← Topical Vault

Motivation Revision notes

Unit 2: Human resource management · Chapter 11 · about 14 minutes · written for the 9609 syllabus · last checked 2026-11-17

Motivated employees work harder, produce better quality, stay longer and come up with ideas. This chapter covers what motivates people, the six theories the syllabus names, and the financial and non-financial methods businesses use in practice. It is one of the most examined AS topics: Paper 1 essays often ask you to judge a theory or method for a particular business, such as a call centre, a school or a building firm.

Why motivation matters

Motivation: the factors that make people want to work well and achieve the goals of the business.

Motivation is a tool of management and leadership: managers need it to achieve the business’s objectives. Well-motivated staff bring higher productivity, better quality and customer service, lower absence and labour turnover (so lower recruitment and training costs), more ideas, and easier introduction of change.

Human needs

People work to satisfy needs: basic needs such as food and shelter (met through pay), security, belonging, respect and the chance to develop. Work can satisfy many of these, through pay, a safe and secure job, colleagues, recognition and interesting tasks. But some jobs, such as repetitive tasks with no say in decisions, leave higher needs unmet, which lowers motivation.

Content theories

Taylor: scientific management

F.W. Taylor believed workers are motivated mainly by money (“economic man”). Managers should study each job scientifically, find the most efficient way to do it, train workers to follow that method exactly, supervise them closely, and pay them by results (piece rates).

Use today: work study and piece rates in some factories and call centres; strict targets. Limitations: ignores social and psychological needs; boring, repetitive work causes low morale; workers may sacrifice quality for quantity; less suited to skilled or creative work.

Mayo: human relations

Elton Mayo’s experiments at the Hawthorne factory found that productivity rose when workers felt valued and noticed by managers, and that social factors (working in groups, good relationships, being consulted) affected motivation as much as pay or conditions.

Use today: team working, social facilities, consultation, managers showing interest in staff. Limitation: the results came from a particular setting and may not apply everywhere; strong groups can also resist management.

Maslow: hierarchy of needs

Maslow’s hierarchy of needs: physiological needs at the base, then security, social, esteem and self-actualisation at the top. Once a lower level is satisfied, the next level becomes the main motivator Self-actualisation reaching full potential Esteem recognition, status, promotion Social belonging, team working Security (safety) job security, safe conditions Physiological pay for food and shelter higher needs
Maslow’s hierarchy: people are motivated by the lowest unsatisfied need; once it is met, the next level up becomes the motivator.

Use: managers should find out which level each employee has reached and offer the next: security through contracts, social needs through teams, esteem through recognition and promotion, self-actualisation through challenging work. Limitations: people don’t always move up in order; needs differ between individuals and cultures; levels are hard to measure; a satisfied need can return (a redundancy threat brings security back to the front).

Herzberg: two-factor theory

Hygiene factorsMotivators
Pay, working conditions, company policy, supervision, job security, relationships with colleaguesAchievement, recognition, responsibility, interesting work, advancement (promotion), personal growth
If poor, they cause dissatisfaction; making them good removes dissatisfaction but does not motivateProvide real job satisfaction and lasting motivation

Herzberg recommended job enrichment: giving workers complete units of work, more responsibility and more challenging tasks. Limitations: based on a small sample of professionals; some workers do value pay as a motivator; enrichment is hard for some jobs and costs money to introduce.

McClelland: achievement motivation

David McClelland argued that people are driven by three needs, in different strengths for each person:

  • Achievement: wanting to succeed, take on challenging goals and get feedback (suits entrepreneurs, sales staff).
  • Affiliation: wanting good relationships and to be accepted (suits team roles).
  • Power: wanting to influence and control others (suits management, if used for the organisation’s goals).

Managers can match jobs and rewards to each person’s dominant need. Limitation: needs are hard to identify, and people may show different needs in different situations.

Process theory: Vroom’s expectancy theory

Victor Vroom argued that motivation depends on what people expect to happen. An employee will be motivated to work hard only if they believe:

  1. extra effort will lead to better performance (expectancy: “If I try harder, can I actually do it?”);
  2. better performance will be rewarded (instrumentality: “Will I get the reward if I do?”);
  3. the reward is something they value (valence: “Do I want that reward?”).

