← Topical Vault

Private costs and benefits, externalities and social costs and benefits Revision notes

Unit 7: The price system and the microeconomy · Chapter 33 · about 14 minutes · written for the 9708 syllabus · last checked 2026-11-14

Externalities are the most common example of market failure in exam questions, and the four diagrams in this topic come up again and again, both on their own and as the starting point for questions on taxes, subsidies and regulation. This topic also covers what happens when buyers and sellers don’t have the same information, and how governments weigh up big projects using cost–benefit analysis.

Externalities

Externality: a side effect of producing or consuming something that falls on a third party, someone not involved in the decision, and is not paid for (or paid to them).

Negative externality: the side effect harms third parties, imposing an external cost.

Positive externality: the side effect helps third parties, giving them an external benefit.

Examples: a factory dumping waste into a river harms people who fish there (negative). A person who gets vaccinated protects the people around them from catching the disease (positive). Neighbours of a new airport suffer from noise (negative).

The externality is the effect on the third party, not the action itself. “The factory produces chemicals” is the action. “People downstream can no longer fish” is the externality.

Private, external and social costs and benefits

Private costs (PC) and private benefits (PB): the costs paid and benefits received by the people directly involved: the producer and the consumer.

External costs (EC) and external benefits (EB): the costs and benefits that fall on third parties.

Social costs (SC) and social benefits (SB): the total costs and benefits to the whole of society.

Social cost = private cost + external cost

Social benefit = private benefit + external benefit

When you drive to school, your private cost is fuel and wear on the car. But you also add to congestion, air pollution and the risk of accidents for others, which are external costs. The social cost of the journey is the total of both.

Worked example

A cement works has private costs of $40 per tonne. Dust from the works damages local crops and people’s health, which is valued at $15 per tonne. Social cost = 40 + 15 = $55 per tonne. The firm bases its decisions on $40, so it produces as if cement were cheaper to make than it really is for society.

The same formulas work backwards: if social benefit is $90 and private benefit is $70, the external benefit is 90 − 70 = $20.

The same terms are used “at the margin” on the diagrams: MPC, MEC and MSC for the cost of one more unit, and MPB, MEB and MSB for the benefit of one more unit. So MSC = MPC + MEC and MSB = MPB + MEB.

Why externalities cause market failure

A free market settles where the people involved are happy: where MPB = MPC (demand meets supply). But society as a whole would be best off where MSB = MSC, the allocatively efficient output. When there is an externality, these two outputs are different:

  • with a negative externality the market produces or consumes too much;
  • with a positive externality the market produces or consumes too little.

Deadweight welfare loss: the loss of net benefit to society caused by producing the wrong quantity. On the diagram it is the triangle between MSC and MSB, from the market output to the social optimum.

A simple way to remember which curve moves:

Production externalities change the cost curves (MSC is drawn apart from MPC). Consumption externalities change the benefit curves (MSB is drawn apart from MPB). In all four diagrams, Q1 is where MPB = MPC (what the market does) and Q* is where MSB = MSC (what society wants).

The four diagrams

1. Negative production externality

Example: a chemical factory polluting the air. The firm only pays its private costs, so its supply curve is MPC. The real cost to society, MSC, is higher by the marginal external cost.

Negative production externality: the market produces Q1, more than the social optimum Q*, causing a deadweight loss Costs and benefits Quantity 0 D = MPB = MSB S = MPC MSC Q* Q1 DWL
The market produces Q1 where MPB = MPC. The social optimum is Q*, where MSB = MSC. Each unit between Q* and Q1 costs society more than it is worth, so the shaded triangle is a deadweight loss from overproduction.

This is the externality diagram examiners ask for most. The MEC usually grows with output (more production, more pollution), so MSC is drawn diverging from MPC, as here.

2. Positive production externality

Example: a firm that trains its workers, who later take their skills to other firms; or a farmer planting trees that absorb carbon dioxide. The firm’s activities benefit others, so the cost to society is lower than the private cost: MSC is below MPC.

Positive production externality: the market produces Q1, less than the social optimum Q*, causing a deadweight loss Costs and benefits Quantity 0 D = MPB = MSB S = MPC MSC Q* Q1 DWL
The market produces Q1, less than the social optimum Q*. The shaded triangle is the deadweight loss from underproduction.

