.
Give two reasons why cutting interest rates might fail to raise growth in a recession.
Any two of: low confidence means households and firms won’t borrow; banks may not lend or pass on the cut; rates may already be near zero (liquidity trap); time lags; other countries’ policies.
Why might a depreciation raise inflation?
Imported finished goods and raw materials become more expensive (cost-push); domestic firms face less competition from imports; and higher net exports raise AD, which is inflationary near full capacity.
Name the three time lags in macroeconomic policy.
The recognition lag (spotting the problem), the implementation lag (deciding and introducing the policy) and the behavioural lag (households and firms responding).
Now practise it
Try the 151 past paper questions on Effectiveness of policy options to meet all macroeconomic objectives, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.
Practise Effectiveness of policy options to meet all macroeconomic objectives questions →