This is the toolkit for the whole theory of the firm. The cost and revenue curves here are the building blocks of every market structure diagram in the next topic, so it is worth getting them exactly right. Expect calculation questions on Paper 3 (working out AFC, MC or profit from a few numbers) and Paper 4 questions on diminishing returns, economies of scale and whether bigger firms really are more efficient.
The short run and the long run
Short run: a period in which at least one factor of production is fixed (usually capital: the factory, the machines).
Long run: a period in which all factors of production can be changed: the firm can build a bigger factory or move somewhere else.
These are not set lengths of time. For a small café the long run might be a few weeks (rent a bigger shop); for a power station it could be ten years. In the very long run, even technology can change.
Short-run production
In the short run, a firm can only raise output by adding more of the variable factor, usually labour, to its fixed factory.
Total product (TP): the total output produced.
Average product (AP): output per worker = TP ÷ number of workers. It is a simple measure of labour productivity.
Marginal product (MP): the extra output from employing one more worker = change in TP ÷ change in workers.
Worked example: a small bakery with one oven
| Workers | Total product (loaves) | Marginal product | Average product |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 20 | 20 | 20 |
| 2 | 50 | 30 | 25 |
| 3 | 90 | 40 | 30 |
| 4 | 120 | 30 | 30 |
| 5 | 140 | 20 | 28 |
| 6 | 150 | 10 | 25 |
| 7 | 150 | 0 | 21.4 |
At first, extra workers help a lot: with two or three people, they can specialise (one mixes, one shapes, one runs the oven). But there is only one oven. From the 4th worker onwards, each new worker adds less than the one before, because they are sharing the same fixed equipment. By the 7th worker, they are just getting in each other’s way.
Law of diminishing returns (also called the law of variable proportions): when more and more of a variable factor is added to a fixed factor, the marginal product of the variable factor will eventually fall.
The “average and marginal” relationship works like your test marks. If your next mark (the marginal) is above your current average, your average goes up; if it is below, your average goes down. That is why the marginal curve always cuts the average curve at the average’s turning point. It is true for AP and MP, and for AC and MC.
Diminishing returns is a short-run idea (one factor fixed). Don’t use it to explain why a firm’s costs rise when it grows bigger in the long run; that is diseconomies of scale, a different idea.
Short-run costs
Fixed costs (FC): costs that don’t change with output in the short run, such as rent, insurance, interest on loans and managers’ salaries. They have to be paid even if output is zero.
Variable costs (VC): costs that change directly with output, such as raw materials, energy used in production, and hourly wages.
TC = FC + VC
AFC = FC ÷ Q AVC = VC ÷ Q ATC = TC ÷ Q = AFC + AVC
MC = change in TC ÷ change in Q
Worked example
A firm has fixed costs of $60.
| Output | TC | VC | MC | AFC | AVC | ATC |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 60 | 0 | – | – | – | – |
| 1 | 100 | 40 | 40 | 60 | 40 | 100 |
| 2 | 130 | 70 | 30 | 30 | 35 | 65 |
| 3 | 150 | 90 | 20 | 20 | 30 | 50 |
| 4 | 180 | 120 | 30 | 15 | 30 | 45 |
| 5 | 230 | 170 | 50 | 12 | 34 | 46 |
| 6 | 300 | 240 | 70 | 10 | 40 | 50 |
Notice that FC is the TC at zero output, AFC keeps falling (the same $60 is spread over more units), and ATC is lowest at 4 units ($45). The MC of the 4th unit ($30) is below ATC, so ATC is still falling; the MC of the 5th ($50) is above ATC, so ATC starts rising.
The shapes of the cost curves
- MC falls at first while marginal product is rising, then rises once diminishing returns set in: if each extra worker adds less output, each extra unit of output needs more labour, so it costs more. (If the wage is $60 and a worker’s MP is 30 units, each unit costs $2 of labour; if MP falls to 20, each unit costs $3.)
- AVC is U-shaped for the same reason.
- ATC = AFC + AVC. At low output, ATC falls because fixed costs are spread more thinly and AVC is falling. Eventually the rise in AVC outweighs the fall in AFC, so ATC rises. The gap between ATC and AVC is AFC, so the two curves get closer together as output rises.
The short-run ATC curve is U-shaped because of diminishing returns, not economies and diseconomies of scale. Scale only changes in the long run.
