Quality is not about luxury: a cheap product can be high quality if it does exactly what its buyers expect. This chapter covers why quality matters and the three approaches to managing it, quality control, quality assurance and Total Quality Management, plus benchmarking. Paper 3 regularly asks about the benefits or problems of quality assurance and TQM.
What quality means
Quality: meeting or exceeding customers’ expectations; a product or service that is “fit for purpose” and consistently does what customers want at a price they are willing to pay.
Customers’ expectations depend on the price and the market: a budget airline is high quality if it is safe, punctual and cheap; a luxury hotel must also deliver comfort and service. In operations management, quality means consistently meeting the standards set, without defects.
Why quality matters
- Builds reputation and brand loyalty, bringing repeat customers and recommendations.
- Allows a higher price and better margins.
- Reduces costs of waste, reworking, returns, refunds and complaints.
- Avoids the huge costs of product recalls, legal action and damaged reputation.
- Helps win contracts with large customers who demand certified standards.
- Gives a competitive advantage in markets where products are otherwise similar.
Quality control and quality assurance
| Quality control | Quality assurance | |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Checking products, usually at the end of production, to find and remove defects | Building quality into every stage of production so that defects are prevented in the first place |
| Who is responsible | Specialist inspectors | Every employee checks their own work against agreed standards |
| Advantages | Faulty products are stopped before reaching customers; simple to organise | Fewer defects and less waste; lower costs in the long run; staff responsibility can motivate; often certified to recognised standards that impress customers |
| Disadvantages | Finds faults after resources have been wasted; inspectors cost money; workers may not take responsibility for quality | Needs training and commitment from all staff; takes time to set up; certification can be bureaucratic and costly |
Don’t mix them up. Quality control detects faults after they happen; quality assurance prevents them by checking processes throughout.
Total Quality Management (TQM)
Total Quality Management (TQM): an approach in which quality is the responsibility of every employee in every part of the business, with the aim of continuously improving quality to satisfy customers, both external customers and the “internal customers” who receive each person’s work.
TQM features: a culture of quality led from the top; every worker and department responsible for quality; the idea that each stage serves the next as its internal customer; continuous improvement; teamwork and staff involvement; and decisions based on data.
| Impact: benefits | Impact: problems |
|---|---|
| Fewer defects, less waste and rework, so lower costs | High training costs and time to change the culture |
| Better reputation, customer satisfaction and loyalty | Needs full commitment from managers and staff; resistance if seen as extra work |
| Motivates staff through responsibility and teamwork | Benefits are long-term and hard to measure, so it may be abandoned early |
| Supports lean production and efficiency | Can become bureaucratic, with too much focus on procedures |
Whether TQM is the best way to solve a quality problem depends on the cause: if complaints come from one faulty machine or a supplier’s poor materials, a targeted fix may be quicker and cheaper; if they come from a culture of carelessness across the business, TQM addresses the root cause.
Benchmarking
Benchmarking: comparing a business’s products, processes or performance with those of the best businesses (in its industry or others) and using the comparison to set standards and improve.
The process: decide what to benchmark (delivery times, defect rates, customer satisfaction) → identify the best performers → collect and compare data → find out how they achieve better results → set targets and make improvements → review.
Importance in quality management: it shows how far behind the best the business is, sets realistic targets based on what others achieve, and spreads good ideas. Limitations: data from competitors can be hard to obtain; copying others doesn’t create a lead over them; and methods may not transfer to a different business or culture.
Answering the Paper 3 and 4 questions
Typical questions: “Analyse two benefits to PPP of using quality assurance”; “Evaluate whether TQM is the best way to solve the problem of AFF’s customer complaints”; “Evaluate the extent to which implementing TQM might reduce costs for TC”; or “Analyse two problems SF may experience when implementing TQM.” Some questions start with a calculation, such as the percentage of output failing quality standards.
Papers 3 and 4 mark long answers on knowledge, application, analysis and evaluation, and “Analyse” questions stop before evaluation. Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order:
- Knowledge: define quality, quality control, quality assurance, TQM and benchmarking precisely.
- Application: use the case: the type of product or service, the quality problems described (complaints, reject rates, returns), the workforce and the business’s finances.
- Analysis: build chains: for example, TQM makes each worker responsible for quality, so defects are prevented rather than found at the end, reducing waste and rework, so unit costs fall.
- Evaluation: consider the cause of the quality problem, the cost and time to implement, staff attitudes and training needs, how quickly benefits appear, and alternatives (better quality control, new suppliers, new equipment).
- Conclusion: make a justified judgement, for example: TQM is the best long-term solution because the complaints come from careless work across several departments, but the business also needs immediate checks to stop faulty products reaching customers while the culture changes.
Check yourself
What is the difference between quality control and quality assurance?
Quality control inspects finished products to find defects; quality assurance builds quality checks into every stage to prevent defects.
What is an internal customer in TQM?
The person or department within the business who receives the output of another stage of work.
Give three reasons why quality is important to a business.
Any three of: reputation and loyalty; higher prices; lower waste and returns costs; avoiding recalls and legal action; winning contracts; competitive advantage.
Give two problems of introducing TQM.
Any two of: training costs; time to change culture; needs commitment from everyone; staff resistance; slow, hard-to-measure benefits; bureaucracy.
What is benchmarking?
Comparing performance or processes with the best businesses and using the comparison to set standards and improve.
Now practise it
Try the 12 past paper questions on Quality management, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.