The marketing mix is the set of decisions a business makes to sell its product: the 4Ps of product, price, promotion and place. This chapter covers the first two, including the product life cycle and the Boston Matrix, which are among the most examined AS tools. Promotion and place are in the next chapter.
The marketing mix (4Ps)
Marketing mix: the key decisions a business makes to market its product successfully: Product, Price, Promotion and Place (channels of distribution).
The four elements must work together and suit the target market: a luxury product needs a high price, exclusive promotion and selective places to buy it; a budget product needs a low price and wide distribution.
Product
Goods and services; tangible and intangible attributes
Goods are physical products (a phone); services are activities performed for customers (a haircut, insurance). Services can’t be stored, are produced and consumed at the same time, and vary with the person delivering them.
Products have tangible attributes, which can be measured or touched (size, features, materials, performance), and intangible attributes, which customers feel or believe (brand image, status, reliability, the experience of using it). Many customers pay more for the intangibles.
Product development
New products are needed to replace those in decline, keep up with competitors and changing tastes, enter new markets and spread risk. Development is costly and risky, as many new products fail, so businesses research customers’ needs, test ideas and often test-market before a full launch.
Differentiation and USP
Product differentiation: making a product different from competitors’ products, through design, features, quality, branding or service.
Unique selling point (USP): a feature or benefit that makes a product different from all its competitors and gives customers a reason to buy it.
A clear USP makes demand less price sensitive (customers can’t easily find a substitute), allowing higher prices and building loyalty. But USPs can be copied, so they need protecting (patents, brand) and renewing.
Product portfolio analysis
The product life cycle
| Stage | Sales and profit | Typical marketing decisions |
|---|---|---|
| Development | No sales; high costs | Research, design, testing |
| Introduction | Low sales; usually losses | Heavy promotion to create awareness; skimming or penetration pricing; limited distribution |
| Growth | Rising sales; profits start | Widen distribution; build brand; competitors enter |
| Maturity and saturation | Sales level off; profit highest; many competitors | Competitive pricing; promotion to defend share; extension strategies |
| Decline | Falling sales and profit | Cut promotion; lower price; withdraw the product or extend its life |
Extension strategies lengthen the product’s life before decline: new versions or features, new packaging, new uses, new markets (another country or customer group), price changes, or fresh promotion. They work only if the product still has appeal; a product made obsolete by technology can’t be saved this way.
Uses of the life cycle: planning when to launch new products (so that some are growing as others decline), choosing the marketing mix for each stage, and managing cash flow (new products absorb cash; mature ones generate it). Limitations: it’s hard to know which stage a product is in until afterwards, the stages vary in length, and it can become self-fulfilling if managers cut support too early.
The Boston Matrix
- Stars: high share of a fast-growing market; profitable but need investment to keep up with growth.
- Cash cows: high share of a slow-growing market; generate more cash than they need, funding other products.
- Question marks (problem children): low share of a fast-growing market; need heavy investment to become stars, or may fail.
- Dogs: low share of a slow-growing market; little profit; candidates for withdrawal.
Uses: it shows whether the business has a balanced portfolio, helps decide where to invest (use cash cows to fund question marks), which products to drop, and when new products are needed. Limitations: it only uses two factors; it’s a snapshot; market share doesn’t always mean profitability; dogs can still be profitable or support other products; and defining the market is a judgement.
Pricing methods
| Method | How it works | When useful | Drawbacks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Competitive | Price set at or near rivals’ prices | Markets with similar products and strong competition | Ignores the firm’s own costs; may lead to price wars |
| Penetration | Low price at launch to win market share quickly, raised later | Mass markets with price-sensitive customers; to build loyalty | Low early profits; customers may resist later price rises |
| Skimming | High price at launch, lowered over time | New, innovative products with a USP and keen early buyers | Attracts competitors; only works while the product is unique |
| Price discrimination | Different prices to different customer groups for the same product | When markets can be separated: peak and off-peak travel, student discounts | Customers paying more may feel it is unfair |
| Dynamic | Prices change continuously with demand, often online and automatic | Airlines, hotels, ride-hailing apps, online retail | Can upset customers; needs good data and technology |
| Cost-based (cost-plus) | Unit cost plus a percentage mark-up | Simple; makes sure each sale covers its costs | Ignores demand and competitors’ prices |
| Psychological | Prices set to influence perceptions, such as $9.99 instead of $10, or high prices to signal quality | Consumer products bought on impulse or for status | Effect may be small; customers may see through it |
cost-plus price = unit cost × (1 + mark-up %)
Example: a unit cost of $8 with a 50% mark-up gives a price of 8 × 1.5 = $12.
The right method depends on the business’s objectives (market share or profit), the product’s stage in its life cycle, competition, costs, and how price sensitive customers are.
Answering the Paper 1 and 2 questions
Typical questions: “‘Having a unique selling point is the most important part of the marketing mix for the success of a mobile phone manufacturer.’ Evaluate this view”; “Evaluate the view that new product development is the most important activity for the success of a toy manufacturer”; or “Discuss whether changing the price element of its marketing mix is the most effective way for a loss-making clothing retailer to survive.”
In Paper 1 Section B you answer one two-part essay: part (a) for 8 marks and part (b) for 12 marks. Each Paper 2 question ends with an 8-mark part and a 12-mark part. The 12-mark parts must include evaluation, and long answers are marked on knowledge, application, analysis and evaluation. Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order:
- Knowledge: define the terms: marketing mix, USP, differentiation, product life cycle, Boston Matrix, the pricing method in the question.
- Application: apply them to the business and its market: what the products are, the competition, the stage of the life cycle, the customers’ sensitivity to price.
- Analysis: build chains: for example, a USP such as a longer battery life makes customers less sensitive to price, so the phone maker can charge more, raising its profit margin.
- Evaluation: weigh the element against the rest of the mix (a USP fails without good promotion and distribution), consider how easily rivals can copy it, the costs involved, and the market conditions.
- Conclusion: make a justified judgement, for example: a USP is very important in a competitive phone market, but only when supported by the rest of a coordinated marketing mix.
Check yourself
What is the difference between tangible and intangible attributes?
Tangible attributes can be measured or touched (features, size); intangible attributes are felt or believed (brand image, status, reliability).
Give three extension strategies.
Any three of: new version or features; new packaging; new uses; new markets; price changes; fresh promotion.
What is a cash cow, and why is it valuable?
A product with a high share of a slow-growing market; it generates more cash than it needs, which can fund other products.
When would a business use price skimming?
When launching a new, innovative product with a USP and buyers willing to pay a high price to have it first.
A product costs $20 to make and the business adds a 40% mark-up. What is the price?
$28.
Now practise it
Try the 76 past paper questions on The marketing mix: product and price, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.