Long-run production: returns to scale
In the long run, the firm can increase all its inputs, for example doubling both workers and machines. Returns to scale describe what happens to output.
| Inputs double and output… | Name | Effect on long-run average cost |
|---|---|---|
| more than doubles | Increasing returns to scale | Falls |
| exactly doubles | Constant returns to scale | Stays the same |
| less than doubles | Decreasing returns to scale | Rises |
For example, if a firm increases all its inputs by 100% and its output rises by 150%, it has increasing returns to scale.
The long-run average cost curve
Long-run average cost (LRAC): the lowest possible average cost of producing each level of output when all factors can be varied.
Each size of factory has its own short-run average cost (SRAC) curve. In the long run, the firm can choose whichever size of factory gives the lowest cost for the output it wants, so the LRAC curve is made up of the lowest points available from all the possible SRAC curves. It is sometimes called an envelope curve because it wraps around them.
Minimum efficient scale (MES): the lowest level of output at which long-run average cost is at its minimum.
MES matters because it shapes the whole industry. Compare MES with the size of the market:
- If MES is small relative to market demand (hairdressers, cafés), many firms can all produce at the lowest cost, so the industry tends to be competitive.
- If MES is large (car making, aircraft, steel), only a few firms can reach it before they have supplied the whole market, so the industry tends to be an oligopoly. If MES is bigger than the whole market, a single firm can supply it most cheaply: a natural monopoly (water pipes, railway track).
Economies of scale
Economies of scale: the cost advantages a firm gets from growing larger, which make long-run average cost fall as output increases.
Internal economies of scale
These come from the firm’s own growth.
- Technical: large firms can use bigger, more efficient machinery and production lines that only make sense at high output; and some capital is cheaper per unit when bigger (a container ship twice the size doesn’t cost twice as much to build or crew). They can also take specialisation and the division of labour further.
- Purchasing (bulk buying): buying huge quantities of materials or stock earns discounts from suppliers. Large supermarket chains are the classic example.
- Marketing: advertising and distribution costs are spread over many more units, and large advertisers get better rates.
- Managerial: large firms can employ specialist managers for finance, marketing, HR and IT, who do each job better than one manager doing everything.
- Financial: banks see large firms as less risky, so they can borrow more cheaply, and can also raise money by selling shares.
- Risk-bearing: a large firm can sell many products in many countries, so a fall in demand for one doesn’t threaten the whole business.
Internal diseconomies of scale
Beyond some size, average costs can rise again, mostly because big organisations are hard to run:
- Coordination and control: it gets harder for managers to keep track of everything, and decisions take longer, with more layers of management and paperwork.
- Communication: messages pass through more people and get delayed or distorted.
- Motivation: workers can feel like a small, unimportant part of a huge organisation, doing repetitive work, so morale and productivity fall.
External economies and diseconomies of scale
External economies of scale: cost savings that benefit all the firms in an industry as the industry grows, especially when the firms are clustered in one area.
Examples: a pool of trained workers (so firms spend less on training), specialist suppliers and repair services setting up nearby, better roads and ports, and shared research, often with local universities. Think of the technology cluster in Silicon Valley, or the clothing industry around Dhaka in Bangladesh.
External diseconomies happen when an area becomes too crowded with firms: traffic congestion raises delivery costs, land and rents become expensive, and competition for skilled workers pushes up wages.
When a question asks you to “show on a diagram” the effect of external economies of scale, draw a downward shift of LRAC. Drawing a movement along the curve shows internal economies, and won’t get the mark.
Revenue
Total revenue (TR): total income from sales = price × quantity sold.
Average revenue (AR): revenue per unit = TR ÷ Q. AR is the same as price, so the AR curve is the firm’s demand curve.
Marginal revenue (MR): the extra revenue from selling one more unit = change in TR ÷ change in Q.
A price taker
A firm in perfect competition is a price taker: it can sell as much as it wants at the market price, but nothing at a higher price. Every extra unit brings in the same price, so P = AR = MR, a horizontal line.
A price maker
A firm with a downward-sloping demand curve is a price maker: to sell more, it has to lower its price on all its units, not just the extra one. So MR is less than price.
| Quantity | Price (= AR) | TR | MR |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 10 | 10 | 10 |
| 2 | 9 | 18 | 8 |
| 3 | 8 | 24 | 6 |
| 4 | 7 | 28 | 4 |
| 5 | 6 | 30 | 2 |
| 6 | 5 | 30 | 0 |
Selling the 4th unit brings in $7, but the firm loses $1 on each of the first 3 units because the price fell from $8 to $7. So MR = 7 − 3 = $4.
