This is the biggest and most examined topic in A Level micro. It asks one question: how does the number of firms and the ease of entering a market change prices, output, profits and efficiency? Almost every Paper 4 micro essay uses these diagrams, so it is worth learning them until you can draw them quickly and accurately.
The four market structures
Market structures sit on a spectrum, from the most competitive to the least:
| Perfect competition | Monopolistic competition | Oligopoly | Monopoly | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Number of firms | Very many | Many | A few dominate | One (or one dominant firm) |
| Product | Identical | Differentiated (brands) | Identical or differentiated | Unique, no close substitutes |
| Barriers to entry | None | Low | High | Very high |
| Control over price | None: a price taker | Some | Some, but depends on rivals | A lot: a price maker |
| Information | Perfect | Fairly good | Imperfect | Poor |
| Real-world feel | Close: some farm products, currency markets | Restaurants, hairdressers, local builders | Supermarkets, mobile networks, car makers | Local water supply, patented medicines |
Natural monopoly: a market where long-run average costs keep falling over the whole range of demand, so one firm can supply the market more cheaply than two or more could (for example, railway track, water pipes, electricity grids).
Don’t confuse monopoly with monopolistic competition. Monopolistic competition has many firms and low barriers; each firm just has a little power over its own brand.
Concentration ratio
Concentration ratio: the combined market share of the largest few firms (usually 3, 4 or 5) in a market.
Example: the top five firms have shares of 30%, 20%, 15%, 10% and 8%. The 4-firm concentration ratio = 30 + 20 + 15 + 10 = 75%. A 4-firm ratio above roughly 60% usually signals oligopoly.
Barriers to entry and exit
Barriers to entry: anything that makes it difficult or impossible for new firms to enter a market and compete with existing firms.
- Legal barriers: patents, licences, copyrights, or the government allowing only one supplier.
- Market barriers: strong brand loyalty built by heavy advertising; existing firms filling every gap with many brands; limit pricing and predatory pricing by existing firms (see chapter 37).
- Cost barriers: huge start-up costs (car plants, aircraft, mobile networks); existing firms’ economies of scale, which mean a small newcomer has much higher average costs.
- Physical barriers: existing firms controlling the raw materials, supplies or shops that a newcomer would need.
Barriers to exit matter too. If leaving means losing sunk costs (money that can’t be recovered, such as research or specialist equipment), firms think twice about entering at all.
Revenue, output and profit: the rules for every firm
- Every profit-maximising firm produces where MC = MR, in every market structure.
- It then charges the price shown on the AR (demand) curve at that output.
- Profit per unit = AR − ATC. Total supernormal profit = (AR − ATC) × quantity: the rectangle on the diagram.
- In perfect competition, the firm’s demand curve is horizontal (it can sell any amount at the market price), so D = AR = MR. In every other structure the firm faces a downward-sloping demand curve, so MR is below AR (to sell one more unit it must cut the price on all units).
When you draw MR below a straight-line AR, start it at the same point on the price axis and make it twice as steep, so it hits the quantity axis halfway along. Examiners notice this.
Perfect competition
Each firm is too small to affect the price, so it simply takes the market price. In the short run, if the price is high, firms make supernormal profit. Because there are no barriers, that profit attracts new firms. Market supply rises, the price falls, and in the long run every firm makes only normal profit, producing at the lowest point of its ATC curve.
Shutdown price and the firm’s supply curve
Short-run shutdown price: the firm stops producing if price falls below minimum average variable cost (AVC). Above that, it at least covers its variable costs and something towards its fixed costs, which it has to pay anyway.
Long-run shutdown price: the firm leaves the industry if price stays below minimum average total cost (ATC).
Only perfect competition has a supply curve like this. In other structures firms choose price as well as output, so there is no single price-quantity supply relationship.
Monopoly
A monopoly faces the whole market’s downward-sloping demand curve. It produces where MC = MR and charges the higher price that consumers will pay for that output. Because barriers stop anyone entering, the supernormal profit can last in the long run.
