The standard theory assumes every firm wants maximum profit. This topic asks whether that is realistic, what else firms might aim for, and how the aim changes the price they charge and the output they produce. It also covers the pricing tactics firms with market power use: price discrimination, limit pricing, predatory pricing and price leadership. All of these are regular Paper 4 essay topics.
Profit maximisation
Profit maximisation: producing the output where the gap between total revenue and total cost is as large as possible. This happens where marginal cost = marginal revenue (MC = MR).
Why MC = MR? Think about the next unit:
- If MR > MC, the next unit adds more to revenue than to cost, so producing it raises profit. Keep expanding.
- If MC > MR, the last unit added more to cost than to revenue, so it reduced profit. Cut back.
- Only when MC = MR can no change in output increase profit.
Profit maximisation is the standard assumption because it is what owners want, and because in competitive markets firms that don’t make enough profit are eventually forced out.
Why firms might not maximise profit
- They don’t know their MC and MR. In practice many firms use simple cost-plus pricing: work out average cost and add a standard percentage. That is unlikely to hit exactly MC = MR.
- Long-term thinking. Very high short-run profits can attract new competitors, or the attention of competition authorities.
- Stakeholders. Huge profits can anger customers and workers, who expect lower prices or higher pay.
- The principal–agent problem. In large companies, managers (who run the firm) may have different goals from shareholders (who own it). See growth and survival of firms.
Other objectives
Survival
When a firm faces a sudden shock, such as a recession, a pandemic, losing its biggest customer or a powerful new rival, its main aim may simply be to survive by minimising its losses. It can carry on making a loss in the short run as long as its revenue covers its variable costs; if it can’t even do that, closing down is the better option.
Profit satisficing
Profit satisficing: aiming for a satisfactory level of profit, enough to keep shareholders happy, rather than the maximum.
A firm is made up of groups with different aims: shareholders want profit, workers want good pay and conditions, managers want status and a quiet life, customers want low prices. Satisficing is a compromise between them. It is most likely when managers, not owners, run the firm, and in firms that have dominated their market for a long time and have become comfortable.
Revenue maximisation
Revenue maximisation: producing the output where total revenue is as high as possible. This is where MR = 0.
Managers may prefer this because their salaries and bonuses are often linked to sales revenue, and revenue is easier to measure and report than profit. Because the firm keeps producing while each unit adds any revenue, even when MC > MR, it produces more and charges a lower price than a profit maximiser.
Sales maximisation
Sales maximisation: selling the greatest possible quantity, subject to making at least normal profit. This is where AR = AC.
Selling more units raises the firm’s market share and its managers’ status, and can help it gain economies of scale. Any output beyond AR = AC would mean a loss.
Don’t confuse revenue maximisation (the most money from sales: MR = 0) with sales maximisation (the most units sold while covering costs: AR = AC). Sales maximisation gives the larger output.
A past question asked about a firm switching from profit maximisation to sales maximisation because of the principal–agent problem. The diagram above is the answer: output rises from Qπ to QS, price falls, and supernormal profit is reduced to normal profit. Consumers gain from the lower price; shareholders lose.
Cross-subsidisation: a firm with several products can use profits from one to cover losses on another, for example a bus company using profits from busy city routes to keep quiet rural routes running. This is common in state-owned firms, which may have social objectives such as keeping prices low or providing a service everywhere.
Price discrimination
Price discrimination: charging different prices to different customers for the same product, where the price difference is not due to a difference in cost.
A higher price for a bigger hotel room is not price discrimination (it costs more to provide). A cheaper cinema ticket for students for the same film in the same seat is.
Conditions needed
- Price-making power. The firm must face a downward-sloping demand curve, so it can’t be in perfect competition.
- Separate markets with different PEDs. The firm must be able to split customers into groups whose demand differs in its price elasticity, for example by age, time, location or how early they book.
- No resale. Customers who pay the low price must not be able to sell the product on to those charged the high price. This is why it works best for services (a haircut, a train journey, a concert), which can’t be resold, and why tickets often carry the buyer’s name.
- Separating the markets must cost less than the extra profit it brings.
The three degrees
- First degree (perfect): each customer is charged the most they are willing to pay. The firm takes all the consumer surplus. In practice it is rare, but it is approached in negotiated sales (cars, houses, some professional services) and in online pricing that uses personal data.
- Second degree: the price depends on the quantity bought: lower prices for bulk purchases or for extra units, such as “buy two, get the third half price”, cheaper per-unit prices on bigger phone data plans, or season tickets.
- Third degree: different prices for different groups of customers: student and senior discounts, peak and off-peak train fares, cheaper air fares booked months ahead, different prices in different countries.
How third-degree discrimination works
The rule is simple: charge a higher price where demand is inelastic, and a lower price where demand is elastic. Business travellers must travel at a particular time and the company pays, so their demand is inelastic; students and pensioners can choose when to travel and are more price-sensitive.
Consequences
For the firm: higher revenue and profit, because it captures some consumer surplus.
For consumers, it is mixed:
- Customers in the inelastic market pay more and lose consumer surplus.
- Customers in the elastic market pay less, and some may be able to buy for the first time.
- Output often rises. Under first-degree discrimination the firm keeps selling until price equals MC on the last unit, which is the allocatively efficient output, though all the gain goes to the firm.
- It can make a service possible that otherwise couldn’t exist. Suppose a bus trip costs $120 to run. Four business travellers would pay $20 and ten pensioners would pay $6. A single price of $20 brings in only $80; a single price of $6 brings in $84. Both lose money, so the bus wouldn’t run. Charging each group its own price brings in 4 × 20 + 10 × 6 = $140: the bus runs, and the pensioners can travel.