Profit
Economists count all the opportunity costs of a business as costs, including a reward for the entrepreneur. That reward is called normal profit.
Normal profit: the minimum profit needed to keep the entrepreneur in this industry rather than using their time and money elsewhere. It is counted as a cost, so it is included in ATC.
Supernormal (abnormal) profit: profit above normal profit, when TR is greater than TC.
Subnormal profit: profit below normal profit, when TR is less than TC. (The firm may still be making an accounting profit.)
Profit = TR − TC = (AR − ATC) × Q
Worked example
A firm sells 500 units at $12 each, and its average total cost (including normal profit) is $9. Supernormal profit = (12 − 9) × 500 = $1,500. If price fell to $8, it would make a subnormal profit (a loss in economic terms) of (8 − 9) × 500 = −$500.
Why it matters: supernormal profit is a signal that attracts new firms into an industry; subnormal profit makes firms leave in the long run. Whether a firm making a loss should keep going in the short run depends on whether it covers its variable costs: see the shutdown rule in market structures.
Normal profit is a cost, already inside ATC. A firm where AR = ATC is earning exactly normal profit, not zero profit in the everyday sense, and has no reason to leave the industry.
Answering the Paper 4 essay
Typical questions: “Explain the link between diminishing returns and the shape of a firm’s short-run MC and ATC curves”; “With the help of a diagram, assess the view that larger firms always have lower average costs than smaller firms”; or “Evaluate how market demand and minimum efficient scale determine the structure of an industry.”
Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:
- Knowledge: define economies of scale, diseconomies of scale, the LRAC curve and minimum efficient scale, and distinguish them from diminishing returns, which only applies in the short run.
- Application: give real examples of each type of economy of scale: bulk buying by supermarket chains, huge container ships (technical), cheaper borrowing for large firms (financial), clusters like Silicon Valley (external); and industries where small firms thrive, such as hairdressers, cafés and repair services.
- Analysis: draw a U-shaped (or flat-bottomed) LRAC curve and explain why it falls: each economy of scale lowers the cost per unit as output grows. Then explain why it may rise beyond MES: coordination, communication and motivation problems.
- Evaluation: larger firms do not always have lower costs: diseconomies of scale set in; once MES is reached LRAC may be flat, so a firm bigger than MES has no cost advantage (many studies find LRAC roughly L-shaped); where MES is low, small firms are just as efficient; small firms in a cluster gain external economies; large firms with market power may suffer X-inefficiency; and small firms have other advantages, such as flexibility and personal service.
- Conclusion: whether bigger means cheaper depends on the industry’s MES compared with the size of the market, and on how well the large firm is managed. The word “always” makes the statement too strong.
Check yourself
A firm’s total cost is $120,000, its AFC is $50 and its AVC is $10. How much does it produce, and what are its fixed costs?
ATC = AFC + AVC = $60. Output = TC ÷ ATC = 120,000 ÷ 60 = 2,000 units. Fixed costs = AFC × Q = 50 × 2,000 = $100,000.
Why does the short-run MC curve eventually slope upwards?
Because of diminishing returns. With capital fixed, each extra worker adds less output than the last, so each extra unit of output needs more labour and costs more to produce.
A firm doubles all its inputs and its output rises by 80%. What does this show?
Decreasing returns to scale: output has risen proportionately less than inputs, so long-run average cost rises (diseconomies of scale).
A price maker sells 3 units at $8. To sell 4 units it must cut its price to $7. What is the MR of the 4th unit?
TR rises from 3 × 8 = $24 to 4 × 7 = $28, so MR = $4, less than the $7 price, because the price cut applies to all four units.
Give one external economy and one external diseconomy of scale for firms in a crowded industrial city.
Economy: a large pool of skilled workers, or specialist suppliers nearby. Diseconomy: traffic congestion raising transport costs, or high rents and wages as firms compete for land and labour.
Why does a large MES relative to market demand lead to an industry with only a few firms?
Firms need to produce a large output to get their costs down to the minimum. If the market is only big enough for a few firms at that size, smaller firms would have higher costs and couldn’t compete, so the industry ends up with a few large firms.
Now practise it
Try the 86 past paper questions on Types of cost, revenue and profit, short-run and long-run production, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.
Practise Types of cost, revenue and profit, short-run and long-run production questions →