Managers turn a business’s resources and people into results. This chapter covers what managers do, two classic views of their role, the main management styles and McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y. Paper 1 has set essays comparing management styles in a particular business, and Paper 2 asks whether a style suits the manager in the case.
What managers do
Manager: a person responsible for setting objectives, organising resources and directing and controlling the work of others to achieve the goals of the business.
The traditional functions of management
- Planning: setting objectives and deciding how to achieve them.
- Organising: arranging the resources (people, money, materials, equipment) needed to carry out the plan.
- Directing: instructing, guiding and motivating people to carry out their tasks.
- Controlling: measuring performance against the plan and taking action to correct problems.
Fayol and Mintzberg on the manager’s role
Henri Fayol described management as a set of logical functions: planning (forecasting), organising, commanding (directing staff), coordinating (making sure departments work together) and controlling. His view suggests management is a structured, rational process.
Henry Mintzberg studied what managers actually do and found their work is fast-moving, varied and constantly interrupted. He grouped it into ten roles in three categories:
| Category | Roles | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Interpersonal | Figurehead, leader, liaison | Attending a ceremony; motivating the team; networking with other managers |
| Informational | Monitor, disseminator, spokesperson | Following market trends; passing information to staff; speaking for the department |
| Decisional | Entrepreneur, disturbance handler, resource allocator, negotiator | Starting a new project; dealing with a strike; setting budgets; agreeing a contract |
The two views complement each other: Fayol describes what management should achieve; Mintzberg shows how messy and people-centred the job is in practice.
How managers contribute to business performance
Good managers set clear objectives, use resources efficiently, motivate and develop staff, make sound decisions, coordinate departments, and adapt to change. Poor management shows up as wasted resources, low morale, high labour turnover, missed targets and lost customers.
Management styles
| Style | Features | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|---|
| Autocratic | Manager makes decisions alone and gives orders; close supervision; one-way communication | Quick decisions; clear direction; useful in a crisis or with unskilled staff | Low motivation; no use of staff ideas; staff may become dependent |
| Democratic | Manager involves staff in decisions; two-way communication; may delegate | Better ideas; higher motivation and commitment; easier to introduce change | Slower decisions; needs skilled, interested staff; manager still accountable |
| Laissez-faire | Manager sets broad goals and leaves staff to decide how to achieve them | Encourages creativity and initiative among skilled, self-motivated staff | Lack of direction and coordination; some staff struggle without guidance |
| Paternalistic | Manager makes decisions but in what they believe is the best interest of staff, explaining them and caring for staff welfare | Staff feel looked after; loyalty; good working conditions | Staff still have little say; can feel patronising; dependent on the manager’s judgement |
No style is always best. The right one depends on the task (routine or creative), the skills and experience of the staff, the time available, the culture of the business and the manager’s own personality. In a hospital emergency, quick autocratic decisions may save lives; in planning a new service, a democratic approach that uses staff expertise may work better.
McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y
| Theory X managers assume… | Theory Y managers assume… | |
|---|---|---|
| Attitude to work | People dislike work and avoid it if they can | Work is as natural as rest or play; people can enjoy it |
| Motivation | Mainly by money and the threat of punishment | By responsibility, achievement and the work itself |
| Responsibility | People avoid responsibility and need close control | People seek responsibility and use creativity |
| Resulting style | Autocratic, close supervision | Democratic, delegation, empowerment |
McGregor’s point is that managers’ assumptions shape how they manage, and can become self-fulfilling: staff treated as untrustworthy lose motivation and behave as expected, while staff given responsibility often rise to it.
Theory X and Theory Y describe managers’ attitudes to workers, not two types of worker. A question about McGregor is about how a manager’s beliefs affect the way they manage.
Answering the Paper 1 and 2 questions
Typical questions: “‘In a hospital, managers using a democratic style are more likely to be successful than managers using an autocratic style.’ Evaluate this view”; “‘Good leaders are more important for business success than good managers.’ Evaluate this view”; or “Evaluate whether laissez-faire is the most appropriate management style for IX” (Paper 2).
In Paper 1 Section B you answer one two-part essay: part (a) for 8 marks and part (b) for 12 marks. Each Paper 2 question ends with an 8-mark part and a 12-mark part. The 12-mark parts must include evaluation, and long answers are marked on knowledge, application, analysis and evaluation. Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order:
- Knowledge: define management, the functions of management, the styles in the question, and Theory X and Theory Y.
- Application: apply them to the business in the question: the type of work (emergency or routine), the staff’s skills and experience, the culture, and any problems in the case.
- Analysis: build chains: for example, a democratic manager in a hospital consults experienced nurses, so decisions use their expertise and they feel valued, raising motivation and the quality of patient care.
- Evaluation: no style suits every situation: consider when the alternative would be better (emergencies, inexperienced staff), the manager’s assumptions, the time available and the cost of mistakes.
- Conclusion: make a justified judgement, for example: a democratic style is more likely to succeed in most hospital departments because staff are highly skilled, but managers must be ready to act autocratically in emergencies.
Check yourself
Name the four traditional functions of management.
Planning, organising, directing and controlling.
Name Mintzberg’s three categories of managerial roles.
Interpersonal, informational and decisional.
What is a paternalistic management style?
The manager makes the decisions but in what they believe is the best interest of staff, explaining them and caring for staff welfare.
When might an autocratic style be most suitable?
In a crisis needing quick decisions, with inexperienced staff, or for simple routine tasks.
What does a Theory Y manager assume about workers?
That they can enjoy work, seek responsibility and are motivated by achievement, so they should be given responsibility and involved in decisions.
Now practise it
Try the 17 past paper questions on Management, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.