3. Negative consumption externality

Example: smoking in public places harms non-smokers; noisy, littering crowds after a big event affect people living nearby. The benefit to society is lower than the benefit to the consumer, so MSB is below MPB.

Negative consumption externality: the market consumes Q1, more than the social optimum Q*, causing a deadweight loss Costs and benefits Quantity 0 D = MPB S = MPC = MSC MSB Q* Q1 DWL
Consumers buy Q1, where MPB = MPC, but society’s optimum is Q*, where MSB = MSC. The shaded triangle is the deadweight loss from overconsumption.

4. Positive consumption externality

Example: education, vaccinations and healthcare. An educated, healthy person benefits themselves, but also their family, their employer and the economy as a whole. MSB is above MPB.

Positive consumption externality: the market consumes Q1, less than the social optimum Q*, causing a deadweight loss Costs and benefits Quantity 0 D = MPB S = MPC = MSC MSB Q* Q1 DWL
Consumers buy only Q1 because they consider their own benefit, not the benefit to others. Society would be better off at Q*. The shaded triangle is the deadweight loss from underconsumption.

Students often draw the deadweight loss triangle in the wrong place. It always points towards the social optimum Q*, and is bounded by MSC and MSB, not by the private curves. Check: the triangle sits between Q* and Q1, with its tip at the point where MSB = MSC.

The government policies used to correct these failures (taxes, subsidies, regulation, tradable permits and so on) are covered in government policies to correct market failure.

Asymmetric information

Asymmetric information: when one side of a transaction (buyer or seller) has more or better information than the other.

Markets work well only if both sides understand what they are trading. Often they don’t: a doctor knows far more about your illness than you do; the seller of a used scooter knows whether it has been in an accident; a person buying insurance knows more about their own health and habits than the insurer. There are two kinds of problem.

Adverse selection (hidden characteristics)

Adverse selection: when one side can’t tell the quality of what is being traded, so the market ends up attracting mainly the “bad” cases: poor-quality goods, or high-risk customers.

The used car market: buyers can’t tell a good car from a bad one, so they will only pay an average price. Owners of good cars think that is too low and don’t sell. So the cars actually for sale are mostly poor ones, buyers expect this, offer even less, and more good cars leave the market. In the extreme, the market for good used cars disappears.

Insurance: at a given premium, people who know they are high-risk are the keenest to buy health or life insurance, while low-risk people may decide it’s not worth it. The insurer ends up with riskier customers than it expected and has to raise premiums, which drives away even more low-risk customers.

Moral hazard (hidden actions)

Moral hazard: the temptation to take more risks when someone else will bear the cost if things go wrong.

Once a phone is insured, its owner may be less careful with it. Once a driver is fully insured, they may drive less carefully. Banks that believe the government will rescue them if they fail (“too big to fail”) may make riskier loans. In each case the other party can’t watch what is being done, so they can’t prevent it.

Ways to reduce these problems include warranties and independent inspections (used cars), medical checks and higher premiums for higher-risk groups (insurance), an excess, where the policyholder pays the first part of any claim so they still have a reason to be careful, and government regulation, such as requiring sellers to disclose information.

Don’t mix them up. Adverse selection happens before the deal, because of hidden information about quality or risk. Moral hazard happens after the deal, because of hidden behaviour.

Cost–benefit analysis

Cost–benefit analysis (CBA): a way of deciding whether a project should go ahead by adding up all its costs and benefits to society, private and external, in money terms.

A private firm only asks whether its own revenue will cover its own costs. A government deciding on a new road, railway, hospital or dam needs a wider view: who else gains, who else loses, and over many years. CBA is especially useful for public goods, where nobody pays directly, so there is no market price to go on.

The four stages

  1. Identify all the costs and benefits: private, external, now and in the future, and who receives each one.
  2. Value them in money. Some have market prices (construction costs, wages). Others don’t (time saved by travellers, cleaner air, a quieter neighbourhood, a life saved), so economists estimate a shadow price.
  3. Forecast how the costs and benefits will change over the life of the project, often 30 years or more. Money in the future is worth less than money today, so future values are scaled down.
  4. Decide: if total social benefits are greater than total social costs, the project is worthwhile. When funds are limited, the projects with the highest benefit–cost ratio (social benefit ÷ social cost) are chosen first.