Monopoly compared with perfect competition
If a competitive industry became a monopoly with the same costs:
- the price would be higher and output lower;
- some consumer surplus becomes profit for the monopolist, and some is lost altogether: a deadweight welfare loss;
- the monopoly is not allocatively efficient (price is above MC) and not productively efficient (it doesn’t produce at the lowest point of ATC);
- without competition it may become lazy about costs: X-inefficiency (costs higher than they need to be for its output).
But the case is not one-sided: a monopoly may enjoy big economies of scale, so its costs, and even its price, could be lower than many small firms could manage. Its secure profits can fund research and new products (dynamic efficiency). And the comparison assumes perfect competition, which barely exists in reality.
In “Is monopoly always bad?” essays, the strongest evaluation is about economies of scale and dynamic efficiency versus higher prices, X-inefficiency and lost consumer surplus. It often depends on whether the monopoly is regulated and whether the market is contestable.
Monopolistic competition
Many firms sell similar but differentiated products, so each has a gently downward-sloping demand curve (it can raise its price a little without losing every customer). In the short run a firm may make supernormal profit, just like a monopoly. But barriers are low, so new firms enter, taking customers. Each firm’s demand curve shifts left until, in the long run, it just touches the ATC curve: normal profit.
So in the long run, firms in monopolistic competition are neither productively efficient (they don’t reach the bottom of ATC; there is excess capacity) nor allocatively efficient (P > MC). The upside for consumers is variety and choice of brands.
Firms here compete heavily through non-price competition, such as advertising, branding, quality and service, to make their demand curve less elastic and keep profits a little longer.
Oligopoly
A few large firms dominate, protected by high barriers. The key feature is interdependence: each firm’s best decision depends on how its rivals react. That is why there is no single neat oligopoly diagram, but there are three ideas you need.
1. The kinked demand curve (no collusion)
Suppose a firm assumes:
- if it raises its price, rivals will not follow, so it loses lots of customers (demand above the current price is elastic);
- if it cuts its price, rivals will follow to protect their market share, so it gains few customers (demand below the current price is inelastic).
Either way, its revenue falls, so it keeps its price where it is. The kink creates a vertical gap in MR: marginal cost can rise or fall within that gap with no change in the profit-maximising price. This explains price rigidity, prices staying the same for long periods.
Criticisms: the model doesn’t explain how the price at the kink was reached in the first place, and in reality oligopolies sometimes have fierce price wars.
2. Collusion, cartels and price leadership
Because price wars hurt everyone, oligopolists have a reason to collude: to act together like a single monopoly and share the profit.
- Cartel (formal collusion): an agreement to fix prices or limit output. It is illegal in most countries (OPEC is an international example between governments).
- Tacit collusion and price leadership: no agreement, but firms follow the price set by a dominant firm. This is harder to prove and often not illegal.
3. The Prisoner’s Dilemma (game theory)
Two firms, A and B, each choose a high or a low price. Profits ($m) are shown as A, B:
| B charges a high price | B charges a low price | |
|---|---|---|
| A charges a high price | 10, 10 | 4, 14 |
| A charges a low price | 14, 4 | 6, 6 |
Look at it from A’s point of view. If B goes high, A earns more by going low (14 > 10). If B goes low, A still earns more by going low (6 > 4). So going low is A’s best choice whatever B does (its dominant strategy), and the same is true for B. Both end up on low prices earning 6 each, although both would earn 10 if they both kept prices high.
This shows two things examiners want: why firms are tempted to collude (to reach 10, 10), and why cartels tend to break down (each member is tempted to cheat and undercut to get 14).
Price and non-price competition
Because price cuts are risky and quickly copied, oligopolists often prefer non-price competition: advertising, branding, loyalty schemes, new features and models, after-sales service, and process innovation that cuts costs.
Efficiency across market structures
| Structure | Allocative (P = MC) | Productive (min ATC) | Profit in the long run |
|---|---|---|---|
| Perfect competition | Yes | Yes (long run) | Normal |
| Monopolistic competition | No | No: excess capacity | Normal |
| Oligopoly | Usually no | Usually no | Often supernormal |
| Monopoly | No | No; may be X-inefficient | Supernormal |
X-inefficiency: when a firm’s costs are higher than they need to be for the output it produces, usually because a lack of competition means there is little pressure to control costs.