If any link is weak, motivation falls. So managers should set achievable targets, provide training and resources, reward performance reliably and fairly, and offer rewards each person values. Limitation: it assumes people calculate rationally, and it is hard to measure each person’s expectations and values.

Motivation methods in practice

Financial motivators

MethodHow it worksSuitsDrawbacks
Time-based wagePaid per hour workedJobs where output is hard to measureNo incentive to work faster
SalaryFixed annual amount, paid monthlyManagers and professional staffNot linked to performance
Piece ratePaid per unit producedRepetitive production where output is easy to countQuality may suffer; income insecure
CommissionPercentage of the value of sales madeSales staffPressure selling; unstable income
BonusExtra payment for meeting targetsMost jobs with clear targetsCan become expected; targets may be manipulated
Profit sharingStaff receive a share of the business’s profitBuilding commitment to the businessLink to individual effort is weak; nothing when profits fall
Performance-related payPay rise or bonus based on an appraisal of performanceJobs judged on quality as well as quantityAppraisals can seem unfair; may damage teamwork
Fringe benefitsNon-cash rewards: company car, health insurance, pension, discountsAttracting and keeping staffCostly; not linked to performance

Non-financial motivators

  • Training and development, and opportunities for promotion, meet esteem and self-actualisation needs.
  • Status: job titles, recognition schemes, awards.
  • Job re-design: job rotation (moving between tasks for variety), job enlargement (more tasks at the same level), and job enrichment (more responsibility and challenge, as Herzberg recommended).
  • Team working: meets social needs (Mayo) and can raise productivity and ideas.
  • Empowerment: giving employees the authority to make decisions about their own work.
  • Participation: involving employees in decisions through consultation, suggestion schemes, quality circles, works councils, worker representatives or employee share ownership.

Match the method to the job and the workforce. Piece rates suit simple, countable production but not nursing or teaching, where quality and care matter. For a strong answer, explain which theory supports a method and whether that theory fits the workers in the question.

Answering the Paper 1 and 2 questions

Typical questions: “‘Non-financial motivators are the most effective way of improving employee motivation in a house building business.’ Evaluate this view”; “‘The best way to improve the quality of teaching in a school is to use Herzberg’s two-factor theory.’ Evaluate this view”; “‘The economic man theory used by Taylor is the best way to motivate the employees of a customer service call centre.’ Evaluate this view”; or “Evaluate whether CC should change the payment method from time-based to piece rate” (Paper 2).

In Paper 1 Section B you answer one two-part essay: part (a) for 8 marks and part (b) for 12 marks. Each Paper 2 question ends with an 8-mark part and a 12-mark part. The 12-mark parts must include evaluation, and long answers are marked on knowledge, application, analysis and evaluation. Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order:

  1. Knowledge: explain the theory or method in the question accurately, using the theorist’s key ideas and terms.
  2. Application: apply it to the workers in the question: what their jobs involve, their skills, how output and quality are measured, and what they are likely to value.
  3. Analysis: build chains: for example, piece rates reward builders for each unit completed, so they work faster, raising output, but they may rush, so quality falls and repair costs and complaints rise.
  4. Evaluation: weigh the method against alternatives and against other theories; consider the cost, the type of work, individual differences, and whether hygiene factors must be fixed first.
  5. Conclusion: make a justified judgement, for example: non-financial motivators are important for a house builder, but because pay is a hygiene factor and output is measurable, a mix of fair pay, team bonuses and training is likely to be most effective.

Check yourself

What did Taylor believe motivated workers?

Money: workers are “economic men” motivated by pay, so they should be paid by results (piece rates) for following the most efficient method.

What is the difference between Herzberg’s hygiene factors and motivators?

Hygiene factors (pay, conditions, supervision) cause dissatisfaction if poor but don’t motivate; motivators (achievement, recognition, responsibility) give real job satisfaction.

Name McClelland’s three needs.

Achievement, affiliation and power.

According to Vroom, what three beliefs must an employee hold to be motivated?

That effort leads to performance, performance leads to a reward, and the reward is valued.

What is the difference between job enlargement and job enrichment?

Job enlargement adds more tasks at the same level; job enrichment adds responsibility, challenge and decision-making.

Now practise it

Try the 57 past paper questions on Motivation, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.

Practise Motivation questions →