Most people earn their income by selling their labour. This topic looks at the labour market from both sides: why people choose particular jobs, how wages are set, why some workers earn far more than others, how easily workers can move between jobs, and the effects of workers specialising.
Choosing an occupation: wage and non-wage factors
Wage factors are the money rewards: the basic wage or salary, overtime pay, bonuses and commission. Non-wage factors are everything else that makes a job more or less attractive:
- job security and promotion prospects; training and qualifications offered;
- working hours, holidays and flexibility; working conditions (safe, pleasant, indoors);
- fringe benefits: pension, health insurance, company car, discounts;
- location and travel time; job satisfaction and status; the people you work with.
Example. Lena is offered two jobs: an engineering job on an offshore oil rig paying $70,000 a year, with long shifts away from home, and a job in a city design office paying $55,000, with regular hours, training and a pension. Lena might choose the lower-paid job because its non-wage factors are worth more than the $15,000 difference. The oil company has to pay more partly to make up for the poor non-wage factors.
How wages are determined
In a free labour market, the wage is the price of labour, set by the demand for and supply of workers.
- Demand for labour comes from employers, and is a derived demand: firms want workers to produce goods and services. It increases when demand for the product rises, when workers become more productive, or when machines that could replace them become more expensive.
- Supply of labour is the number of people willing and able to do the job. It is lower when the job needs rare skills or long training, has poor non-wage factors, or the working population is small; it rises with population growth, immigration and better access to training.
Two other influences can move wages away from the free-market level:
- Trade unions bargain on behalf of their members for higher pay; their success depends on their relative bargaining power compared with employers (see trade unions).
- Government policy: a national minimum wage, the pay of public sector workers (who are employed by the government), and laws on equal pay and discrimination.
The national minimum wage
National minimum wage (NMW): the lowest wage per hour that employers are legally allowed to pay workers.
In a labour market the equilibrium wage is $8 an hour and 1,000 workers are employed. A NMW of $10 is introduced. At $10, employers demand only 850 workers, while 1,150 people want to work. Employment falls by 150; unemployment in this market is 1,150 − 850 = 300. Those still employed earn more: the total wage bill rises from 1,000 × $8 = $8,000 to 850 × $10 = $8,500 an hour.
| Advantages of a NMW | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Raises the incomes of the lowest-paid and reduces poverty and inequality | May cause unemployment if set well above the market wage, especially among young and unskilled workers |
| Better-paid workers may be more motivated and stay longer, raising productivity | Raises firms’ costs, which may lead to higher prices or lower profits and investment |
| Higher spending by low-paid workers can boost demand in the economy | Some firms may employ workers illegally below the minimum, or replace them with machines |
Whether unemployment results depends on how far above the market wage the NMW is set, how responsive firms’ demand for labour is to wages, and whether demand for labour is rising anyway.
Why wages differ
| Reason | Effect on wages |
|---|---|
| Demand for and supply of labour | High demand and scarce supply (surgeons, software engineers) give high wages; low demand and plentiful supply (cleaners, farm labourers) give low wages. |
| Relative bargaining strength | Workers in strong trade unions, or with rare skills, can negotiate higher pay than unorganised workers. |
| Discrimination | Some groups — for example women compared with men — may be paid less for the same work, or kept out of higher-paid jobs. |
| Government policy | A minimum wage raises the lowest pay; equal pay laws reduce discrimination; the government sets public sector pay. |
These reasons explain the patterns you see:
- Skill: skilled workers usually earn more than unskilled workers — supply is scarcer (long training) and they are more productive, so demand is higher.
- Sector: primary sector jobs (farming, fishing, mining) are often low-paid, apart from some skilled mining jobs; secondary (manufacturing) and many tertiary (services such as finance, law and IT) jobs pay more, as productivity and the value of the output are higher. As countries develop, workers move from the primary to the secondary and tertiary sectors.
- Discrimination: women are paid less on average than men in most countries, partly because of discrimination and partly because they are more often in lower-paid or part-time work.
