← Topical Vault

Policies to correct imbalances in the current account of the balance of payments Revision notes

Unit 6: International economic issues · Chapter 29 · about 10 minutes · written for the 9708 syllabus · last checked 2026-11-17

The final AS chapter brings together the policies of Unit 5 and the international economics of Unit 6. It asks how a government can reduce a current account deficit (or surplus), and what each policy costs. Essays nearly always ask you to compare two policies, so the trade-offs are the heart of this topic.

The objective: a stable current account

Governments don’t usually aim for an exact balance, but they want to avoid large and persistent imbalances. A big, long-lasting deficit means building up foreign debt or selling assets, and leaves the currency vulnerable to a sudden fall; a big surplus can fuel inflation and tension with trading partners. Before choosing a policy, identify the cause of the imbalance (see the current account): too much domestic demand, uncompetitive industries, or an overvalued currency each need a different response.

Policies to reduce a deficit work in two ways:

  • Expenditure-reducing policies cut total spending in the economy, including spending on imports.
  • Expenditure-switching policies persuade people at home and abroad to switch spending from foreign goods to domestic goods.

Fiscal policy

Contractionary fiscal policy (higher income taxes or lower government spending) reduces households’ disposable income and aggregate demand. With less to spend, people buy fewer imports, so the deficit narrows. Firms facing weaker demand at home may also try harder to sell abroad. It is expenditure-reducing.

  • Strengths: works directly on a deficit caused by excessive consumer demand; also reduces inflation and the budget deficit.
  • Weaknesses: reduces output and employment, because most spending cut is on domestic goods, not imports, so the cost in lost jobs can be large for a small improvement; politically unpopular; does nothing about poor competitiveness.

Monetary policy

Higher interest rates reduce borrowing and spending, cutting imports (expenditure-reducing). But they also attract money from abroad, causing the currency to appreciate, which makes exports dearer and imports cheaper, the opposite of what is needed. So the overall effect on the current account is uncertain.

Lower interest rates tend to make the currency depreciate, making exports cheaper and imports dearer (expenditure-switching), but they also boost domestic spending, some of which goes on imports.

  • Strengths: quick to change; a depreciation can improve competitiveness without direct controls.
  • Weaknesses: conflicting effects; a depreciation raises import prices and inflation; it only works if demand for exports and imports is price elastic, and often only after a delay; interest rates are usually set to meet the inflation target, not the current account.

Supply-side policy

Supply-side policies such as training, infrastructure, support for research and lower business costs raise productivity and quality, so domestic firms become more competitive at home and abroad. Exports rise and imports are replaced by domestic goods: a lasting form of expenditure-switching.

  • Strengths: tackles the root cause of a deficit caused by uncompetitiveness; raises output and employment rather than reducing them; no retaliation.
  • Weaknesses: takes years to work; costly; results are uncertain; higher incomes from growth may also raise spending on imports.

Protectionist policies

Tariffs, quotas and other barriers make imports dearer or limit them directly, switching spending to domestic goods; export subsidies make exports cheaper abroad.

  • Strengths: quick and direct; can protect jobs in import-competing industries; tariffs raise revenue.
  • Weaknesses: other countries may retaliate, cutting the country’s exports and possibly leaving the current account no better; breaks WTO rules in many cases; raises prices for consumers and costs for firms using imports; protected firms have less incentive to become efficient, so the underlying problem remains.

Comparing the policies

PolicyHow it worksSpeedMain cost
Contractionary fiscalExpenditure-reducingFairly quickLower output and jobs
Monetary (interest rates)Reducing or switching, with conflicting effects through the exchange rateQuick to change, slow to actInflation (if depreciating) or lower growth
Supply-sideLong-run expenditure-switching through competitivenessSlowCost to the government; uncertain results
ProtectionistExpenditure-switchingQuickRetaliation, higher prices, inefficiency

Correcting a surplus uses the same tools in reverse: expansionary fiscal or monetary policy to raise domestic spending (including on imports), allowing the currency to appreciate, or removing trade barriers.

Answering the Paper 2 essay

Typical questions: “Assess whether contractionary fiscal policy is likely to be the best way to reduce a current account deficit”; “Assess whether it is better to use protectionist policies or contractionary policies to reduce a current account deficit”; or “Assess the extent to which supply-side policy would be the best way to reduce a deficit on the current account.”

Section C questions (on macroeconomics and international issues) come in two parts: part (a), worth 8 marks, asks you to explain and then briefly consider; part (b), worth 12 marks, asks you to assess. Plan both in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:

  1. Knowledge: define a current account deficit, the policies in the question, and expenditure-reducing and expenditure-switching.
  2. Application: use examples: a country with a deficit caused by a consumer boom; one whose manufacturing has become uncompetitive; tariffs imposed to cut imports and the retaliation that followed.
  3. Analysis: explain each chain: for example, higher income tax reduces disposable income, so spending on imports falls and the deficit narrows, but AD also falls, reducing output and employment. Use an AD/AS diagram where it helps.
  4. Evaluation: the best policy depends on the cause of the deficit; compare side effects (unemployment, inflation, retaliation), speed, cost and the price elasticity of demand for exports and imports; consider whether the deficit needs correcting at all.
  5. Conclusion: make a judgement, for example: supply-side policy is the best long-term solution to a deficit caused by uncompetitiveness, while contractionary policy suits a deficit caused by excess demand; protectionism risks retaliation and rarely solves the problem.

Check yourself

What is the difference between expenditure-reducing and expenditure-switching policies?

Expenditure-reducing policies cut total spending, including on imports; expenditure-switching policies shift spending from foreign goods to domestic goods.

How does contractionary fiscal policy reduce a current account deficit?

Higher taxes or lower spending reduce disposable income and AD, so households buy fewer imports.

Why might higher interest rates fail to reduce a current account deficit?

They also cause the currency to appreciate, making exports dearer and imports cheaper, which works against the fall in spending.

Give one strength and one weakness of supply-side policy for the current account.

Strength: tackles the root cause by making firms more competitive, without cutting output. Weakness: slow, costly and uncertain.

Why might protectionism leave the current account no better off?

Trading partners may retaliate with their own barriers, reducing the country’s exports by as much as its imports fall.

Now practise it

Try the 56 past paper questions on Policies to correct imbalances in the current account of the balance of payments, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.

Practise Policies to correct imbalances in the current account of the balance of payments questions →