Where a business operates and how big it grows both have a lasting effect on its costs, its access to customers and its ability to compete. This chapter covers location decisions, from choosing a site in a town to moving production to another continent, and the economies and diseconomies that come with scale. Paper 3 often combines a location choice with an investment appraisal calculation.
Factors in location and relocation
Quantitative factors (can be measured in money)
- Costs: land, rent and building costs; labour costs; transport costs for materials and finished goods; energy and utilities; local taxes.
- Revenue: how close the site is to customers, and how many customers it can reach (crucial for shops, restaurants and service businesses).
- Government help: grants, tax breaks and subsidies to locate in particular areas.
- Investment appraisal of each option, using payback, ARR or NPV (see investment appraisal), to compare their expected returns.
Qualitative factors (harder to measure)
- Availability of skilled labour; quality of infrastructure (roads, ports, internet).
- Room for future expansion; quality of life for managers and staff.
- Planning restrictions and local opposition; environmental impact.
- Political stability, corruption and legal systems (especially abroad).
- The owner’s preferences; the image of the area (a fashion brand in a prestigious street).
Relocation brings extra costs: moving equipment, redundancy payments for staff who won’t move, recruitment and training at the new site, disruption to production, and possible loss of customers and reputation in the old area.
Local, national and international location
- Local decisions (which site within a town) focus on customer footfall, rent, parking, competition nearby and planning permission.
- National decisions (which region of a country) focus on labour availability and wages, transport links, government regional grants and closeness to markets and suppliers.
- International decisions add: labour and land costs in other countries, access to new markets, avoiding trade barriers (producing inside a trading bloc avoids its external tariff), exchange rate risk, cultural and language differences, legal and ethical standards, and political risk.
Offshoring and reshoring
Offshoring: moving a business activity, such as manufacturing or customer service, to another country, usually to cut costs.
Reshoring: bringing previously offshored activities back to the home country.
Reasons to offshore: lower labour and production costs, access to skills or resources, being nearer to new markets, and round-the-clock operations across time zones. Impact: lower costs, but long supply chains, possible quality and communication problems, job losses at home and reputational risk if conditions in overseas factories are poor.
Reasons to reshore: rising wages abroad, high transport costs, supply chain disruption (such as during the pandemic), quality problems, the value customers place on “made at home”, faster response to customers, and government incentives.
Globalisation and location
Globalisation (freer trade, cheaper transport and communications, more open capital markets) has made it much easier to locate each activity wherever it is cheapest or most effective: design in one country, components in several others and assembly in another. It also brings more competition, so firms are under pressure to keep reviewing where they operate.
Scale of operations
The scale of a business is the size of its operations. The right scale depends on the business’s objectives (some owners want to stay small), the size of the market, finance available, the type of product (personal services suit small scale; cars and steel need large scale), competition and the economies of scale available.
Economies of scale
Economies of scale: the reductions in average (unit) cost that come from increasing the scale of operations.
| Internal economies (from the firm’s own growth) | Example |
|---|---|
| Purchasing (bulk buying) | Discounts from suppliers for large orders |
| Technical | Large, efficient machinery that is only worth buying at high output |
| Financial | Lower interest rates and easier access to finance for large, secure firms |
| Marketing | Advertising cost spread over many more units |
| Managerial | Specialist managers for each function, improving efficiency |
External economies of scale come from the growth of the whole industry in an area: a pool of skilled workers, specialist suppliers and services nearby, shared infrastructure and research, and a reputation for the area (a technology cluster or a textile region). They lower costs for every firm there.
Diseconomies of scale
Diseconomies of scale: the increases in average cost that occur when a business grows beyond its most efficient size.
- Communication problems: more levels of hierarchy and more people make messages slower and less accurate.
- Coordination and control problems: harder to make many departments and sites work together.
- Motivation: workers in large organisations may feel unimportant and less involved.
- External diseconomies: when too many firms crowd into an area, land prices, wages and congestion rise.
The link to unit costs: economies of scale explain why big firms can often charge lower prices; diseconomies explain why growth can raise costs and why some businesses deliberately decentralise or split into smaller units to keep the benefits of being small.
Answering the Paper 3 and 4 questions
Typical questions: “Calculate the ARR for location X. Evaluate which location OV should choose to build its factory”; “Evaluate whether TC should build the new factory in country M”; “Analyse two benefits to CD resulting from internal economies of scale”; or “Analyse two possible effects on WCP’s efficiency of an increase in its scale of operations.”
Papers 3 and 4 mark long answers on knowledge, application, analysis and evaluation, and “Analyse” questions stop before evaluation. Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order:
- Knowledge: define the terms: quantitative and qualitative location factors, offshoring, reshoring, internal and external economies of scale, diseconomies of scale.
- Application: use the case data for each option: costs, revenue forecasts, investment appraisal results, labour, infrastructure, distance from customers and suppliers.
- Analysis: explain how each factor affects costs, revenue and profit: for example, the cheaper site in country M lowers labour costs, but higher transport costs to the main market reduce the saving and lengthen delivery times.
- Evaluation: weigh quantitative results against qualitative factors; consider the reliability of the forecasts, risks (political, exchange rate, reputation), the business’s objectives and whether the decision can be reversed.
- Conclusion: make a justified recommendation, for example: location X is the better choice despite its lower ARR, because its skilled workforce and stable government reduce the risk to quality and supply.
Check yourself
Give two quantitative and two qualitative factors in a location decision.
Quantitative (any two): land or rent costs; labour costs; transport costs; government grants; expected revenue. Qualitative (any two): skilled labour; infrastructure; room to expand; quality of life; planning rules; political stability.
What is reshoring, and why might a business do it?
Bringing offshored activities back home, because of rising costs abroad, supply chain risks, quality problems, faster response to customers or customer preference for home-produced goods.
Explain the difference between internal and external economies of scale.
Internal economies come from the growth of the firm itself (bulk buying, technical, financial); external economies come from the growth of the industry in an area (skilled labour pool, specialist suppliers).
Give two causes of diseconomies of scale.
Any two of: poor communication; coordination and control problems; low motivation in a large organisation; congestion and rising costs in a crowded area.
Why do economies of scale matter to competitiveness?
They lower unit costs, so a large firm can charge lower prices or earn higher margins than smaller rivals.
Now practise it
Try the 8 past paper questions on Location and scale, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.