- Private or public sector: public sector pay is set by the government and is often lower at the top than private sector pay, but with greater job security and better pensions; private sector pay responds more quickly to demand and profits.
Mobility of labour
Occupational mobility: how easily workers can move from one type of job to another.
Geographical mobility: how easily workers can move from one area to another to take a job.
| Changes in mobility are caused by | Consequences |
|---|---|
| Occupational: education and training (retraining schemes raise mobility); qualifications and licences required; the time and cost of training; transferable skills | Low mobility: workers made unemployed in a declining industry cannot fill vacancies in growing ones, so unemployment and skills shortages exist side by side |
| Geographical: differences in housing costs between areas; family and social ties; cost of moving; lack of information about jobs elsewhere; language and immigration rules | High mobility: workers move to where they are most productive, unemployment falls, firms fill vacancies, and wage differences between areas narrow |
The division of labour
Division of labour: breaking production into separate tasks, with each worker specialising in one task (worker specialisation).
| Advantages | Disadvantages | |
|---|---|---|
| For workers | Become skilled and fast at their task; may earn more as productivity rises; less training needed for one task | Boredom and lack of variety; skills are narrow, so low occupational mobility; risk of unemployment if the task is automated |
| For firms | Higher output per worker and lower costs; workers placed in tasks that suit them; time not wasted moving between tasks | Bored workers may make mistakes and leave; if one stage stops (absence, a strike), the whole process stops; higher quality-control costs |
| For the economy | More output from the same resources, so higher living standards | Areas that depend on one specialised industry suffer badly if it declines |
Common mistakes: listing pay as a non-wage factor; drawing the labour market with “Price” and “Quantity” instead of wage and quantity of labour; and saying a minimum wage always causes unemployment (it does only if it is set above the market wage, and the effect may be small).
Answering the Paper 1 and 2 questions
Typical questions: “Identify two non-wage factors that influence a person’s choice of occupation”; “Explain why a surgeon earns more than a cleaner”; “Draw a diagram to show the effect of a national minimum wage”; “Analyse the advantages to a firm of the division of labour”; “Discuss whether a government should raise the national minimum wage.”
Paper 1 has 40 multiple-choice questions in an hour: work out the answer before you look at the options, because the wrong options are the answers you get from the common mistakes. Paper 2 (2 hours) has a compulsory data question in Section A and three structured questions, from a choice of four, in Section B. Short parts ask you to define, identify, calculate or explain; longer parts ask you to analyse or discuss, and a “discuss” answer is marked on analysis and on evaluation — both sides, then a judgement. Plan every “analyse” or “discuss” answer in the same five steps, in this order:
- Knowledge: define the terms (derived demand, NMW, occupational and geographical mobility, division of labour) and identify the influences on demand and supply of labour.
- Application: apply them to the workers or jobs in the question, using any data, and draw the labour market or NMW diagram where it helps.
- Analysis: explain the chain: for example, a NMW above the market wage → firms’ costs rise → they demand fewer workers while more people want to work → unemployment, but higher pay for those in work.
- Evaluation: weigh the other side: how far above the market wage it is set, whether higher pay raises productivity and spending, and the effect on poverty and firms’ profits.
- Conclusion: reach a judgement, for example: a moderate rise in the NMW is likely to reduce poverty without causing much unemployment, but a large rise could cost jobs for young and unskilled workers.
Check yourself
Why is the demand for labour a derived demand?
Firms want workers only because they want to produce goods and services that consumers demand.
Give two non-wage factors that make a job attractive.
Any two: job security, promotion prospects, training, good working conditions, holidays, pension, location, job satisfaction.
The equilibrium wage is $12 and a NMW of $10 is set. What happens?
Nothing: a minimum wage below the market wage has no effect.
What is geographical immobility of labour, and give one cause?
Difficulty moving to another area for work; for example high housing costs in the area with jobs, or family ties.
Give one disadvantage of the division of labour for workers.
Any one: boredom, narrow skills (low occupational mobility), risk of being replaced by machines.
Now practise it
Try the 103 past paper questions on Workers, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.