Worked example

$ millionPrivate benefitExternal benefitPrivate costExternal cost
Shopping mall20020130110
Railway line15011018030
  • Shopping mall: private benefit 200 − private cost 130 = a profit of $70m, so a firm would happily build it. But social benefit (220) − social cost (240) = −$20m. Society is worse off.
  • Railway line: private benefit 150 − private cost 180 = a loss of $30m, so no firm would build it. But social benefit (260) − social cost (210) = +$50m. Society gains. This is the kind of project governments fund, because the market won’t.

Evaluating CBA

Strengths: it is a clear, systematic method; it makes decision-makers think about third parties and the environment, not just money; it allows very different projects to be compared on the same basis; and it makes decisions more transparent.

Weaknesses:

  • Valuing things without a price is hard and controversial. What is a quiet garden worth? A rare species? A human life? Different estimates can change the answer completely.
  • It is hard to identify everyone affected, or where to draw the line. A new road affects traffic and businesses many kilometres away.
  • Forecasting costs and benefits decades ahead is very uncertain, and big projects often go over budget.
  • It ignores who gains and who loses. A project with a positive net benefit could make poor people worse off and rich people better off.
  • It can be biased. Groups who want a project may push for generous estimates of its benefits, and the final decision is often political anyway.
  • A full CBA is expensive and slow to carry out.

Answering the Paper 4 essay

Typical questions: “Explain, with a diagram, why negative externalities lead to market failure”; “The existence of externalities means that the government should provide the good. Discuss”; or “Assess the usefulness of cost–benefit analysis in deciding whether to build a new hospital.”

Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:

  1. Knowledge: define externality and third party, the private, external and social costs and benefits (SC = PC + EC, SB = PB + EB), allocative efficiency (MSB = MSC) and deadweight loss.
  2. Application: use a real example that fits the question: air travel or plastic waste (negative), vaccination or education (positive), electric cars (lower pollution than petrol cars). For CBA, name the actual costs and benefits of the project in the question: for a hospital, building costs, staff, shorter journeys for patients, lives saved, extra traffic for neighbours.
  3. Analysis: draw the correct diagram, labelling every curve, Q1, Q* and the deadweight loss, and explain the chain: the decision-maker ignores the external effect, so the market settles where MPB = MPC, not where MSB = MSC, producing too much or too little.
  4. Evaluation: how big is the externality, and can it be measured? Would a tax, subsidy, regulation or information campaign fix it better than state provision? Could government failure make things worse? For CBA, weigh its systematic, wide view against the difficulty of valuing intangibles, forecasting, and ignoring who gains and who loses.
  5. Conclusion: answer the question directly: for example, externalities justify some intervention, but usually a tax, subsidy or regulation rather than the government providing the good itself, which is mainly needed for public goods.

“Externalities mean the government should provide the good” is a trap statement. Externalities justify some intervention, but usually not state provision. Taxes, subsidies, regulation or information campaigns can move output to Q* while leaving production to private firms. State provision is mainly the answer for public goods.

Check yourself

How is external cost calculated from social and private cost?

External cost = social cost − private cost.

A diagram shows MSC above MPC, and MPB = MSB. What type of externality is it, and is the market producing too much or too little?

A negative production externality. The market produces where MPB = MPC, which is more than the social optimum where MSB = MSC.

Why does the market consume too little education?

Education has a positive consumption externality: MSB is above MPB. Students and families base their decisions only on the private benefit, so they consume where MPB = MPC, below the social optimum where MSB = MSC.

A person buys travel insurance and then leaves their bag unattended at the airport. Adverse selection or moral hazard?

Moral hazard: being insured changed their behaviour after the deal, because someone else now bears the cost of the risk.

Why might a government go ahead with a project that would make a loss for a private firm?

Because CBA includes external benefits. A project can lose money privately but still have social benefits greater than social costs, like the railway line in the worked example.

Now practise it

Try the 97 past paper questions on Private costs and benefits, externalities and social costs and benefits, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.

Practise Private costs and benefits, externalities and social costs and benefits questions →