Marginal costing separates costs into variable costs, which change with output, and fixed costs, which don’t. Every unit sold earns a contribution towards the fixed costs; once they are covered, every further unit adds its contribution to profit. This simple idea answers most short-term decisions: how many units must we sell to break even? Should we accept this order? Should we make this part or buy it? It is the most heavily examined costing topic in Paper 2’s question 4.
Marginal cost: the variable cost of making one more unit (direct materials, direct labour, direct expenses and variable overheads). Contribution: selling price − variable cost (per unit), or revenue − total variable costs (in total).
Contribution per unit = selling price − variable cost per unit
Profit = total contribution − fixed costs
Break-even point (units) = fixed costs ÷ contribution per unit
Contribution to sales (C/S) ratio = contribution ÷ selling price (or total contribution ÷ revenue)
Break-even revenue = fixed costs ÷ C/S ratio
Units for a target profit = (fixed costs + target profit) ÷ contribution per unit
Margin of safety = budgeted (or actual) output − break-even output (in units, in $, or as a % of budgeted output)
Break-even analysis: worked example
Toro Ltd makes one product, selling at $40. Variable costs per unit: direct materials $12, direct labour $8, variable overheads $4. Fixed costs are $48,000 a month (fixed production overheads $30,000; selling and administration $18,000). Budgeted sales are 4,000 units a month.
- Variable cost = 12 + 8 + 4 = $24; contribution = 40 − 24 = $16 per unit.
- Break-even point = 48,000 ÷ 16 = 3,000 units; break-even revenue = 3,000 × $40 = $120,000.
- C/S ratio = 16 ÷ 40 = 0.4; check: 48,000 ÷ 0.4 = $120,000. ✓
- Budgeted profit = 4,000 × 16 − 48,000 = $16,000.
- Margin of safety = 4,000 − 3,000 = 1,000 units ($40,000 of revenue, or 1,000 ÷ 4,000 = 25%): sales could fall by a quarter before Toro makes a loss.
- Units needed for a profit of $24,000 = (48,000 + 24,000) ÷ 16 = 4,500 units.
Interpreting a break-even chart
You won’t be asked to draw one, but you may have to read one or explain what it shows.
- The fixed cost line is horizontal at $48,000: these costs are paid even at zero output.
- The total cost line starts at $48,000 (fixed costs) and rises by the variable cost of each unit.
- The revenue line starts at zero and rises more steeply, because each unit sells for more than its variable cost.
- Where they cross is the break-even point: 3,000 units and $120,000. To the left, total cost is above revenue (the loss area); to the right, revenue is above total cost (the profit area). The vertical gap between the lines at any output is the profit or loss.
- The distance from the break-even point to budgeted output is the margin of safety.
- A higher selling price makes the revenue line steeper and moves the break-even point left; higher fixed or variable costs move it right.
Limitations of break-even analysis: it assumes the selling price and variable cost per unit are the same at every output (no bulk discounts, no price cuts to sell more); that fixed costs never change (they may step up); that everything made is sold; and that there is one product (or a constant sales mix). Figures are forecasts. It is still a quick, clear guide to risk and to the effect of changing prices or costs.
Marginal and absorption costing profit statements
Under marginal costing, inventory is valued at variable cost only and all fixed costs are charged in the period they arise. Under absorption costing, inventory also carries a share of fixed production overheads (see absorption costing). When inventory levels change, the two methods report different profits.
In March Toro made 5,000 units (its normal output, used to set the absorption rate) and sold 4,000. There was no opening inventory. Fixed production overhead absorption rate = 30,000 ÷ 5,000 = $6 per unit, so full production cost = 24 + 6 = $30 per unit.
| Marginal costing statement for March | $ | $ |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue (4,000 × $40) | 160 000 | |
| Variable cost of production (5,000 × $24) | 120 000 | |
| Less closing inventory (1,000 × $24) | (24 000) | |
| Variable cost of sales | (96 000) | |
| Contribution | 64 000 | |
| Fixed production overheads | 30 000 | |
| Fixed selling and administration | 18 000 | (48 000) |
| Profit | 16 000 |
| Absorption costing statement for March | $ | $ |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue (4,000 × $40) | 160 000 | |
| Cost of production (5,000 × $30) | 150 000 | |
| Less closing inventory (1,000 × $30) | (30 000) | |
| Cost of sales | (120 000) | |
| Gross profit | 40 000 | |
| Selling and administration | (18 000) | |
| Profit | 22 000 |
| Reconciliation of the profits | $ |
|---|---|
| Profit under absorption costing | 22 000 |
| Less fixed overheads carried forward in the increase in inventory (1,000 × $6) | (6 000) |
| Profit under marginal costing | 16 000 |
The difference is always the change in inventory × the fixed overhead absorbed per unit. When inventory rises, absorption costing shows the higher profit (some fixed costs are carried forward to next month in the inventory); when inventory falls, marginal costing shows the higher profit; when they are equal, profits are the same. (Here production equalled normal output, so there was no under- or over-absorption to adjust for.)
Using contribution for decisions
- Identify the costs and revenues that change because of the decision. Fixed costs that will be paid anyway are not relevant, even if a full-cost figure includes them.
- Compare the extra contribution with any extra fixed costs.
- Make the decision that gives the higher total profit — then check the non-financial factors.
Special order. Toro normally sells 4,000 units a month and has capacity for 5,500. A new customer offers to buy 800 units at $30 each — no more than the full production cost of $30, before any selling costs — with delivery costing Toro an extra $1,000. Extra contribution = 800 × (30 − 24) = 4,800, less 1,000 = +$3,800. Fixed costs don’t change, so profit rises by $3,800: accept, provided there is spare capacity (4,800 units in total is within 5,500), regular customers won’t find out and demand the lower price, and the price covers variable costs.