- Extra profit could fund investment and new products, or simply go to shareholders.
- Many people see it as unfair when a customer pays more simply because they need the product more.
Other pricing policies
Limit pricing
Limit pricing: an established firm sets its price low enough to discourage new firms from entering, usually at about the level where a new entrant, with its higher start-up costs, couldn’t make a profit.
The firm gives up some short-run profit to protect its long-run position. It works best when the established firm has lower costs than any newcomer (for example from economies of scale). Consumers benefit from lower prices in the short run, but the low price acts as a barrier to entry, so in the long run there may be less competition and choice than there would otherwise have been.
Predatory pricing
Predatory pricing: deliberately setting a price below cost to force a rival out of the market, intending to raise prices again once it has gone.
The predator needs deep pockets to survive its own losses longer than the rival. Consumers gain while the price war lasts, but lose afterwards when prices go back up and there is less competition. It is illegal in many countries as an abuse of market power, but it is hard to prove: authorities have to show the price is below cost and intended to remove a rival, not just fierce competition.
| Limit pricing | Predatory pricing | |
|---|---|---|
| Aim | Stop new firms entering | Force an existing rival to leave |
| Price | Low, but usually still covering costs | Below cost: the predator makes a loss for a while |
| Legal? | Usually legal | Usually illegal |
Price leadership
Price leadership: one firm in an oligopoly, usually the largest or the brand leader, sets its price and the other firms follow.
It is common in markets like fuel retailing. It lets firms avoid a damaging price war without any formal (illegal) agreement: it is a form of tacit collusion. The firms then compete in other ways, such as advertising, loyalty schemes and quality. Smaller firms with higher costs may struggle if the leader cuts its price, because they have to follow to keep their customers.
Price elasticity of demand and revenue
Whether a price change raises or lowers revenue depends on PED:
| PED | MR | Price cut | Price rise |
|---|---|---|---|
| Elastic (> 1) | Positive | Revenue rises | Revenue falls |
| Unit elastic (= 1) | Zero | Revenue is at its maximum and doesn’t change | |
| Inelastic (< 1) | Negative | Revenue falls | Revenue rises |
On a straight-line demand curve, demand is elastic in the top half and inelastic in the bottom half, with PED = 1 at the midpoint, where MR = 0. So a profit-maximising firm always produces on the elastic part of its demand curve: MC is positive, so MC = MR needs MR to be positive. (The revenue diagram is in costs, revenue and profit.)
The kinked demand curve
An oligopolist expects rivals to react differently to a price rise and a price cut:
This explains why prices in some oligopolies stay the same for long periods, even when costs change. Its weakness is that it doesn’t explain how the price at the kink was set in the first place. There is more on oligopoly in market structures.
Answering the Paper 4 essay
Typical questions: “Consider whether a firm’s best interest is always served by maximising profits”; “Evaluate the consequences for price and output if a firm changes its objective from profit maximisation to sales maximisation”; “Limit pricing benefits consumers in the short run but harms them in the long run. Discuss.”
Plan every long answer in the same five steps, in this order. They match how long answers are marked:
- Knowledge: define profit maximisation (MC = MR) and the alternatives: survival, satisficing, revenue maximisation (MR = 0) and sales maximisation (AR = AC). For pricing questions, define the policy precisely (for example, limit pricing versus predatory pricing).
- Application: apply it to real firms: large public companies run by salaried managers (principal–agent problem), firms fighting to survive a recession, a dominant supermarket or airline using low prices to keep newcomers out.
- Analysis: draw the objectives diagram and explain the chain: moving from Qπ to QR or QS means more output and a lower price, but less profit. For limit pricing, explain how a low price removes the profit a new entrant could hope for, so it acts as a barrier to entry.
- Evaluation: in competitive markets firms that don’t maximise profit may not survive, so other objectives are only possible where firms have market power; owners can push managers back towards profit through bonuses and the threat of takeover; and in the long run pursuing market share or deterring entrants may actually be the way to maximise profit. For pricing policies, compare the short run and the long run, different groups of consumers, and whether the policy is legal.
- Conclusion: answer the exact question: for example, profit maximisation is a sensible long-run aim, but a firm’s best interest at a particular time may be survival, growth or deterring entry, depending on its market power and who controls it.
Check yourself
A firm’s MR is $8 and its MC is $5 at its current output. What should a profit maximiser do?
Increase output. The next unit adds $8 to revenue but only $5 to cost, so profit rises. It should keep expanding until MC = MR.
Where does a revenue-maximising firm produce, and what is PED at that point?
Where MR = 0. On a straight-line demand curve this is the midpoint, where PED is unitary (= 1).
Total cost and total revenue are equal at 40 units, and the firm chooses to produce 40 units. What is its objective?
Sales maximisation: it is selling the largest quantity it can while still covering its costs (AR = AC, normal profit only).
Why must a firm be able to prevent resale to practise price discrimination?
Otherwise customers who buy at the low price could resell to those being charged the high price, and the high-price market would disappear.
What is the difference between limit pricing and predatory pricing?
Limit pricing sets a low price to stop new firms entering, usually still covering costs. Predatory pricing sets a price below cost to drive an existing rival out, then raises it again.
Now practise it
Try the 48 past paper questions on Differing objectives and policies of firms, with mark schemes. Start with the most recent ones; if one goes wrong, come back to the section above that covers it.
Practise Differing objectives and policies of firms questions →