At AS Level you met the current account. This topic completes the picture with the whole balance of payments, then asks what a government can do when it is out of balance. Paper 4 essays here are almost always about choosing between expenditure-switching and expenditure-reducing policies, so make sure you can explain the difference and the drawbacks of each.
The parts of the balance of payments
Balance of payments: a record of all the economic transactions between a country’s residents and the rest of the world over a period of time.
| Account | What it records |
|---|---|
| Current account | Trade in goods and trade in services; primary income (wages, profits, interest and dividends earned abroad and paid abroad); secondary income (transfers such as workers’ remittances and foreign aid) |
| Capital account | Usually small: debt forgiveness, money brought in or taken out by migrants, and the sale of patents, copyrights and mineral rights |
| Financial account | Direct investment (building or buying firms abroad), portfolio investment (shares and bonds without control), other investment (bank deposits and loans) and reserve assets (the central bank’s gold and foreign currency) |
| Net errors and omissions | A balancing figure to cover mistakes and missing transactions |
Don’t confuse the investment with the income it earns. Buying shares in a foreign firm goes in the financial account; the dividends those shares later pay go in primary income in the current account.
Why the balance of payments always balances
Every transaction has two sides. If a country buys more from abroad than it sells (a current account deficit), it must pay for the difference somehow: by borrowing from abroad, selling assets to foreigners or using its reserves. Those show up as a matching surplus on the financial account. So current + capital + financial accounts + net errors and omissions = 0. In practice the figures never quite match, which is why the balancing item exists.
Worked example ($bn)
| Item | $bn |
|---|---|
| Trade in goods | −40 |
| Trade in services | +15 |
| Primary income | −10 |
| Secondary income | +5 |
| Current account | −30 |
| Capital account | +2 |
| Financial account (net inflow) | +25 |
| Net errors and omissions | +3 |
The three accounts add up to −30 + 2 + 25 = −3, so $3bn more must have come in than was recorded: net errors and omissions is +3.
When is a deficit or surplus a problem?
A current account deficit is more worrying when it is large (as a percentage of GDP), persistent, caused by uncompetitive industries or by spending on consumer goods, and financed by short-term borrowing or hot money that could leave suddenly. It is less worrying when it is temporary, or caused by importing machinery that will raise future output and exports, or financed by long-term direct investment.
A financial account surplus (more investment coming in than going out) can finance a current account deficit, create jobs and raise growth. But in later years foreign owners take profits, interest and dividends home, which worsens the primary income balance. A financial account deficit may just mean residents are investing abroad (which brings income back later), but if it reflects capital flight, as people lose confidence and move money out, it lowers tax revenue, investment and the exchange rate.
Expenditure-reducing and expenditure-switching policies
Expenditure-reducing policy: reducing total spending in the economy, so that less is spent on imports (and domestic firms, with a smaller home market, try to sell more abroad).
Expenditure-switching policy: persuading people at home and abroad to switch their spending from foreign products to the country’s own products, without reducing total spending.
Expenditure-reducing policies
These are contractionary fiscal and monetary policies: higher taxes, lower government spending, higher interest rates or slower money growth.
Evaluation:
- It is likely to improve the current account, and it also reduces inflation, which helps competitiveness.
- But it sacrifices growth and jobs: to cut imports by a certain amount, total spending may have to fall by much more, because only part of each dollar is spent on imports.
- Higher interest rates may raise the exchange rate, making exports dearer and partly cancelling the improvement.
- It treats the symptom: if the deficit comes from uncompetitive industries, it returns when the economy recovers.
Expenditure-switching policies
1. A lower exchange rate (devaluation in a fixed system, or a depreciation encouraged by the central bank): exports become cheaper abroad and imports dearer at home. How well it works depends on price elasticities (the Marshall–Lerner condition) and it may make things worse at first (the J-curve). See exchange rates.
2. Protectionism: tariffs, quotas, import licences and subsidies to domestic firms.
3. Supply-side policies: better education, training, infrastructure and technology lower costs and improve quality, making the country’s products more competitive. They also make the country more attractive to foreign investors, improving the financial account.