Make or buy. Toro makes a handle for each product: variable cost $9 (materials $5, labour $3, variable overhead $1) plus $4 of absorbed fixed overhead, a full cost of $13. A supplier offers handles at $11. The fixed overheads would still be paid, so the relevant comparison is $9 to make against $11 to buy: making saves $2 a handle, $8,000 a month on 4,000 handles. Keep making — unless the freed capacity could earn more than $8,000 of contribution in some other way, or the supplier’s quality or reliability is much better.
Closing a business unit. Delta Stores has three departments. Fixed costs of $78,000 are shared out in proportion to revenue.
| Delta Stores: results by department | A $ | B $ | C $ | Total $ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 120 000 | 90 000 | 50 000 | 260 000 |
| Variable costs | (66 000) | (54 000) | (38 000) | (158 000) |
| Contribution | 54 000 | 36 000 | 12 000 | 102 000 |
| Fixed costs apportioned | (36 000) | (27 000) | (15 000) | (78 000) |
| Profit (loss) | 18 000 | 9 000 | (3 000) | 24 000 |
Department C appears to lose $3,000. But its $15,000 share of the fixed costs would still be paid if it closed. Closing C would lose its $12,000 contribution, so total profit would fall from $24,000 to $12,000. Keep C open while it makes a positive contribution — unless some fixed costs would be saved by closing it (and the saving is more than $12,000), or the space could be used for something more profitable.
Limiting factor. Vela Ltd makes X and Y. Material is limited to 9,000 kg a month. Fixed costs are $40,000.
| X | Y | |
|---|---|---|
| Selling price | $50 | $45 |
| Variable cost | $30 | $27 |
| Contribution per unit | $20 | $18 |
| Material per unit | 4 kg | 2 kg |
| Contribution per kg | $5.00 | $9.00 |
| Ranking | 2nd | 1st |
| Maximum demand | 1,500 units | 2,000 units |
X has the higher contribution per unit, but material is the scarce resource, so rank by contribution per kg. Make all 2,000 Y first (4,000 kg), then use the remaining 5,000 kg for 5,000 ÷ 4 = 1,250 X. Contribution = 2,000 × 18 + 1,250 × 20 = 36,000 + 25,000 = $61,000; profit = 61,000 − 40,000 = $21,000. Making all 1,500 X first would give only $57,000 of contribution.
Non-financial factors in every decision: the reaction of regular customers (special orders at low prices), quality and reliability of a supplier (make or buy), job losses, staff morale and the business’s reputation (closure), customer goodwill if one product is not supplied (limiting factor), and whether the figures are reliable estimates.
Uses and limitations of marginal costing
| Uses and advantages | Limitations |
|---|---|
| Shows clearly how profit changes with output; essential for short-term decisions | Not acceptable for inventory in the financial statements (IAS 2 requires production overheads to be included) |
| Profit is not affected by changes in inventory, so it can’t be increased just by producing more | Prices based on contribution may not cover fixed costs in the long run |
| No arbitrary apportionment of fixed costs | Splitting semi-variable costs into fixed and variable parts may be difficult |
| Break-even and margin of safety are easy to calculate | Assumes costs and prices behave in a straight line |
Answering the Paper 1 and 2 questions
Typical questions: “Calculate the break-even point in units and in revenue”; “Calculate the margin of safety”; “Prepare statements showing the profit using marginal costing and absorption costing, and reconcile them”; “Advise the directors whether to accept the special order”; or “Calculate the production plan which maximises profit.”
Paper 1 has 30 multiple-choice questions: work each one out on paper before you look at the options, because the wrong options are the answers you get from the common mistakes. Paper 2 has four structured questions (30, 15, 15 and 30 marks): you prepare accounts and calculations, then explain, discuss or advise. The written parts are marked on knowledge, analysis and evaluation. Plan every “discuss”, “advise” or “evaluate” answer in the same five steps, in this order:
- Knowledge: define contribution, break-even point, margin of safety and the limiting factor, and state which costs are relevant.
- Application: calculate the figures for the decision: the extra contribution, the break-even point, the ranking per unit of the limiting factor.
- Analysis: explain the result: for example, department C covers its variable costs and contributes $12,000 to fixed costs that would be paid anyway, so closing it would cut profit by $12,000.
- Evaluation: weigh the figures against the assumptions (constant prices and costs, spare capacity) and the non-financial factors (customers, staff, suppliers, reputation).
- Conclusion: give a clear, justified decision, for example: Toro should accept the special order, because it adds $3,800 of profit using spare capacity — provided regular customers are not offered the same price.
Check yourself
Selling price $25; variable cost $15; fixed costs $30,000. Calculate the break-even point in units and revenue.
Contribution $10; 3,000 units; $75,000.
Using the same figures, budgeted sales are 4,000 units. What is the margin of safety as a percentage?
1,000 ÷ 4,000 = 25%.
How many units are needed for a profit of $20,000?
(30,000 + 20,000) ÷ 10 = 5,000 units.
Production 6,000 units, sales 5,000; fixed production overhead absorbed at $4 per unit; no opening inventory. Which method shows the higher profit, and by how much?
Absorption costing, by 1,000 × $4 = $4,000.
A product earns $6 contribution and uses 3 machine hours; another earns $5 and uses 2 hours. Machine hours are limited. Which should be made first?
The second: $2.50 per hour against $2.00 per hour.
Now practise it
Try the 191 past paper questions on Marginal costing, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.