Remember dynamic efficiency (improvements over time through innovation): firms with supernormal profit, like oligopolies and monopolies, may be the ones that can afford it.
Contestable markets
Contestable market: a market where entry is free and exit is costless (no sunk costs), so existing firms face the constant threat of new competitors.
Contestability is about the threat of entry, not the number of firms. Even a monopoly in a perfectly contestable market will behave competitively, because any supernormal profit would attract “hit-and-run” entrants who come in, take the profit and leave at no cost.
Implications of a perfectly contestable market:
- existing firms earn only normal profit in the long run;
- they are pushed towards productive and allocative efficiency;
- they can’t use profits from one market to undercut newcomers in another (no cross-subsidisation);
- the number of firms in the market doesn’t matter.
A good example is budget airlines on short routes: aircraft can be leased and moved to other routes, so the cost of leaving a route is small. Governments use deregulation and privatisation to make markets more contestable.
Answering the Paper 4 essay
Typical questions: “Monopolies restrict output to raise prices to exploit consumers. With the help of a diagram, assess the extent to which a government should intervene in monopoly markets”; “Oligopolies are able to avoid price competition while maintaining supernormal profits in the long run. Evaluate this statement”; or “With the help of a diagram, evaluate the impact on consumers and producers of an increase in market contestability.”
Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:
- Knowledge: define the market structure in the question and its features (number of firms, product type, barriers to entry, price-making power), the profit-maximising rule MC = MR, and productive and allocative efficiency.
- Application: name real markets that fit: a national water company or rail network (monopoly), mobile networks, supermarkets or airlines (oligopoly), cafés and hairdressers (monopolistic competition), and refer to any industry named in the question.
- Analysis: draw the right diagram and explain it step by step: for a monopoly, output where MC = MR, price read off the demand curve above MC, supernormal profit kept in the long run because barriers stop entry, and a deadweight loss compared with perfect competition. For oligopoly, use the kinked demand curve or game theory to explain why firms avoid price wars.
- Evaluation: monopolies can also bring benefits: economies of scale may give lower costs and prices than many small firms could; supernormal profit can fund research (dynamic efficiency); natural monopolies are cheapest with one supplier; and if the market is contestable, the threat of entry keeps prices down. Oligopolists often do compete, through non-price competition or occasional price wars, and collusion tends to break down or be illegal. Intervention can also fail.
- Conclusion: reach a clear judgement: for example, intervention is justified when barriers are high and the monopoly is abusing its power, but regulating prices or increasing contestability is usually better than breaking up a firm whose size gives real cost savings.
Always say which structure you are drawing and label the diagram fully (AR, MR, MC, AC, the price, the output and the profit area). Most marks for analysis come from explaining the diagram in words, not just drawing it.
Check yourself
A firm in perfect competition faces a price below its average variable cost. What should it do in the short run, and why?
Shut down. At that price it can’t even cover its variable costs, so producing would lose more than its fixed costs. Shutting down limits the loss to its fixed costs.
Why does a firm in monopolistic competition make only normal profit in the long run?
Barriers to entry are low, so short-run supernormal profit attracts new firms. Each existing firm loses customers, its demand curve shifts left until it just touches ATC, and price = average cost.
The 4-firm concentration ratio rises from 40% to 65%. What does this suggest?
The market has become much more concentrated and is now highly oligopolistic. The biggest four firms control almost two-thirds of the market.
According to the kinked demand curve model, how will rivals react to a price cut and to a price rise?
They will match a price cut, so the firm gains few customers, but ignore a price rise, so the firm loses many customers. This keeps prices stable.
Why do cartels often break down?
Each member can earn more by secretly cutting its price or raising its output while the others stick to the agreement (the Prisoner’s Dilemma). If members cheat, the agreed price can’t hold.
Now practise it
Try the 148 past paper questions on Different market structures, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.