Evaluating expenditure-switching
- A lower exchange rate raises import prices, which causes inflation (especially if the country imports raw materials and energy), and that erodes the competitive gain. It needs elastic demand, takes time, and other countries may object.
- Tariffs and quotas raise prices for consumers and for firms using imported inputs; protected firms may become inefficient; other countries may retaliate, hurting exports; and WTO rules and trade agreements limit what can be done. They work best when good domestic substitutes exist.
- Supply-side policies tackle the real cause and don’t sacrifice other objectives, but they are slow and expensive, and their success is uncertain.
To decide which type a policy is, ask: does it change the total amount spent in the economy? If yes, it is expenditure-reducing. If it changes where the spending goes, it is expenditure-switching.
Policies for a current account surplus
The same tools work in reverse: expansionary fiscal and monetary policy (more spending, including on imports), allowing the currency to appreciate or revaluing it, and removing import restrictions. Countries with big surpluses are sometimes pressured by trading partners to do this.
Policies aimed at other objectives can also affect the balance of payments by accident: an income tax cut to reduce unemployment raises spending on imports and can widen a deficit; higher interest rates to fight inflation attract hot money and raise the exchange rate.
Answering the Paper 4 essay
Typical questions: “Discuss whether expenditure-reducing policies are preferable to expenditure-switching policies in order to correct a persistent current account deficit”; “With the help of a diagram, evaluate the effectiveness of expenditure-switching policies to reduce a current account deficit”; or “The use of tariffs is the most effective way to correct a balance of payments deficit. With a diagram, evaluate this statement.”
Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:
- Knowledge: define the current account and its parts, a current account deficit, and expenditure-switching and expenditure-reducing policies, with examples of each.
- Application: use real cases: persistent deficits in countries such as Argentina or the UK, India’s deficit driven by oil imports and income paid to foreign investors, tariffs in recent US–China trade disputes, devaluations in countries such as Egypt.
- Analysis: draw the diagrams and explain the chains: contractionary policy shifts AD left, cutting spending on imports but also output and jobs; a tariff raises import prices, so domestic output rises and imports fall; a depreciation makes exports cheaper and imports dearer, and the effect depends on the elasticities.
- Evaluation: what causes the deficit (high demand, or uncompetitive industries)? Expenditure-reducing policy sacrifices growth and jobs; expenditure-switching risks inflation, retaliation and inefficiency, and the J-curve means a delay; supply-side policy is the lasting cure but is slow. Is the deficit actually a problem (how large, how financed)?
- Conclusion: make a judgement: for example, neither type is always preferable; if the deficit comes from an overheating economy, expenditure-reducing policy fits; if it comes from poor competitiveness, expenditure-switching (especially supply-side measures) is needed, and a combination usually works best.
Check yourself
Malaysian citizens buy shares in Nigerian firms. Where does this appear in Malaysia’s balance of payments?
In the financial account (portfolio investment). Any dividends later received would go in primary income.
A country’s current account is −$20bn, its capital account +$1bn and its financial account +$16bn. What is the net errors and omissions figure?
−20 + 1 + 16 = −3, so net errors and omissions = +$3bn.
Is a rise in interest rates an expenditure-switching or expenditure-reducing policy?
Expenditure-reducing: it reduces total spending in the economy, including spending on imports.
Give two reasons why a tariff might fail to reduce a current account deficit.
Any two of: other countries retaliate, reducing exports; there are no good domestic substitutes, so imports barely fall; higher costs for firms using imported inputs make exports less competitive; WTO or trade bloc rules prevent it.
Why might a large financial account surplus lead to a weaker current account in the future?
Foreign investors will take profits, interest and dividends out of the country in later years, which are debits in the primary income part of the current account.
Now practise it
Try the 41 past paper questions on Policies to correct disequilibrium in the balance of payments, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.
Practise Policies to correct disequilibrium in the balance of payments questions →