← Topical Vault

Trade unions Revision notes

Chapter 19 · about 11 minutes · written for the 0455 syllabus · last checked 2026-11-19

In the current syllabus trade unions appear as one of the influences on how wages are set: you need to understand how they raise wages and what decides their relative bargaining power against employers. This note concentrates on exactly that.

Trade union: an organisation of workers that acts on behalf of its members to improve their pay and working conditions.

Collective bargaining: negotiation between a trade union, on behalf of all its members, and an employer (or employers’ association), about pay and conditions.

How unions try to raise wages

  • Collective bargaining: one union negotiating for thousands of workers has far more influence than each worker alone, who could easily be replaced.
  • Industrial action, if negotiations fail: a strike (refusing to work), a work-to-rule (doing only the minimum the contract requires), an overtime ban or a go-slow. These cost the employer output and profit, putting pressure on it to agree.
  • Other roles: protecting members’ jobs and health and safety, representing members in disputes, and campaigning for laws such as a minimum wage.

Relative bargaining power

Whether a union wins higher pay depends on how strong it is relative to the employer.

A union is stronger when…Why
A high proportion of the workers are membersA strike would stop production completely.
Workers are skilled and hard to replaceThe employer cannot easily hire others or use machines instead.
Demand for the product is strong and the employer is profitableThe firm can afford higher pay and loses a lot from a strike.
Unemployment is lowWorkers can find other jobs, and the firm cannot easily recruit replacements.
Labour costs are a small part of total costsA pay rise adds little to the firm’s costs.
The union has funds to support strikers, and public opinion is on its sideMembers can afford to strike for longer; the employer faces public pressure.
Laws make it easy to organise and take industrial actionStrikes can be called quickly and legally.

The employer is stronger when it is large, can move production elsewhere or replace workers with machines, has large stocks of finished goods, or when unemployment is high.

Effects on wages and employment

In (a) a trade union negotiates a wage W2 above the market wage W1: firms employ fewer workers, Q2 instead of Q1. In (b) the union also helps raise productivity (training, better working practices), so the demand for labour rises from DL1 to DL2 and both the wage and employment rise Wage Labour 0 (a) Higher wage, fewer jobs SL Q1 W1 DL Q2 W2 Wage Labour 0 (b) Higher wage and productivity SL Q1 W1 DL1 DL2 Q2 W2
A union can raise wages; whether jobs are lost depends on what happens to the demand for labour.
  • If a union negotiates a wage above the market level and nothing else changes, the firm employs fewer workers (diagram (a)) — just like a minimum wage. Workers who keep their jobs gain; some lose them or are not hired.
  • But unions can also raise productivity: by agreeing to training and new working methods, and by making workers feel fairly treated, they may increase the demand for labour, so higher wages and more jobs are both possible (diagram (b)).
  • Higher wages may be passed on to consumers in higher prices if demand for the product is inelastic, or may reduce the firm’s profits and investment.
  • Industrial action costs output and income for workers, firms and the wider economy.

Example. Train drivers are highly skilled, take more than a year to train, and almost all belong to one union. A strike stops the whole railway, and the train company cannot quickly hire replacements. Their bargaining power is strong, so they are likely to win a pay rise. Cleaners at the same company, easily replaced and less unionised, have much weaker bargaining power.

Common mistakes: saying unions always cause unemployment; ignoring the employer’s side when explaining bargaining power; and describing strikes without explaining why they pressure the employer (lost output and profit).

Answering the Paper 1 and 2 questions

Typical questions: “Define a trade union”; “Explain two factors that increase a trade union’s bargaining power”; “Analyse how a trade union could raise its members’ wages”; “Discuss whether trade unions benefit workers.”

Paper 1 has 40 multiple-choice questions in an hour: work out the answer before you look at the options, because the wrong options are the answers you get from the common mistakes. Paper 2 (2 hours) has a compulsory data question in Section A and three structured questions, from a choice of four, in Section B. Short parts ask you to define, identify, calculate or explain; longer parts ask you to analyse or discuss, and a “discuss” answer is marked on analysis and on evaluation — both sides, then a judgement. Plan every “analyse” or “discuss” answer in the same five steps, in this order:

  1. Knowledge: define a trade union and collective bargaining, and identify the influences on bargaining power.
  2. Application: apply them to the workers in the question: their skills, membership, the employer’s position and the state of the economy.
  3. Analysis: explain the chain: for example, high membership and scarce skills → a strike would stop production → the employer loses profit → it is more likely to agree to higher pay.
  4. Evaluation: consider the other side: higher wages may cost jobs if the demand for labour does not rise, strikes cost members their pay, and employers may automate or move production.
  5. Conclusion: reach a judgement, for example: unions benefit workers most when they raise pay and productivity together; where they push pay far above productivity, some jobs may be lost.

Check yourself

Define collective bargaining.

Negotiation between a trade union, on behalf of its members, and an employer about pay and conditions.

Why does high unemployment weaken a trade union?

Employers can more easily replace striking workers, and workers fear losing their jobs.

Give two forms of industrial action.

Any two: strike, work-to-rule, overtime ban, go-slow.

Why might a union-negotiated pay rise not cause job losses?

If productivity or demand for the product rises at the same time, the demand for labour rises too.

Why are skilled workers’ unions usually stronger?

Skilled workers are hard to replace, so a strike costs the employer more.

Now practise it

Try the 24 past paper questions on Trade unions, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.

Practise Trade unions questions →