A budget is a financial plan that turns a business’s objectives into targets for income and spending. This chapter covers why budgets are used, the three types in the syllabus, and how comparing actual results with the budget (variance analysis) helps managers control the business. Paper 1 regularly asks how important budgets are to a particular business, and Paper 2 sets variance calculations.
The meaning and purpose of budgets
Budget: a detailed financial plan for a future period, setting targets for revenue, costs or profit, usually for each department.
Budgets are used for:
- Planning: making managers think ahead and set targets linked to the business’s objectives.
- Allocating resources: deciding how much each department can spend.
- Controlling and monitoring: comparing actual results with the budget so problems are spotted and corrected early.
- Measuring performance: judging managers and departments against their targets.
- Coordinating departments, and motivating staff with clear targets.
| Benefits | Drawbacks |
|---|---|
| Clear targets and direction for each department | Take time to prepare and agree |
| Spending is controlled and kept in line with objectives | Can be inflexible if conditions change during the year |
| Problems spotted early through variances | Based on forecasts that may be inaccurate |
| Can motivate managers, especially if they help set them | Imposed or unrealistic budgets demotivate; managers may overspend at year end to avoid having their budget cut |
| Helps coordinate departments | Departments may compete for resources rather than cooperate |
Types of budget
| Type | How it works | Strengths | Weaknesses |
|---|---|---|---|
| Incremental budgeting | Last year’s budget adjusted by a small amount, such as +3% for inflation | Quick and simple; stable | Builds in past waste; doesn’t question whether spending is still needed |
| Flexible budgeting | The budget adjusts to the actual level of output or sales (for example, materials budget per unit produced) | Fairer comparisons when output changes; more realistic | More complex to prepare and update |
| Zero budgeting (zero-based) | Each budget starts from zero and every item of spending must be justified | Removes waste; resources go where they are most needed | Very time-consuming; managers may exaggerate needs |
Variances
Variance: the difference between a budgeted figure and the actual result.
Favourable variance: the actual result is better for profit than budgeted (revenue higher, or costs lower). Adverse variance: the actual result is worse for profit (revenue lower, or costs higher).
| $ | Budget | Actual | Variance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales revenue | 50 000 | 46 000 | 4 000 A |
| Materials | 18 000 | 16 500 | 1 500 F |
| Wages | 12 000 | 13 000 | 1 000 A |
| Profit | 20 000 | 16 500 | 3 500 A |
Profit is $3,500 below budget: the adverse sales and wages variances outweigh the favourable materials variance.
Lower costs are favourable and lower revenue is adverse. Always judge the effect on profit, not whether the number went up or down.
Interpreting variances
A variance shows that something differs from the plan, not why. Managers must investigate: the adverse sales variance could come from a new competitor, a price cut or a weak economy; the favourable materials variance could come from cheaper suppliers or simply from making fewer products because sales were low, in which case it isn’t really good news. A flexible budget, adjusted to actual output, separates these effects. Variances should lead to action: correcting problems, or revising unrealistic budgets.
Answering the Paper 1 and 2 questions
Typical questions: “Evaluate the importance of using budgets for the success of a large road construction project”; “‘The use of budgets is the most effective way to monitor the performance of a hotel.’ Evaluate this view”; “Evaluate whether setting budgets is important to the success of a farming business”; or a variance calculation in Paper 2.
In Paper 1 Section B you answer one two-part essay: part (a) for 8 marks and part (b) for 12 marks. Each Paper 2 question ends with an 8-mark part and a 12-mark part. The 12-mark parts must include evaluation, and long answers are marked on knowledge, application, analysis and evaluation. Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order:
- Knowledge: define budget, the type of budget in the question, and favourable and adverse variances.
- Application: apply them to the business: a construction project with many costs over a long period; a farm whose output depends on the weather; a hotel with many departments. Calculate variances accurately.
- Analysis: build chains: for example, a budget for each stage of a road project lets managers spot an adverse materials variance early, investigate, and act before costs spiral and the project makes a loss.
- Evaluation: consider how predictable the business is (budgets are harder for a farm facing uncertain weather, so flexible budgets suit it), how budgets are set (imposed or agreed), and other ways of monitoring performance (ratios, customer feedback, quality measures).
- Conclusion: make a justified judgement, for example: budgets are essential for a large construction project because costs are huge and overruns common, but they must be flexible and reviewed regularly to stay useful.
Check yourself
Budgeted wages were $30,000 and actual wages were $27,000. What is the variance?
$3,000 favourable (costs were lower than budgeted).
Budgeted revenue was $80,000 and actual revenue $85,000. What is the variance?
$5,000 favourable.
What is zero budgeting?
Every budget starts from zero, and all spending must be justified, rather than adjusting last year’s figure.
Why might a favourable materials variance not be good news?
It may be caused by producing less because sales were low, rather than by better efficiency or cheaper suppliers.
Give two benefits and two drawbacks of budgets.
Benefits (any two): clear targets; control of spending; early warning through variances; motivation; coordination. Drawbacks (any two): time-consuming; inflexible; based on forecasts; can demotivate if imposed; encourage end-of-year overspending.
Now practise it
Try the 20 past paper questions on Budgets, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.